22 Best Pizza Restaurants near Hayesville

“Places like this that are family owned by generational farmers rooted in the community they serve are not so common anymore. Good people and great food“

“We just tried the smash burgers for the first time today and they are my favorite burgers in all of Ashland county! And, the onion rings are the best around! You can't beat the service either! Love this place!“

“Absolute gem in the tiny town of Hayesville! We stopped by to check this place out as we were driving through. Very cool, unique store with awesome selections of beers and wines. We each tried a sandwich at the deli, both were amazing and very reasonably priced. Stop in and check this place out, especially for lunch! They even have a nice sit down area inside and outside to enjoy your food. Looking forward to coming back!“

“Pizza was nice and fresh. The hot bbq boneless wings had amazing flavor. My wife doesn’t drink alcohol but made the mistake of ordering a hard seltzer. Our server fixed it for her quickly, even though it was our mistake. Everytime we come the service is consistent as well as the food. Will be a place we frequent as it gets warm to enjoy the outside seating.

Dietary restrictions: Cauliflower crust is available for those with gluten intolerance.“

“Love thier pizza. Awesome every time.“

“The best place to eat in town. Always delicious! The apple tarts are to die for“

“I had the buffet and everything I tried was good. The price was affordable for a buffet including the drink. I highly recommend.“

“We loved the fried chicken and Jo Jo's. Jo Jo's were crispy on the outside and tender and hot inside. We got the Florentine pizza which could've been a little crispier on the bottom, but the crust was tasty and toppings plentiful. Italian sub was also good. Definitely will be back!“

“We had lunch in their dining room today! Excellent pizza and with the temps in the 90's the air conditioning was really appreciated! The waitress was extremely friendly and very helpful! Will definitely be our go to place for pizza ☺️“

“Was just treated to their Pizza for the first time and it’s the best! Perfect Pep and Bacon 8” pizza! Lots of bacon!“

“this review is for the new Rexburg location in Mother hibbards have stopped in there four times within the last week to try the food and they never have anything in the warmer. no pizzas nothing. I went in there tonight. no food in the warmer. the kids that work there are sitting on the floor up against the wall doing absolutely nothing. Do they only serve Pizza at lunch and zero food for dinner? there's nothing anywhere that says what times they have food what time? they don't have food so tonight I went from hangar 54 right over to Valley wide and got me a personal pizza and now I'm headed to work.“

“Had Romeo’s Pizza for the first time. Excellent pizza. Sauce is a little on the sweet side . . . but very good tasting pizza!! Reasonable prices too!“

“Awesome. Very good food. Great food and service.“

“the guy gave me a hard time again trying to forget about the whole thing this guy working at nights they need to get rid of him I called to order a pizza he said I remember you gave me a bad rep how can you give him a bad rep which he was the one that started it by canceling the order which the manager seen it threw the computer when I went in there i know who this guy is he cancelled my bank card he bad he lies they need to fire him i love there food but he has to go I heard from other people this guy is really bad he gives the costumers hard times he rude he makes bad compliments on people I'm sorry it's the truth and that is considered discrimination which they better make it right I'm sorry which he would not do my order at all which the lady gave me 20 dollars on my account which when I called him he said he didn't see it which I called Mansfield Marcos they seen where it might been deleted on my account if it dont go right im going to main company sorry“

“Great food and earn free pizza ..“

“This is a neighborhood bar that is Always a fun time. Great Bartenders, Wonderful Owners, and just a great place to go.“

“Caddy Shack has great food from their pizza to wings to nachos! Their family friendly atmosphere makes it an exceptional place to hang out with family and friends of all ages! They even have complimentary pool tables! The owner let me host my brother's birthday party at the Caddy and she went out of her way to make is a special event! My brother had the best birthday party ever!“

“Pizza is always good! Salad with just what one wants on it is always good. Selection was good, but not fantastic.

Servers were the best part of the experience - friendly and helpful.

The building is not shiny/new. It is just a bit worn looking, but comfy. Seating and serving us quickly and efficiently.

Kid-friendliness: There were 6 kids - ages 4, 7, 7, 9, 9, 12. The staff were all helpful and friendly when the kids were using the buffet.“

“Tonight, I requested the delivery driver to draw a dinosaur on the box and he did! So Amazing!!!“

“I don’t know if they got new management or what. Before we’ve went and they’ve dropped the ball and the passed 4times the food has been on time and the quality was 100% better. We always order pretzel pizza and crazy bread and it’s been amazing. Sorry I can’t post any pictures we ate it all before I got a chance. Thank you Ashland Little Caesars!!“