50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Galloway

“Updating review to 5-stars as requested by my mom since we been ordering there a lot recently, as of 11/13/2024.

They got really good food, so I would recommend their French fries, chicken tenders or their BBQ wings. (Reason BBQ wings made it to the list because Flyer's is the only location that actually puts BBQ sauce all over their wings...compared to Domino's who gives you no sauce).“

“It's what you would expect in a small town tavern. We really liked it. The 3 of us shared pizza and wings and both were great. The habanero sauce is definitely hot but I didn't care for the flavor that much. We will definitely go again.“

“The food is great and the staff is very helpful. Olivian took and helped me with my order, Joe got it here quick and helped me because I'm disabled and couldn't get to the door fast. Then I talked to Elena to let them know my appreciation and she was wonderful. The great food is the key, but the staff made my experience easier and all were helpful.“

“The food/pizza is amazing!“

“Very good pizza and bosco sticks, amazing customer service!“

“Relaxing, entertaining & fun. The food is adequate.“

“The salad was big enough for 4 adults to share & was delicious! We had pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion pizza and it was AMAZING !“

“Might be some of the best pizza in Columbus!! Todd and Billy aren’t messing around with this pizza! Their dry rub on their wings are on another level, and the meatball pizza with sauce dolloped on top was such a unique and delicious addition to their pizza! Everyone NEEDS to run and try this pizza!!“

“A huge shout out to Romeo’s for absolutely nailing my lunch order today! Everything was perfect!“

“we love this place.we order from here alot. there food is so tasty and the people who run it are so very nice“

“The Don Corleone w/ sausage and my delicious date Judy.“

“We ordered from the new store in Galloway, Ohio. Pizza and sub was very hot and delicious. I highly recommend trying their food.“

“stopped in on way from Columbus. had an Italian sub and it was fresh and tasty, loved the bun. hubby had a Philly and was pleased.“

“We had really good pizza this afternoon. The 12 inch classic was perfect! It was nice having real fresh toppings on our pizza. The cinnamon dough(cinnaBrenz)with cream cheese was outstanding! Thank you to the man making the pizza who recommended this. We will definitely be coming back. 🍕 Anthony and Amanda“

“Great pizza! Friendly service! I highly recommend the bbq chicken pizza!“

“Ordered carry out on a crappy and super snowy Friday. Pizza was VERY good. Sauce is just right, pepperoni was spicy and delicious, and the crust was flaky, crispy, and cooked to perfection. Italian sub that I ordered was equally excellent! That bread is so good! Finally, I ordered an open face pizza sub. This was the absolute best that I’ve had! Again, bread is awesome, red sauce is fire, and that spicy old world pepperoni was just like it should be! VERY, VERY good! Six out of five stars!!!“

“I got a pizza today and unfortunately it was over cooked. Crust was way too crunchy and cheese burnt, but this is the first bad pizza I’ve gotten from here in all the years I’ve been going“

“Food is good but customer service is not okay. Called to order and the lady on the phone was just not friendly just acted like she hated life and didn’t care about anything“

“We ordered Cattleman's for the first time Monday, deciding to split the Italian sub and pepperoni pizza. Best Italian sub we have ever had and best pizza in Grove City. Will be back soon!“

“Food is always tasty and enjoyable! We ❤️ the Make It Good Fish Sanswich 😉“

“I have only had good experiences at Figlio! I am gluten free (sensitive) and have not had any issues. The workers are very nice and knowledgeable!

Dietary restrictions: Seperate gluten-free menu and the workers can answer questions.

Kid-friendliness: Crayons are provided upon request.“

“I order no contact delivery. The driver was standing in front of the door waiting for us to open the door for maybe a minute. He then texted me and told me to get my order or it would be canceled. After we got the order he had to come back to have us sign the receipt. The text was unnecessary.“

“It's a great place. Been going there for years. Definitely want to try the sub with double meat. It is the ? And their pizza is amazing. Really good. Always fresh. You can taste the TLC in it but when I go there I got to make sure I get that super salad. It's a must-have. It's so delicious so if you ever get a chance I would definitely recommend.“

“Great 🍕 best on in the West!!“

“only pizza I will eat!!! getting ready to order now“

“I ordered 12 pizza's as soon as they opened up on February 2nd. In about 40 minutes I had all 12 pizzas, all hot, all cooked perfect, without any mistakes. Granddad's IS Columbus pizza, thanks!“

“the best on the westside.....ive gone there for the past 30 years...never disappointed“

“Grew up with Josie’s weekly, excited to open the door to Jason & feeling all grown up saying “keep the change”. Moved away after college & only get to grab a pizza on occasional visits home. So happy the OG is still slingin the dough 🍕. Hope to see more business come to the new location, new Franklinton residents brings a whole new crowd so wishing only the best success for this family owned & community loved shop!“

“Our pizzas are always really delicious and any additional food we order is too. This time I ordered 3x pineapple on my Hawaiian pizza and it didn't seem like there was much more than the normal amount. The pizza was still delicious, but I would have liked more pineapple. We'll still keep coming back, we love Flyers on Hoover Rd.!“

“We have been enjoying this Flyers location since they've opened. Besides goid pizza, it is important to mention their outstanding customer service. The staff and delivery drivers are always extremely friendly and professional. Customer service is terrible at most places these days, so it's refreshing to encounter great customer service. We really appreciate it!“

“Yeah every time we order Jets the pizza is ALWAYS perfect. We probably order more than we should but there has never been a time we had to send our pizza back or call to complain.

This pizza is just that good. If you’ve never had Jets I would place it in my top three favorite pizza joints to order from.

Crisp, flaky tasty pizza always leaving my mouth watering before I take the first bite.

Think I’m kidding, order it today and prove me wrong. ? and please don’t lie about it lol

I recommend the 8 corner pizza!“

“best pizza ever i wish they would bring me 2 large pep and cheese and one with banana peppers and mushrooms 234 school st williamsport ohio 20 dollar tip“

“Todd's was extremely busy tonight and the waitress we had was working very hard and she was amazing! They weren't expecting such a big crowd tonight but they handled it well. The food was good and the customer service was awesome!!“

“Pizza is amazing! Staff is amazing! We're fans for life!“

“This is the best place to get your Ohio lottery scratch off tickets and just about anything else you need including gas dinner alcohol cigarettes groceries and even check cashing and money orders and bill pay and you can also purchase cellular phones and lot's More.... This place is a One Stop Shop option to get more for less I must confess and you will be impressed ??“

“Re. the Grandview location - Great food. But, building is just fair. It is freezing in there this time of year (late Fall/Winter). With the high ceilings, any heat never makes it to the patrons inside (please learn to use your ceiling fans to help with this). Also, having doors that open straight to the outside doesn't help. Each time they are opened, it is a blast of cold air for half the establishment.“

“So the pizza is really good here, but the staff actually cares and that makes all the difference! pep, mushroom extra sauce and well done 9/10“

“Great pizza! The sausage sub was also delicious. Highly recommend!“

“This is my second time having it, and my fiancés like 50th ?. He grew up next to it and decided to show me his favorite food from his childhood. Their food is SOOOOO good. Better than any papa johns, donatos, anything, they’re so good and all of the staff is just incredibly sweet. Thank you for amazing food and customer service everytime we’ve visited. We got the sub n crust.“

“The restaurant was clean and had a nice family atmosphere. All of the staff were friendly and attentive. The blackened chicken was delicious. The Gelato was equally delicious. I tested a few different flavors of gelato, then settled on the Lemon Cake and Mora. We will definitely visit again!“

“Had a wonderful time at this location, last night was my first visit and will not be my last. This pizza is so good, I love pizza that the crust is not floppy. I got the NY style dairy air and it was one of the best pizzas I’ve had in a long time. The music was great, the service was great, the food was impeccable and I can’t wait to go back!“

“Bambino's hands down has the best subs in West Jefferson and London. If you want a good sub definitely get it from Bambino's.“

“Hands down my favorite Pizza shop. Family members from out of town always request a pizza from Mama Mimi's when visiting. Tiffany is always wonderful and very helpful with ordering. I've never had a pizza from here I didn't like, but my favorites are the Rajun Cajun and the Marmelletta Amore. The Lasagna is also amazing.“

“great place to go get fast good pizza“

“OMG 😲 Best Salad Ever🤗🥰💯 I got a Speciality Salad with some grilled chicken on it. Which there is no SALADS on the menu like this, so they had to make this to order.... And Babbbbbyyyyy y'all did that💪🏾💯 It's 2 days of PERFECTION RIGHT HERE😍🥰. Yes my lettuce is still green 💚 and everything still crispy and delicious 😋 #Ubettergetone #JetsSaladSlaps #JetsPizzaon5th #GreatSalads“

“BUFFET ... I enjoy the buffet and variety BUT allowing other patrons to use the same plate throughout their visit is DISGUSTING!! I'm here now and have witnessed 3 separate people use dirty plates at the buffet AND one with visible trash on theirs at the buffet. IT RUINED MY APPETITE!!!!!!!!!!!! My wife and I are regulars, here ERLVERY week ... This 'trend' is getting worse - POST A SIGN “

“Wonderful Food & Wonderful Service 😉“

“Top notch bowling center with a great staff!“

“Joseppies is the best pizza (our favorite) in GC. This is my opinion and also my Wife’s. We also really enjoy Cardo’s, Ange’s, Cattleman’s, Tammy’s, Plank’s, etc. AND Zamarelli’s (RIP) 🪦 use to be our go-to. Now it’s Seppies.

One of the great things about Grove City is the diversity in pizza. You can basically get any style. Whether it’s a local spot or a chain restaurant.

As far as Seppies, I see a lot of people complain about the placement of their pepperoni. As far as it being cooked under the cheese versus on top. I completely understand that someone might not like this. But I’m sure if you ask them to put the pepperoni on top, they would accommodate. Idk, call me crazy. 😵‍💫

Also, you have to remember, this place is a pizza joint that’s a hole in the wall. You can’t dine in there. So who cares if there’s dust or dirt on the windowsill. They have chairs. So use them.

Now for the downside of my review. My biggest problem with Seppies is the consistency or lack of. I get it though. It seems like a lot of younger kids work here. So it is, what it is.

But this is one area that I really wish they would work better at. It’s not a big enough problem to cause us to not want their pizza. But at the same time, when you eat at a place so much on a regular basis. It can kind of start to become a problem.

One other thing that I wanted to address; Is ordering a large pizza versus ordering an extra large. The dough on the extra large pizza is way thicker than the dough on a large. Which doesn’t really make sense to me. And by the extra large having that excess dough, it completely changes the entire Pizza. Not in a good way.

Normally, we would want the extra large. But we only ever order a large because of this issue. So hopefully somebody sees this review and can correct this issue.

Regardless, this is our favorite pizza place here and we eat it at least once a week.“