Sandwich Shops near West Islip

Hometown Heroes Sandwich Shop • $
240 Higbie Ln, West Islip

Customers` Favorites

Manhattan Roast Beef with Mozzarella on Garlic Bread
Classic Hot Pastrami Hero
Italian with the Works
Macaroni and Cheese
Chicken Tenders
Chicken Cutlets
Chicken Philly
Waffle Fries
Italian Hero
Greek Salad

“Amazing heroes! I was so blown away how good they are, I’m glad I found a good hero place here in the islip area where I’m close by to, most good hero spots I have to travel throughout Suffolk county, i highly recommend hometown heroes most especially the Mac Attack or Good Sam hero’s!! Will be back again!“

4 Good44 Reviews

2
Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
282 Higbie Ln, West Islip

“This was my first time to this Subway. I've been to bad ones before where I've gotten sick so I stopped eating it for awhile but I had a random craving for Subway today. I came in around 11:30 am. There was one man ahead of me. The clerk finished with him much faster than I expected. I noticed the store was very clean. The atmosphere was comfortable. I happened for some reason to look at their prepping boards and they were pure white which actually calmed my fear about getting sick. I ordered a philly cheesesteak with provolone cheese, lettuce, onions, sweet peppers, pickles, black olives and jalapeno (like I said random craving) He made a joke when he rung up my order and said $125.40 instead of $12.54 I laughed and asked him his name. He told me his name is Rocky. He printed my receipt and said if I do the survey on the receipt I could get a free cookie. I went on the website right then and there and answered the questions. Rocky even helped me and I got a free cookie. Rocky had great customer service. He made me feel welcomed. Oh and the sanidwich? was awesome! Perfect amount of toppings to complement the steak. I recommend it. Thanks Rocky! Would definitely come back.“

1.6 Poor10 Reviews
Fresh Stop Cafe Sandwich Shop • $
201 Old Country Rd, Melville - 8.25 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chipotle Turkey Avocado Sandwich
Thai Peanut Chicken Salad
Melville Bomb Sandwich
Egg White Cheddar
Chicken Tenders
French Fries
Plain Omelet

“Highly Recommend Fresh Stop CafeThe food is delicious always fresh and service is amazing very sweet and kind.You will love their Cobb Salad , Cesar salad, the cafe Milano is perfect, their Cesar salad wrap along with omelets are delish.Definitely recommend.“

4.8 Superb30 Reviews
Pastrami N Friends Sandwich Shop • $$
110 Commack Rd, Commack - 9.24 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pastrami on Rye with Deli Mustard
Corned Beef or Pastrami
Matzo Ball or Kreplach
Coleslaw and Pickle
Matzo Ball Soup
Split Pea Soup
Potato Kinish
Chicken Soup
Free Pickles
French Dip

“Wow! What a great place to eat. The people are so nice. The menu is Kosher. I had a corned beef sandwich and coleslaw on the side, delicious.I highly recommend Pastrami N Friends.Dietary restrictions: Kosher menu.Parking: We had no problem parking.Kid-friendliness: It's a family and friends environment. Something for everyone. Including kids.“

4.3 Superb64 Reviews
Subway on Depot Rd. Fast Food • $
334 Depot Rd, Huntington Station - 10.24 miles

Customers` Favorites

Black Forest Ham Egg & Cheese Footlong with Regular Egg
Turkey Cali Club Footlong Pro Double Protein
The Mexicali 6 Inch Regular Sub
Carved Turkey with Bacon Salad
Turkey & Bacon Avocado Wrap
Spring Garden Chicken
Western Egg & Cheese
Submarine Sandwich
Chocolate Chip
Spicy Italian

“Without a doubt, I wholeheartedly recommend this Subway for its outstanding consistency in food quality and taste, coupled with the warm and friendly staff. The commitment to cleanliness further enhances the overall dining experience. For a reliably fantastic meal in a welcoming environment, this Subway is undoubtedly a top-notch choice.“

4.4 Superb42 Reviews
35th Street Family Deli Inc Sandwich Shop • $
302 35th St, Lindenhurst - 4.4 miles

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake

“I have to say growing up in Lindenhurst, you always look for great places. 35Th Street Family Deli is TOPS!!Whenever I am off from work, I get breakfast sandwiches from them and they are always delicious.Recently I ordered food for the first time. Steven was very accommodating and the presentation was on point.Thank you for representing our town so well and I am looking forward to using you again in the future.“

4.5 Superb26 Reviews
Lasaka House of Noodles Sandwich Shop • $
1701 Sunrise Hwy F5, Bay Shore - 3.89 miles

“I don’t know why this place doesn’t have a lot of positive reviews, this place is AWESOME. Not only the food was absolutely delicious but the staff were VERY nice and very friendly, you get A LOT of food with a GREAT price.I was going to get Sarku Japan but this place is 10000000% better, more variety of food, PLUSSSSS they make bubble tea. WHICH IS ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS!!! I usually get the coconut bubble tea, and they made it perfect.This place is my spot now!!Parking: It’s a mall so there’s plenty of parking.“

4.8 Superb17 Reviews
Roast Sandwich House Sandwich Shop • $$
827 Walt Whitman Rd, Melville - 8.6 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Potato Tater Tots
Alla Vodka

“I went here on a spontaneous rendezvous and my taste buds were taken for quite the ride. This place does not hold back on the steak (most places usually hold back on the steak). If I could describe this establishment in three words I’m not sure what words I would use, but this place is great. I’ll be back.“

3.8 Good74 Reviews
Jersey Mike's Subs Sandwich Shop • $
585 Main Street, Montauk Hwy, Bay Shore - 4.31 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Ranch Chicken Cheese Steak
Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak
Jersey Shore's Favorite
Turkey and Provolone
The Original Italian
Mike's Famous Philly
Ham and Provolone
Club Sub
Mike

“We went here on 4th of July because many of the other stores and restaurants in the area were closed. We were looking for something to take out and bring on a boat and Jersey Mike's subs definitely hit the spot! I was surprised to read some negative reviews because the workers there that day were extremely friendly & helpful. We got the #9 giant hero and a bag of chips (no onions/pickles), all the toppings including hot peppers ? and we had it on the rosemary parm bread . The sub was fresh and was delicious, much better than we expected. The perfect takeout food for beach, picnic or boat. This fed two adults for both lunch and dinner. For about $20. Definitely recommend!“

3.9 Good35 Reviews

10
Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
1934A Deer Pk Ave, Deer Park - 4.14 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken

“The best customer service I got cookie an they made me laugh vinny s an hary an osmany are literally the best staff I’ve met like I was dying cuz I fell of my bike an a car hit me an I broke my left toe aan they made that cookie so good that shi healed me it was like god like that cookie tasted holy an I only like the cookies form here when there are toasted an he did just that“

3.9 Good20 Reviews
J & V Deli Sandwich Shop •
2104 Joshuas Path, Hauppauge - 8.19 miles

“The food was delicious! Ordered the White rice and Bistec (steak) in a tomato sauce with bell peppers, onions, and two tortillas made by hand. My family also had the chicken fajitas over rice and the East village sandwich. They both agreed their plates were good as well. They lots of different drinks to chose from, like authentic Salvadoran Soda Kola shanpan to every soda and juices you can think of. Good customer service nice young ladies helping at the counter! Come in with confidence and enjoy the rest of your day!“

4.5 Superb8 Reviews

12
Blimpie

Blimpie Sandwich Shop • $
160 Adams Ave, Hauppauge - 7.72 miles

Customers` Favorites

Blimpie Best
Subs
Ham

“It brought back so many great memories going to Blimpies. We used to go there as a kid growing up in the Bronx back in the 70's and 80's. I ordered what I used to order back then- Ham & Cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise with oil and vinegar! Had the same delicious taste as it did growing up. Blimpies is WAY WAY better than Subways.“

4 Good13 Reviews

13
Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
477 Park Ave Suite 19, Lindenhurst - 2.88 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cold Cut Combo

“The couple who run this place make it a worth the trip. They are always friendly. We go there as much as possible. You can get your sandwich made to order. They are always a five stars eatery. Out of respect I don't post pictures. During the summer it is on the busy side.“

3.5 Good61 Reviews

14
Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
650 NY-110, Melville - 8.83 miles

Customers` Favorites

Steak & Cheese Melt

“Overall we had a good enjoyable meal... staffs were friendly. As usual we had a veg delight... my son wanted just olives in toasted bread, one of the staff was miser, added very less olives, other staff came in picked up that and added more olives... on looking at that my son was very happy.. I recommend this shop ☝️“

4.3 Superb7 Reviews

15
Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
Fc2/Food Court, 1701 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore - 3.86 miles

Customers` Favorites

Tuna

“I agree they are a bit skimpy with the toppings, but my server was very polite and helpful. Sandwich was good, but bread was a little stale. I mean, come on, is t that what they are known for, their bread. They lost a full star for that. Otherwise, ok sandwich for a food court.“

3.5 Good46 Reviews
Jersey Mike's Subs Sandwich Shop • $
5050 Sunrise Hwy, Massapequa Park - 7.76 miles

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak
Turkey and Provolone
Soda Bottle
Cookie
Chips

“I honestly love Jersey Mikes. I am a big supporter of small businesses, don't get me wrong, but sometimes a quick and easy sandwich is just what you need. I always get the super sub on the rosemary parm bread. The staff has always been helpful and kind and I've never have a significant issue with my order. Even with delivery the food is good, but I do live relatively nearby. Now that I'm thinking about it I may need it sooner rather than later.“

3.5 Good38 Reviews

17
Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
1393 Straight Path, Wyandanch - 4.05 miles
4 Good7 Reviews
Loading...
map Map