29 Best Pizza Restaurants near Castalia

“Unbelievable value for food that fills you up and leaves you wanting more. Be it the pizza, the subs, the wings or appetizers you are getting a dish crafted with care. My favorite is the chicken Alfredo sub and fries 🍟 . My wife loves the taco pizza 🍕 🌮 and my kids love for the cheese pizza followed by a Reese’s ice cream 🍦 If you haven’t you, you should, if you are thinking about it, you must! Kyle & Tony and crew deliver every time!“

“We are so fortunate to have Village Pizza House close by and willing to deliver. Countless times we the staff/owners have ordered on a night that we were too busy to cook. Additionally, our campers often call for deliveries as well - such a great option for a meal after having traveled a long distance. Keep up the good work!“

“Bangin’ pizza! 3 hours away from home, and the best pizza I’ve found anywhere!“

“Excellent service .- Our waitress, Taylor, was very attentive. The food was delicious!“

“the food is great and the service is awesome“

“Picked up dinner tonight for the family and boy, did it not disappoint!! Everything was delicious! The pizza and cheese bread was demolished so fast as I expected lol The salad was exactly what I wanted for a post-Christmas crunch, and the wings my husband nearly inhaled so I can’t review those personally lol but I will next time! Thanks for a delicious dinner and great conversation! We’ll be back soon!!“

“This place was a blast. Great Saturday night visit. Food good and service amazing! Great time!“

“Love their pizza. Hate their hours which are ridiculously short.“

“The food was simply awsome, everything was well put together. We didn't dine in, we just ordered and went home with it, but it was extremely good. The pizzeria was a ghost town, didn't have any customers. It's sad to see, because it was extremely good. Although there weren't really chairs to sit, everything was fine. I really liked it and will most like come again it I've got time. I'd say 8/10. Very good food, although the atmosphere could be improved.“

“The BEST pizza in the world!! It is unmatched. I have been all over the world and nothing draws me back like this pizza! My favorite sub will always be the Super Wheel! Be sure to try this place! Love supporting this business. They are the best around!“

“Best pizza around! The chicken club foldover never disappoints 🤤🍕“

“We ordered the Mac n cheese pizza and the New York white. Both were absolutely delicious. The Mac pizza was a hit with the kids, the New York white was a little more “adult” but my husband and I both agreed that the Mac n cheese pizza was probably the best pizza we’ve ever had. Will definitely order it again when we return to the area!“

“Delicious food, a great wine and cocktail selection and a beautiful atmosphere! The Canoe Club is one of our absolute favorites and a must stop if you are in the area! We ate there last night and we were waited on by Ally, who was one of the best servers we have had! Thank you Canoe Club for always being a fantastic dining experience!“

“I take my wife and son ( 15 ) for dinner and a game of pool. The pizza is ( The Best ) their Burgers are amazing! The atmosphere is great if not to packed.
A fun fact: My parents met here on their 1st date. Married 50 years 🙏🙏☺️🫈“

“To tina stockero dont lie on someone as great as mo. Your profile picture is you naked you nasty nasty chick.. I Love flash, they instantly know the prices of what i want even if its a list. They have the best of everything from pop- booze/chips- treats. Every time is in and out. Favorite drive thru ive ever been to!“

“I just ordered delivery tonight from this one, the pizza was supper hot when it arrived & the driver Blaire was very friendly with an uplifting & positive attitude that is hard to find these day's. The tip was well earned & deserved.“

“Patina Porch has become one of our absolute favorite places. From the moment you walk in, the atmosphere is airy, welcoming, and full of charm. The staff are just as warm as the space itself. They’re always happy to adjust things to your tastes, and as someone with a gluten allergy, it means a lot that they genuinely take it seriously and go out of their way to make sure I’m taken care of. My fiancé Chad and I also love browsing the beautiful antiques, upcycled items, and plants. It makes every visit feel like a little experience beyond just stopping in. Over time, the staff have become friends, and we’ve even met new friends along the way while spending time there. It’s also one of our favorite places to bring people who are visiting or to introduce friends to, because we know they’ll love it as much as we do. We also love their trivia nights on Thursdays. It’s always a fun reason to come back and spend time there. Patina Porch is one of those rare places that feels both special and comfortable at the same time, and we’re always happy to come back.“

“I visited Fast Eddie’s a few weeks ago and my server was Christina! Great personality and wonderful service. It’s so nice to be served with a smile and the food was great too!“

“Just ordered a small cheese pizza with green peppers. I asked for the top to have a little brown. This pizza was as I asked and it taste so good!!“

“Got blown off the lake and found Jamestown tavern to be the perfect place to get out of the wind. Enjoy delicious loaded tots and ice cold beer. Buffi the bartender was on top of her game. We will be back.“

“Food is great and very friendly and accomodating owner.“

“Brand’s has a great Service Department. They recently did a super job performing some overdue scheduled maintenance on a Yanmar 2GM20 in our J105. I recommend them for the care of your sailboat.“

“excellent food and service!!!“

“The pizza was amazing! Best I've had in this area. The staff are very friendly. Highly recommend!“

“We were up there last weekend for a volleyball tournament, @ 9pm we were all tired and hungry! I called and ordered 8 pizzas, 30 breadsticks, and 3 two liters of pop and these guys were fantastic!!!!!! Our order was delivered to the hotel in 30 mins and they brought plates, napkins, & cups! It's the best service we have had out of several Sandusky restaurants. Thank you!“

“We ordered from here this evening and first off the delivery driver, Pirate-Rob, is Amazing; he got our dinner to us in excellent time and has a superb personality, to say the least! However, I ordered honey BBQ / Habanero wings, they were delivered plain, they forgot to pack my coke and I have had better Taco pizza. Pirate-Rob took my wings back and had them coated and brought my coke back in record time, even though he had another delivery after mine. I give the delivery driver five stars but the establishment itself a 3 If you deliver from this Dominos ask for Pirate-Rob. If something is wrong he will make it right!“

“The food at Daly’s is always good. Extensive menu and daily food specials keep me coming back. Always quick service from friendly bartenders. A staple in Sandusky that’s been around forever for a reason! Plenty of room for everyone with a huge bar and a large dining room.“

“Fresh, hot, good amount of toppings. (We did carry out)“

“This Marcos always has a great staff with even better deals for our meal! 🫶🏼“