14 Best Pizza Restaurants near Castalia

“Vegetarian options: A few options including veg pizza.Dietary restrictions: Possible to eat lower cal but not easy.Parking: Parking is no problem.Kid-friendliness: Kids are welcome. The menu has a kids section and there are high chairs. Nicely informal atmosphere helps also.“

“Family owned! By far the best pizza we have had in a long time! Delivery was fast and friendly! We orderd a pepperoni bacon,and banana peppers, pizza, when I tell you it was HOT, CHEESEY, FULL OF TOPPINGS..and PERFECTLY baked to perfection!!“

“I have been wanting to try this place for a while now. Needed something new as far as pizza goes. The reviews looked promising, as well as the pictures of all the different pizzas.Ordered 2 medium pizzas and an order of breadsticks, with an addition side of Garlic Butter. Ordered at 610, was estimated to be done at 640, and was ready 10 minutes early, staff greeted me when I walked in.Now the pizza. Definitely one of the best pizzas I have had in a while. Very flavorful and perfect amount of toppings on both of them. Pickle pizza was loaded with pickles and the ranch drizzle was a great touch. Bacon Cheeseburger pizza was also fantastic. Toppings weren't falling all over the place.I went back to leave a tip and tell them what a great job they did. I'll definitely be ordering again. Amazing spot. ??????“

“Absolutely love this place!! Anytime I’m in town I will grab something, whether to dine in or take home. The best cheesy bread, the wings are cooked perfectly, and of course the pizza!Noah was our server today, and she is just the most delightful human being! A wealth of knowledge on the restaurant and the menu.“

“We visited Ohio from out of town! Food and vibe of the restaurant was amazing! Staff was friendly and personable! We ordered a simple vegan pizza with basil. One of the best tasting vegan pizza's I've ever had! Feedback suggestion would be to offer a vegan protein for pizza and a vegan friendly appetizer.Vegetarian options: Amazing Vegan Pizza“

“Delicious food, a great wine and cocktail selection and a beautiful atmosphere! The Canoe Club is one of our absolute favorites and a must stop if you are in the area! We ate there last night and we were waited on by Ally, who was one of the best servers we have had! Thank you Canoe Club for always being a fantastic dining experience!“

“Quick stop in to grab a bite to eat. Don't really know the area or places to eat. But glad we stopped ininto Rayz. Had the Chicken Balls. Perfectly breaded, cooked and delicious ? Service by the young man who waited on us was awesome. Atmosphere was a little dark except for tables on the upper landing.“

“Our family found while staying in Sandusky a few weeks ago. Food was PHENOMENAL and the staff were so friendly and kind. I look forward getting to try them again when we come again in the summer!Parking: They have a lot plenty of spaces and a smooth path for pick ups :)“

“Dined here approximately 5PM on New Year's Eve so you can imagine how busy they were. Five minutes after placing our order I asked our waitress to add an item to our order. This item was not delivered along with the initial order which was understandable. After a short period of time our waitress noticed the item had not been delivered. Shortly after that another person which I believe to be the owner came up to us and said the item will be comped and apologized for the delay. Did my best to tell her this not expected and we were fine as we realized how busy they were but they did indeed remove the item from our bill. This was not our first time to the Brick House and for sure it will not be the last. So great to experience stellar service, thank you.Kyle“

“Great little menu. I had chicken salad sandwich and chips and it made me crave chicken salad the whole week. The atmosphere is super cute and open. I love the drink specials and use of herbs from their very own garden. One of the owners offered for me to take any of the fresh cut sunflowers from around the resturant. Super cool and cute. Loved it all. Next time I will go back when they have live music.“

“New spot that has recently opened. The menu is extensive and priced competitive. I was really impressed with the quality of the products. We had a couple of pizzas and appetizers and they were excellent. The food was ready on time, and was hot. They didn’t skimp on toppings.The local joints have some serious competition now, and we are looking forward to patronizing this spot in the future.“

“Came into town after stopping to grab a stuffed animal for our grandson from African Wildlife Safari. Stopped in to try the pizza and WOW, awesome little pizza shop. The atmosphere is open and welcoming, staff friendly and knowledgeable about their product and business. Our server Scott was absolutely fantastic, had great recommendations on the food. Food came out quickly and was delicious ?“

“Highly recommend. Their wings and fries are delicious, but my favorite was probably the GIANT hot pretzel with beer cheese. The server was really friendly and attentive, and the overall feeling while being there was awesome. If I lived closer, I feel like this would be a regular place that I would go to just spend some time.“

“Had the box lunch and the Italian sandwich was wonderful! HOWEVER…I have to say this out loud…..that coleslaw is the BEST coleslaw I have ever had in my life! Dave…any way you could post your coleslaw recipe? Great customer service and all-around great place to get food and provisions.“