36 Best Bakeries near West Henrietta

“I asked a Comic Heroes cake to Michelle 2 days before my son's 5th birthday, it took me no more than 20 mins to explain to her through messenger how I wanted the cake and she did the exact idea (physically even better) on what I had in mind. And the flavor was more than amazing, delicious!.I will recommend her a 100%. She is fair, great, honest, punctual and great!.“

“the best doughnuts danish soup hot dog pretzels soooo glad your back my wife got me doughnuts“

“Best Greek food I've ever eaten“

“I stopped in today with a friend to get a few random goodies to take home. (I will confess… I know the owner so I already knew it was going to be tasty.) But WOOOOW! Above and beyond! I don’t even know what this is but it FABULOUS!!!! I’m beyond impressed!! Lucas… you are AWESOME and so is whoever you have helping you make this food!!! Side note, it’s lovely inside, SO CLEAN and the staff was very friendly 🙂 I also included a screenshot of my friends texts… she ate her cookie and then got into the cake she bought for her Father 😂 Loved it… I will def be back! For the delicious food and to visit the outstanding man behind the scenes. Well done!“

“Just stopped by here today and grabbed two loaves of focaccia. Not exaggerating, this is the BEST bread I’ve had in my life. Do yourself a favor and stop by here as soon as you can to grab some delicious home made bread. They also have a variety of local items as well and I picked up some dog treats and pies from crust.“

“Absolutely amazing bakery! I'd been meaning to stop by myself after receiving some of the small cheesecakes as a gift and they did not disappoint! The staff is extremely friendly, and it seems like everyone knows each other there which is so sweet.

Their cheesecakes are to die for, they're not overly sweet. The carrot cakes as well stayed moist and delicious. Absolutely will be going here for birthday needs 💜“

“This love story began 20 years ago 😆 in the artsy Southwedge part of Rochester, NY!
It’s like it melts in your mouth, easily in the top 3 of all things cheesecake. I’m serious folks.
You have to try it, just go lay your eyes on it. Looking away is impossible, after just one bite you’re hooked…my mother seconds this❤️“

“Best chocolate babka ever. They do a wonderful job catering too. We used them for my son’s post-wedding breakfast and we heard nothing but great things about the food!“

“Jenny's quickly became a regular Saturday morning treat for my fiance and I. The staff have always been very kind, and I think they've started recognizing us ar regulars, which is always fun. The drinks are so tasty, it's one of the two best chai lattes in the Rochester area in my opinion! My fiance adores the melon breads and we both enjoy the beef sausage bread. The croffles are also to die for! Definitely worth the trip.“

“I seriously can’t recommend Savoia’s enough! Everything was so delicious and carefully package for my wedding. Everyone is so kind & beyond helpful when planning for your event. Everyone raved how delicious the desserts were. I now found my new favorite spot to get my sweets from!“

“Scratch has made quite a few different desserts for my family and they have gone above and beyond expectation every time. Just when you think their cakes are the best you’ve ever had, their cookies and fresh doughnuts enter the arena too. 🤣 I cannot stress enough about how great their treats and staff are. ❤️“

“Best cheesecake I’ve ever had in my life it is so so soooooooo good it is almost orgasmic, just thinking about it I am drooling 🤤 a mist try if you are a cheesecake fan ! Also tried the banana bread it is really yummy and those ginger turmeric bar are also really yummy. The bread is different a little like a pumpernickel I really liked it ! Love this place it’s one of the hidden gems of ROC glad we tried it ❤️“

“Always very good. Cookies are warm and large when picked up. ( only had one cookie that was cold. Totally worth the money. Cute boxes too!“

“From time to time work brings me into Rochester. During a trip my co-worker brought me to Georgie’s for an amazing Cubano w/chicharrones. I enjoyed the food and chats with Georgie. Stand-up guy with an amazing café. So glad to see him and his family putting amazing food out after all of these years. You will not be disappointed!“

“We had a friend introduce us to this bakery a month ago as we we're searching for a good gluten free bakery to get some deserts for our daughter's graduation party. I stopped in a few days prior to the party and picked up a variety of items, their assorted mini cookie tray, a few of their frosted cookies and a variety box of cupcakes. All of our gluten free guests LOVED the options and devoured the sweets pretty quickly. My daughter's favorite is the Carrot Cake cupcake. We will definitely be making more visits, especially before our daughter leaves for college.“

“The Cake Place was absolutely amazing for my wedding. The communication was amazing since my original email. She was so prompt and responsive the entire way. Setting up a tasting was so easy. The cake and the frosting options tasted absolutely amazing. The wedding day - the cake was beautiful and exactly what I wanted. And it tasted just as amazing. 10/10 recommend!!“

“The thanksgiving pie was AMAZING.“

“The absolute best customer service you could ask for! Kellie was amazing to work with, so kind and responsive. I wouldn't order my cakes from anywhere else!“

“I’m not a cake person at all first time having this cake was at a graduation , now I’m Hooked and now I have my co workers hooked . This definitely will be are weekly fix. All Flavors are too die for, and the frosting is amazing . Store was clean costumer service is A+ as well.“

“Erin went absolutely above and beyond with our cookies and cherry cheesecake for our wedding! She was so easy to work with for our out of town wedding. We consider ourselves cheesecake connoisseurs, and that was far and away the best cheesecake we have ever had in our lives. My husband arrived 20 minutes early to pick everything up, and Erin had everything ready and waiting, and helped carry everything across the street and loaded it into the car. Please go see Erin at Vanilla Lane, she is wonderful!“

“carbo heaven. wonderful sweet and savory items. i'm thrilled that we're past winter farmer's market. Crust's items are divine!“

“This woman is Amazing in the cake she made me for my New Year’s Eve reception. She . I sent her a picture and she made me a cake 🎂 of my dream. I literally screamed in excitement when I picked it up. She went way beyond the call of duty. Making me a custom base that lights. She worked in my budget and everyone at my reception loved it so much because how unique it was and wanted her into to order!!!“

“Cute little Macaron shop! Great flavor choices“

“just bought a birthday cake for my boss and she loved it. vanilla & strawberry cake was moist & soft, with amazing taste. the fruits were extremely fresh, not overwhelming with sweetness. the cake was perfect , definitely recommend. the owner is very nice! nd the prices are reasonable! #tutifrutibakery for the win! give them a try definitely going bck.“

“I ordered cookies for my daughter in laws baby shower. The cookies were beautiful and delicious. I sent an inspiration picture and our color scheme and designs were perfectly captured. I would definitely order again!“

“Great strombolis; customer service slow to reply when a problem arises (20 weeks in my complaint's case) but they WILL respond to a valid complaint. Patience is definitely a virtue here - I'm thinking they're swamped and/or understaffed (it would explain both their response time AND the mistake that had prompted my complaint).“

“Oh Sunny Six Grain how I love thee.... My favorite bread of theirs, and the breakfast sandwich is so good even my grumpy 15 year old will get up early for one!“

“This was my first time ordering a cake for my dog and it made his 11th birthday so special! We got the 5” single round hound cake. They were very communicative about my order and any questions I had! The ingredients in the cake and the treats are high quality and healthy for dogs. It also looked perfect. My dog couldn’t wait to dig in! He also loves the treats sold there (I got him the birthday ones). There’s also a space in store for all sorts of treats and toys, I will bring him along next time. Thanks for making my dog’s birthday special!“

“For anyone who mourned the loss of those delicious Martusciello rolls and baked goods, great news, the bakery reopened now as Casa Saratoga. The lights were on when I drove by there recently, so I stopped in today to see what was going on. A very friendly woman greeted me and went on to tell me that some of the same people are making many of the same type of rolls and baked goods as they did when the bakery was operating as Martusciello's. And the prices are still very reasonable like they were before. A bag of six delicious Italian sandwich rolls costs just $3. Try getting THAT kind of deal on fresh baked rolls anywhere else, including Wegmans. Seriously, if you've missed those delicious baked goods from Martusciello's, your prayers have been answered. Enjoy, and thanks for reading!“

“Came here yesterday. A nice quiet spot with good snacks. Honestly found the Korean corn dog and mochi donuts a little too oily for my taste, but the texture was great. Also was hoping to get my drink in a can like the photos but I didn't know if I had to ask for that or what but it's alright. But thinking back on it, I think the ube tasted a lot more like taro and those are two different root crops, but don't take my word for it. I'm a taro girl through and through, maybe I just haven't dignified my pallet. I guess what I'm trying to say is I expected a little more. Though it was a nice spot to hangout for a while and read as it wasn't busy.“

“An iconic Little Italy Neighborhood business with delicious bread and sweets!“

“The Yummy Cookie Jar makes fantastic cookies!! And very creative flavors!! I highly recommend!“

“Just had these at the Public Market during the food truck rodeo. Easily the best apple cider donut I’ve ever had. And I lived on an apple farm growing up that made these types of donuts fresh everyday lol. Would highly recommend getting them and eating them hot!“

“This place is amazing! I have been getting bread every now and then from there for a few years and each time, I wish I went more often. There are quite a few different types loaves that rotate for a good variety. I don't usually make reviews but after having some of the cheddar jalapeno loaf (which quickly turned into the entire loaf), it seemed right to give due credit.“

“Super clean, AWESOME service. Great atmosphere.“