7 Best Pizza Restaurants near Centerburg

“Have to get their Italian sub pizza and their BLT pizza- so good!“

“While visiting Centerburg, Ohio, the geographical center of the state, I got sidetracked and found the center of the pizza universe at Long Branch Pizza! If you’re on a quest for the holy grail of pizza, let me save you some time: this is where the journey ends. Picture this—you walk in, the smell of fresh dough and melted cheese hits you like a warm, delicious hug. They make their dough in-house everyday! I went in with family, and we ordered a bit of everything from appetizers to pizzas. First, let’s talk about the crust: it’s like a cloud had a baby with a pizza oven, crispy on the outside but oh-so-fluffy inside. Then there’s the sauce, a tangy, secret concoction that I swear has to be some kind of culinary magic. The toppings? Fresh, generous, and divine. I don’t know what kind of wizardry the chef has going on, but every bite was like a mini-fireworks show exploding in my mouth! I’m talking pepperoni perfection, veggie nirvana, and don’t even get me started on the cheese—gooey, stretchy, and just the right amount of melty. Oh, and don’t even think about leaving without trying on of their new signature pizzas; The Hattie! It’s loaded with pepperoni, hot honey, and chili flakes! You want sweet? You want spicy? You want The Hattie! The vibe here is tremendous. Friendly staff, a cozy vibe, and the kind of energy that says, “Yes, you should definitely order another pizza.” I spoke with the owners, and after a few minutes, it felt like we were lifelong friends! I’m probably gonna have to kidnap them and take them back to Texas with me so that I can have this pizza all the time! If you’re reading this, just stop. Go. Now. Run, don’t walk, to the best pizza in Ohio!“

“Good people making good pie for the right reasons. It’s thin crust. Yet still has a nice chew. Good ingredients. If your in the area, give them a try!“

“Nashville hot pizza is no joke.. best pizza ever! don't be afraid of the name, you'll enjoy it even if you're not a spicy fan.“

“The food is always awesome! Best pizza I have ever had and piled high with toppings. Love playing the arcade games!!“

“Tables in bar area & bar top rarely cleaned off after guests leave. Service in bar area is usually slow. Bathrooms are ALWAYS deplorable - feces/urine on toilet seats, paper towels on the floor & rarely not in dispenser, floor is sticky, bad odor ALWAYS“