Browse menus, reviews and photos of New American Restaurants near West Islip.
Bar & Grill · $$
191 Higbie Lane, West Islip
Customers’ favorites
“Had the best lunch today. Food was amazing but the server was even more amazing. Donna rocked it!!! I will be going back soon!”
Fast Food · $
510 Union Boulevard, West Islip
Customers’ favorites
“Absolutely love their cheese steaks! Service was fast and with a smile....cheese throughout sandwich as it should be...ribeye steak grilled perfectly. Well done!”
New American · $$
149-06 Veterans Memorial Highway, Commack · 9.3 miles
“Came here for their Sunday brunch menu with a friend! Will be coming back. The wings were so delicious and the bistro burger was amazing. Prices make It so you can order quite a few things for a great price. Will be coming back again to try those lemon poppy pancakes ! Danielle took care of us and was attentive and caring.”
New American · $$$$
135 Maple Avenue, Bay Shore · 3.5 miles
Customers’ favorites
“We celebrated our wedding anniversary at Lakehouse after traveling from New Jersey, and overall, we had a wonderful dining experience! The food was absolutely delicious and full of flavor. My steak was fantastic, my husband’s pork chop was to die for, and the crab cake was exactly what I was craving! Everything we ordered was flavorful, and the service was wonderful. One especially thoughtful touch was the complimentary champagne they brought us at the end of our dinner to celebrate our anniversary. Such a kind gesture that made the evening feel extra special and was truly appreciated! Despite the small disappointment of the fire pit and outside area being closed, the delicious food, attentive service, and thoughtful hospitality made for a memorable anniversary dinner. Thank you, Lakehouse!”
New American · $$$
124 Maple Ave, Bay Shore · 3.46 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Love John the bartender. Great food and atmosphere”
American · $
298 West Main Street, Bay Shore · 2.66 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I just had another amazing lunch at Zest. The portions are VERY generous and the food is always amazing. The chef is a culinary artist.”
New American · $$$
185 Main Street, Farmingdale · 7.58 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Tasting room is a hit! From the atmosphere to the food and the creative cocktails that they’re making this place is a very welcomed addition to the downtown Farmingdale area. From the burger to the lasagna, everything we ordered was yummy. The owner is a very hard-working long-standing business owner Who puts his heart and soul into his establishment. I highly recommend giving Tasting Room a try.”
Steak House · $$$$
325 Smithtown Bypass, Hauppauge · 9.94 miles
Customers’ favorites
“….….Best place on earth………”
American · $$$$
21 Fire Island Avenue, Babylon · 1.12 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Thank you for the great job they did for Juliana’s shower”
Bar · $$$
5 Third Avenue, Bay Shore · 3.31 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Been here a couple of times. Once on a date night Thursday with my wife, another time for birthday party on a Saturday night with DJ C Natryl. He created a sick vibe. Can't wait to come back to hear him play again!! Nice little room that really is a gem. :)”
American · $$
49 E Hoffman Ave, Lindenhurst · 3.67 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Really great spot for drinks and food, plenty of delicious creative options! Big fan always coming back, and it helps to know they have help out amazing organizations as well!”
Cocktail Bar · $$
64 East Main Street, Bay Shore · 3.33 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Thank you Gabby and Anthony for being the best service oriented hosts. Great drinks and comversation.”
American · $$$
90 Deer Park Avenue, Babylon · 1.05 miles
Customers’ favorites
“5/5 stars! We had an awesome experience at this place! Amazing food & cute yummy cocktails! This is my new go to spot!”
Cuban · $$
944 West Jericho Turnpike, Smithtown · 10.28 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Omg Amazing food, great drinks and perfect ending with the flan 🍮 😍 to die for, highly recommend!!!!”
Fine Dining · $$$
41 East Main Street, Bay Shore · 3.3 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Delicious cocktails and food! We all had a difficult time deciding on a meal, everything sound so good! Friendly helpful staff, would totally recommend!”
Breakfast · $$
1511 Old Country Road, Plainview · 9.05 miles
Customers’ favorites
“In town on business and ordered take out from The Shed both nights. Food was fantastic. Will come back when the opportunity presents itself in order to sit down and truly enjoy a meal.”
Bar & Grill · $$
306 Main Street, Farmingdale · 7.52 miles
Customers’ favorites
“We just had the BEST experience at the Farmingdale location. Food, DRINKS, our amazing waitress Hailey… all outisde in their beautiful “Backyard” space. Will recommend and make this a regular spot!!!”
Deli · $
936 Little East Neck Road, West Babylon · 2.77 miles
Customers’ favorites
“This is a great deli anf sandwich shop for me. They have a few things other deli don't have. The food is always good. Worth a stop if your coming in this direction. The inside is not large. They make the best of the space do you can eat here. I always take it to go”
Greek · $$
Dix Hills Road, Huntington Station · 9.51 miles
“This family owned restaurant is worth the time and effort. Nothing fancy except good Greek food. We both eat in and take out The staff is so accommodating and friendly. Many times the owners wife and children are eating there. The grandfather works at the grill when not spending time with his grandkids Again, nothing fancy except for the food, the atmosphere and the people. Please go and enjoy home-cooking while eating out”
Gastropubs · $$
Mayfair Shopping Center, 204 Jericho Turnpike, Commack · 9.63 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Great consistent food. Priced very fairly. Great atmosphere. Enjoy seeing Todd O and Richie. It's like the 90s and Sprats. We are just missing Danny S.”
Bar · $$
262 Deer Park Avenue, Babylon · 0.94 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Great place to go very safe and friendly”
Cheesesteaks · $
191 Main Street, Farmingdale · 7.58 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Absolutely love their cheese steaks! Service was fast and with a smile....cheese throughout sandwich as it should be...ribeye steak grilled perfectly. Well done!”
Bar · $$
252 Main Street, Farmingdale · 7.55 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Clean, courteous, staff, and more food that you’re able to eat in one sitting”
Seafood · $$$
61 West Main Street, Bay Shore · 3.15 miles
Customers’ favorites
“My Husband and I stumble across this place tonight and couldn’t be happier about it! From the moment we walked through the door on a busy Saturday night at 7:00pm we walk in simply based on a great name! The hostess Deanna was lovely and welcoming we were able to sit right away! The food was absolutely amazing and so were the drinks!! But the star of the show was the staff our waitress Emily was the best we have ever had! Just the right amount of attentive that we never looked for her and always felt taking care up. The busser also did an amazing job never a dirty plate on our table. We go out alot and I can’t remember the last time a restaurant covered it all flawlessly Service drinks and food. We have already texted friend excited to bring them here! Can’t wait to come back keep up the amazing work!”
American · $$
317 Main Street, Farmingdale · 7.64 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Had the experience of a lifetime when we did the chefs table. Chef Eric Levine was amazing and the food he prepared for us was like no other we’ve ever had. Six wonderful courses. Janice took care of our table and was equally amazing. I was so happy to be able to share this experience With family and would definitely do it again.”
Irish Pub · $$
60 East Main Street, Bay Shore · 3.33 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Large bar, big place, lots of tv’s, great space upstairs for private events, cold 🍺 and great food = good times 💫”
American · $$
335 East Main Street, East Islip · 7.06 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Service and cuisine was excellent. Staff was very friendly and eager to please.”
American · $$
400 Baylawn Avenue, Copiague · 5.87 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Latin Tuesdays is awesome‼️ 🕴🩰💃🏻🕺🩰🕴”
Steak House · $$$
283 Main St, Farmingdale · 7.53 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Harley's American Grille Restaurant in Farmingdale is great place for Lunch, Brunch or Dinner. The place has been redone with a really nice decor. Menu is not extensive but offers a lot of great options. We had the Chicken Sandwich and the Wild Mushroom Ravioli.- both were delicious. They offer a Wine List. The service was awesome and Jesse our server was just amazing. Parking is hard in the Village but there are large metered parking lots behind all the stores.”
Chinese · $
3283 Sunrise Hwy North Service Road, Islip Terrace · 7.54 miles
Customers’ favorites
“This is by far one of the best chinese takeouts left on the island. I would travel 30 mins to pick up and return home because of the flavors. I’ve ordered a few times now and it is always consistent. Most authentic taste made with love.”
Chinese · $
334 East Jericho Turnpike, Huntington Station · 9.8 miles
Customers’ favorites
“The food is very fresh, no msg, very good efficient friendly service.Great lunch specials and they deliver fast !”
New American · $$
16 East Court, Babylon · 1.75 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Tres Palm is Tres Bon!! Random pick while looking at the map. Great location in the sun, on the water. Had the lobster roll and that Hawaiian burger. OMG!!”
Seafood · $$
218 East Montauk Highway, Lindenhurst · 3.2 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Delish lobster!!! Also recommend the aging steak!!! Truly enjoyed our meal!!! Highly recommend giving this hidden gem a try! Prices are still good while everyone else's are ridiculously overpriced! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️”
Lounges · $$
854 South Wellwood Avenue, Lindenhurst · 3.66 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Went today for the first time for the anniversary. Food was good so was the staff (Thanks John 🍻) and we sat outside by the water. If im not mistaken there is also roof top seating with a bar but we didn't venture that way this time...Atmosphere was choice for us as well. Will be back.”