40 Best Pizza Restaurants near Commercial Point

“I was casually scrolling around to find a pizza place near Mt. Sterling and stumbled upon Mo’s. I packed the kids and wife in the car and drove the 20 minutes to sit in the dining room. I ordered 1 cheese pizza, a salad for my wife, and a ham and cheese sub for my kid. The food was great, cheese pizza was amazing. Mo even came out and had spoken to us a few times while we were dining. He had asked if we have ever tried the wings, and I mentioned this was our first time. So he cooked up a few boneless, and bone-in wings for us to try! Carolina gold was delicious on both, he mentioned he uses Tyson wings. Everything we had was great and his customer service was the best I’ve had in a long time. He did say that the dining room is always empty, so I wanted to post this review in hopes that more people will jump in and try his place out.“

“If you don’t know where to go this is the spot. Been going here since I met my husband. This place always a great place to go. ❤️🫶💯“

“Wife had a pizza and I had a buffalo chicken sub. The misses liked her pizza and the sub was good. A little small for my liking but the taste was good. They have a great bourbon selection and live bands occasionally.

Wheelchair accessibility: There is a step up to get into the front door, but once inside plenty of room.“

“Classic Columbus Pizza! Worth the trip.“

“only pizza I will eat!!! getting ready to order now“

“I order no contact delivery. The driver was standing in front of the door waiting for us to open the door for maybe a minute. He then texted me and told me to get my order or it would be canceled. After we got the order he had to come back to have us sign the receipt. The text was unnecessary.“

“10/10.. friendly service, amazing pizza! We are traveling through from out of town for our son's birthday and we will definitely be back if we ever come through again.. chicken bacon ranch was the BEST and the owners son was so nice!! Thank you!!“

“We ordered Cattleman's for the first time Monday, deciding to split the Italian sub and pepperoni pizza. Best Italian sub we have ever had and best pizza in Grove City. Will be back soon!“

“Used to deliver here regularly and the owner was super nice to all her vendors. She would make a sub for us and even offer a cold drink on hot summer days. The kind of place you enjoy delivering to. Every small village or town needs a nice place like this in it.“

“best place to get a awesome salad at my uncle and I got the small chef salad there was so much we couldn't even eat it all. will be trying more from them. people who work there is very friendly and nice. will recommend them. I will give a 5 star rating“

“Our pizzas are always really delicious and any additional food we order is too. This time I ordered 3x pineapple on my Hawaiian pizza and it didn't seem like there was much more than the normal amount. The pizza was still delicious, but I would have liked more pineapple. We'll still keep coming back, we love Flyers on Hoover Rd.!“

“What ever, you are doing keep it up best pizza ever“

“best pizza ever i wish they would bring me 2 large pep and cheese and one with banana peppers and mushrooms 234 school st williamsport ohio 20 dollar tip“

“Yeah every time we order Jets the pizza is ALWAYS perfect. We probably order more than we should but there has never been a time we had to send our pizza back or call to complain.

This pizza is just that good. If you’ve never had Jets I would place it in my top three favorite pizza joints to order from.

Crisp, flaky tasty pizza always leaving my mouth watering before I take the first bite.

Think I’m kidding, order it today and prove me wrong. ? and please don’t lie about it lol

I recommend the 8 corner pizza!“

“Thought we’ll give them another shot first
Time we wanted to try them they were outta dough Gave it awhile and tried them again! Pizza was really good and the had the old time peps what I absolutely love ! And baked to perfection. There subs were pretty
Good to something about the dressing is really what did it for me. The fella and fellaet was really friendly lobby was pretty small with one table but place was clean and didn’t smell bad. Maybe get some kind of music or some type of something to get the hype up for the bomb pizza.“

“We are regulars of this establishment. The pizza is absolutely the best pizza. The subs are okay. However the only thing I don't like about it is no discounts or minimal discounts especially to regular consumers like we are okay but nonetheless the pizza is great“

“Very kind employees, very clean place to sit and eat and their prices aren't expensive at all! I'd have to say other than Donatos Pizza, Pj's Pizza would be my second favorite pizza place. The atmosphere is quiet, respectful, great paced and great hospitality!“

“We love the spaghetti & breadsticks.🍝 We do miss the caesar salads though.“

“Just got my CDL and stopped in for a shower and bite to eat. Christian took care of me, held my order at godfather’s so it’s fresh, and his ambition to customer service made my day. It’s nice to see friendly when I don’t know anyone. After 20+ years in the service industry I see it and appreciate it.“

“Amazing!! it's been quite a few yrs since I've gotten pizza from here. I used Uber tonight for delivery and they sure didn't disappoint! we loved everything. garlic bread,antipasto salad,sub and 2 med pizza's.we enjoyed every bit of it with yummy leftovers for tomorrow. 5+ AAA+ will definitely make this our go to order spot.“

“The best pizza around this area for sure and must dine in Saturday nights for some karaoke with Dwayne good fun music and pizza can't beat it“

“Came across this place when looking for a place to eat before our grandsons baseball game. Friendly staff and excellent food! Burgers are HUGE and cooked perfectly. Fries on point. Good fair pricing. Will definitely be back when in the area!“

“Joseppi’s Pizza was a great surprise to me. I didn’t care for the Pizzas made in our local shops, so I decided to try Joseppi’s. Soooooo glad I did!! The crust is thin and crispy. The sauce doesn’t taste sweet and bland like the others. It’s tasty, tangy, plenty of oregano, and reminds me of my favorite pizza from years ago……Hank Newman’s Pizza. Their staff is friendly, delivery is prompt, and the pizza is so worth it! R. Shiflet“

“This was our first time at Tammy's on Hoover. We were there at lunch time and the lone worker, Mitchell, was busy but still very friendly and helpful. We had The Works pizza and really liked it. I enjoyed the crispness of the shell. We ordered at the counter and were served at our table. Bottled soft drinks are available out of a cooler.“

“For gas station pizza I would put this at the top of the mountain. I really enjoy their cheese and thier overall taste. The attendant inside this particular location did not seem very enthusiastic about her job and seemed rather irritated That she had to be a pizza Queen. The breadsticks were slightly burnt but tasted good had they been cooked right? They probably would've been amazing. I would recommend.“

“On 8/24/25 after spending the whole day doing wedding prep or getting married, anyone after ceremony was invited to get pizza/dinner afterwards with us. We went to Pizza Cottage, as it was the closest and best reviewed pizza place. I was not first at the business because we were the last to leave the farm. Despite the waiting for the entire party to arrive… my husband was the last to arrive… the staff was friendly and accommodating. They made sure the refills of drinks kept coming and the food was good and came out quickly. They were patient and did not make us feel rushed, despite us being there a little past closing. I am kinda surprised I did not take more pictures at dinner, but I was STARVING. Because we got married in the later evening, it made it trickier to have a venue for a “reception”. This however, turned out to be a great option and a good time was had with our friends and family and good food was had.“

“Joseppies is the best pizza (our favorite) in GC. This is my opinion and also my Wife’s. We also really enjoy Cardo’s, Ange’s, Cattleman’s, Tammy’s, Plank’s, etc. AND Zamarelli’s (RIP) 🪦 use to be our go-to. Now it’s Seppies.

One of the great things about Grove City is the diversity in pizza. You can basically get any style. Whether it’s a local spot or a chain restaurant.

As far as Seppies, I see a lot of people complain about the placement of their pepperoni. As far as it being cooked under the cheese versus on top. I completely understand that someone might not like this. But I’m sure if you ask them to put the pepperoni on top, they would accommodate. Idk, call me crazy. 😵‍💫

Also, you have to remember, this place is a pizza joint that’s a hole in the wall. You can’t dine in there. So who cares if there’s dust or dirt on the windowsill. They have chairs. So use them.

Now for the downside of my review. My biggest problem with Seppies is the consistency or lack of. I get it though. It seems like a lot of younger kids work here. So it is, what it is.

But this is one area that I really wish they would work better at. It’s not a big enough problem to cause us to not want their pizza. But at the same time, when you eat at a place so much on a regular basis. It can kind of start to become a problem.

One other thing that I wanted to address; Is ordering a large pizza versus ordering an extra large. The dough on the extra large pizza is way thicker than the dough on a large. Which doesn’t really make sense to me. And by the extra large having that excess dough, it completely changes the entire Pizza. Not in a good way.

Normally, we would want the extra large. But we only ever order a large because of this issue. So hopefully somebody sees this review and can correct this issue.

Regardless, this is our favorite pizza place here and we eat it at least once a week.“

“I had dinner for the first time there last night and my friend and I loved everything we got. The waiter was friendly and very good at keeping tabs on our table and many others. We will be back!“

“Excellent food and service. would highly recommend“

“Used to love going to this location and have been since they opened this store. Went in tonight and had the worst customer service EVER!!!! I will not be back to this location ever again. We drove 45 minutes to get here and was lied to not once but 2 times after waiting for a table for 30 minutes. Not going into all the details but i will NOT be back I'll drive over an hour to go somewhere else or another location next time. Our rating will be a negative stars if that was possible“

“We tried Zanzis for the first time tonight! Finally an affordable pizza place for larger families! The food was absolutely amazing and we will definitely be ordering more 🍕 🧡“

“Been Alive 34 years and always remember my Grandma Jenny Lymn Paugh working for Victor, making pizzas in the kitchen, oh and the best gravy and biscuits in town. Miss then days.

Kid-friendliness: Awesome to kids.

Parking: Parking is complicated, with lifted amount if space. However, there is a drive-thru.

Wheelchair accessibility: Not very accessible to the handicap as myself, store is too small/crowded for wheelchair access.“

“I am a truck driver. I have been to several Pizza, wing, burger, Chinese, Mexican, Seafood, BBQ and Korean places over my years being on the road. Often I do not have to order food. But when I do, it’s pizza. If you like thin crust pizza, this is hands down THE BEST PIZZA in America. That is from Maine to Washington State, to California to Florida. I have found that New York State has the best stuffed crust, Detroit is known for their deep dish, and you go to Chicago if you want a pie style…but this restaurant is undoubtedly the best at making thin crust pizza. Seeing as that is my favorite ethos is my new favorite place to get pizza from in the United States. Perfectly baked crust. Very Very well seasoned. Offers a unique flavor to all of your common favorite and then even some not so common favorites. The pizza looks exactly as the pictures show on their websites and links. I would post a photo but I ate it for the most part a soon as it got here. That being the other thing. It was even as good as I had imagined despite being cold, considering my delivery driver had a previous order that took longer than expected and I ordered in a time where Columbus Ohio is highly trafficked. So no foul to the driver and esspecially not the Pizza place. Will be returning for future orders. I would assume if the pizza and cheese bread are just as good tasting as they look their calzones, salads, meatballs, and deserts are as-well. May be on the menu for the future. Thank you for serving such a delicious pizza to a hungry half distraught truck driver.“

“Craving a dine-in experience? Here’s one of the few that are left.“

“Okay. First time ordering delivery from this location. Possibly last time with difficulties in ordering and delivery. We understand the Nation in Decline. Businesses are dealing with Democrat Induced RECESSION since stolen ELECTION. Businesses are short staffed... high gas prices... Good Customer Service is hard to find. This being written, a Monday Afternoon should still be a good time to place an order anywhere... no excuse for a Pizza to be thoroughly destroyed being delivered a quarter of a mile away... BEHOLD!! WOW!! This is how my Pizza was delivered to me... by a very nice driver. This November Trump must WIN to Make American Business Great Again... Thank me. 2nd. HORRIBLE EXPERIENCE LAST SUMMER... I ASKED FOR A 7IN. HAWAIIAN PIZZA. I RECEIVED AN ITALIAN SUB... HAWAIIAN PIZZA SOUNDS NOTHING LIKE ITALIAN SUB. PLEASE HIRE BETTER EMPLOYEES... MANAGEMENT CORRECTED THIS DINE-IN BAD EXPERIENCE... 3RD. STRIKE... 12 JANUARY 2025... I PLACED A SIMPLE TIMED DELIVERY FOR 11:30. JOSE FROM... DOOR DASH??... WAS LOST. LATE. DIDN'T READ INSTRUCTIONS. COLD PIZZA... MANAGEMENT AT THIS LOCATION EXTREMELY UNPROFESSIONAL, UNEDUCATED AND RUDE. "EVERY PIECE IS IMPORTANT"... PIECE MISSING UPON FINALLY RECIEVING THE PIZZA!! UNBELIEVABLE!! WOW!! LET'S MAKE PIZZA GREAT AGAIN. TRAIN YOUR EMPLOYEES TO BE POLITE, PROFESSIONAL, KIND AND CERTIOUS. THIS CURRENT INDIFFERENT, UNPROFESSIONAL, RELAXED TO ALMOST COMATOSE SHOULDN'T FLY... DONATO'S WAS ONCE A FAMILY FAVOURITE. NOW, IT'S OF THE HOOD, ON GATEWAY DRUGS... FILTHY... DONE WITH THIS LOCATION.“

“KEVIN!!! He’s the man!!! We came in last night after accidentally ordering at the wrong location! Oops!! (Totally our fault)
He helped us without making us feel like he was irritated by our mistake (which most places do nowadays)
So a true shoutout to Kevin for taking care of us and for all the ladies and gentlemen in the back making our order. We truly appreciate it. A promotion and a raise is in order for Kevin!“

“The manager CHASE is like talking to an old friend the conversation just flows, such a nice energy to experience. The store is very clean and the crew, came up to say hello…it was at 1am. COWAN is really an excellent example of how a young person should present themselves. I’ve been a couple times, so I appreciate that he recognized my face and remembered what I like to order. Well mannered and super personable.“

“Kenna (I think is her name) is amazing!!!! Super sweet girl!!! Very nice customer service!!! Thats why we 💘 this place!!!!“

“This is our sister church on our district. This church held our NMI (Missions) and NYI (Youth) Convention. A large church w school program. Congregation is warm n giving. The parking lot is huge, handicapped parking n wheelchair accessibility.“

“Always a great experience when I go there it’s 2 min from my job and I’m a regular. I will always recommend. Chickens always fresh, but on this pictureI got gizzards, and I know a lot of people don’t like them, but they are great fresh and they are not that actually chewy which I love. Don’t forget to try out the Chester sauce similar to Canes sauce.“