New American Restaurants near Kelleys Island, OH

Browse menus, reviews and photos of New American Restaurants near Kelleys Island.

Showing 16 of 16 restaurants

  • The Island House 131 Division Street, Kelleys Island American · $$

    1 The Island House

    4.4 Superb 197 Reviews

    131 Division Street, Kelleys Island

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Fried Chicken and Waffles an IH Classic
    • Peri Peri Shrimp & Crusty Bread
    • Mediterranean Platter
    • Salmon Deviled Eggs

    “The Island House staff is always awesome! Great food, drinks and atmosphere. Shout out to Erica - one of my favorite bartenders on the island. She and Joe (at the Caddy Shack) are the best!”

  • Dockers Waterfront Bar and Restaurant 114 West Lakeshore Drive, Kelleys Island Bar & Grill · $$

    2 Dockers Waterfront Bar and Restaurant

    4.2 Good 198 Reviews

    114 West Lakeshore Drive, Kelleys Island

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • Shrimp and Scallops with Quinoa and Vegetables
    • Shrimp and Scallop Skewer
    • Crab Cake Sandwich
    • Grilled Meatloaf

    “Great. Ambience. Good Pizza. Excellent food truck.”

  • Wave Lakeside Dining - Marblehead, OH 614 East Main Street, Lakeside Marblehead American · $$

    3 Wave Lakeside Dining - Marblehead, OH

    4.6 Superb 121 Reviews

    614 East Main Street, Lakeside Marblehead · 4.38 miles

    Customers’ favorites

    • Spicy Salmon & Tuna Bowl
    • Chopped Cobb Salad
    • Steak and Eggs

    “We love coming here! Beautiful views and great food/drinks AND service. Our server was Alaina and she was sweet and wonderful :).”

  • Ørchard Farm Stand 3350 Northeast Catawba Road, Port Clinton New American · $$

    4 Ørchard Farm Stand

    4.2 Good 229 Reviews

    3350 Northeast Catawba Road, Port Clinton · 6.54 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Whipped Feta and Hot Honey with Pita Bread
    • Hot Honey & Double Pepperoni Pizza
    • Mushroom & Duck Proscuitto
    • Brunch Burger with Home Fries

    “The atmosphere is perfect! Breakfast okay. Had to ask for cream, salt and pepper, not much butter on the toast. Had pizza there last year and that was great.”

  • JJ's Table and Bar 6982 East Harbor Road, Lakeside Marblehead Bar & Grill · $$

    5 JJ's Table and Bar

    4.6 Superb 260 Reviews

    6982 East Harbor Road, Lakeside Marblehead · 6.51 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Salted Caramel Chocolate Cake
    • Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
    • Blackened Shrimp Tacos
    • Mexican Street Corn

    “Their birria tacos are the best tacos i’ve ever had. They always take care of me whenever I call 15 mins before they close and I’m looking for some grub. Highly recommend.”

  • J Bistro Downtown Sandusky 129 West Market Street, Sandusky Fine Dining · $$

    6 J Bistro Downtown Sandusky

    4.6 Superb 245 Reviews

    129 West Market Street, Sandusky · 9.74 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Escargot Appetizer with a Cheeze Meat and Cracker Board
    • Roasted Tomato and Olive Bruschetta Appetizer
    • Apple Crisp with Vanilla Ice Cream
    • Shrimp Tacos Appetizer

    “I’ve never eaten anywhere that you could so easily tell that everything was made in house. The food was absolutely incredible with their meatballs being our favorite item. The steaks were cooked perfectly with a fresh sear that stayed on the outside and such a tender and even cook inside. Decor is really cute and made a great dinner date atmosphere. Our server was great. Super attentive and really engaging when she did stop by.”

  • Big Boppers Restaurant 7581 East Harbor Road, Lakeside Marblehead American · $

    7 Big Boppers Restaurant

    4.5 Superb 416 Reviews

    7581 East Harbor Road, Lakeside Marblehead · 6.09 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Open Face Roast Beef Sandwich with Mashed Potatoes and Gravy
    • Chili Bopper Burger and Onion Rings
    • Eggs with Home Fries & Toast
    • Shrimp PO-Boy Sandwich and Fries

    “Best breakfast in the area. Great atmosphere and service. love it”

  • Crush Wine Bar 145 Columbus Avenue, Sandusky American · $$

    8 Crush Wine Bar

    4.5 Superb 262 Reviews

    145 Columbus Avenue, Sandusky · 9.7 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Butternut Squash Bisque
    • Lobster Mac and Cheese
    • Awsome Wine Selection
    • Smoked Salmon Pasta

    “Love the vibe at Crush. Good food and great drink selection.”

  • Marketplace Downtown 133 East Market Street, Sandusky New American · $$

    9 Marketplace Downtown

    4.6 Superb 82 Reviews

    133 East Market Street, Sandusky · 9.71 miles

    “Absolutely amazing! It's so modern. It really makes downtown Sandusky POP.”

  • Jamestown Tavern - Lakeside Marblehead, OH 902 West Main Street, Lakeside Marblehead Bar · $

    10 Jamestown Tavern - Lakeside Marblehead, OH

    4.5 Superb 162 Reviews

    902 West Main Street, Lakeside Marblehead · 4.16 miles

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • Chicken Nachos 1 2 or Full
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
    • Hot B B Q Chicken Pizza
    • Buffalo Chicken Pizza

    “Got blown off the lake and found Jamestown tavern to be the perfect place to get out of the wind. Enjoy delicious loaded tots and ice cold beer. Buffi the bartender was on top of her game. We will be back.”

  • Ørchard Bar & Table 3266 Northeast Catawba Road, Port Clinton New American · $$

    11 Ørchard Bar & Table

    4.1 Good 791 Reviews

    3266 Northeast Catawba Road, Port Clinton · 6.55 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Wagyu Beef Burger with Truffle Fries
    • Scallops with Corn Bacon Risotto
    • Apple Butter Pork Chop
    • Brussels Sprouts

    “Highly recommend the hot ham & hot peach jam sandwich with the truffle fries”

  • TONY'S - Downtown Sandusky 115 West Water Street, Sandusky Hot Dogs · $

    12 TONY'S - Downtown Sandusky

    4.3 Superb 224 Reviews

    115 West Water Street, Sandusky · 9.66 miles

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • Traditional Wings and Fries Buffalo
    • All-American Cheeseburger
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
    • Beer Battered Onion Rings

    “We visited last week while renting a condo about a block from Tony's for a week. We found this place by accident, just strolling thru town. Our son wanted wings and it was the first place with a menu our family of 4 could all agree upon. We came in from the back and up the patio to enter and weren't sure what to put expect. We were impressed with the interior and that it was the first restaurant (4th overall in Sandusky on our trip) with an adequate cooling system. We were all impressed with our choices. My husband had the Greek cheesesteak and loved it. I couldn't decide between the mac & cheese hot dog or the French Dip. Our server JP a suggested the French Dip and I have to say it is one of the best I've ever had. I think their seasoned mayo is what makes their sandwiches! The daughter and I both got the mac and cheese. She said it was the best mac & cheese she's ever had and she's never impressed. If we are ever back in Sandusky, we're definitely coming back!”

  • The Shores Club Restaurant (Private) 200 Bay Point Boulevard, Lakeside Marblehead American · $$

    13 The Shores Club Restaurant (Private)

    3.8 Good 12 Reviews

    200 Bay Point Boulevard, Lakeside Marblehead · 5.71 miles

    • Take-Out

    “Just spent an awesome day at Baypoint Resort & Marina and I’m already counting down until we’re back! Caught The Visitors playing at the tiki bar and they absolutely crushed it! Such a fun, high energy set. The whole vibe was immaculate, from the music to the water views, and the bartenders were on point. Seriously, we love everything about this place. Hoping The Visitors are back again soon because we’ll definitely be there! 🎶🍹”

  • Rayz on the Bay 1101 East Bayview Drive, Sandusky Bar · $

    14 Rayz on the Bay

    4.3 Superb 249 Reviews

    1101 East Bayview Drive, Sandusky · 10.53 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Basket of Brew City Fries or Hand-Cut Fries
    • Garlic Parmesan Chicken Ballz
    • Shrimp Basket with Fries
    • Perch Diner at Rayz

    “Great browns backer bar and friendly and fun atmosphere”

  • Crow's Nest 2170 North Buck Road, Lakeside Marblehead American · $$

    15 Crow's Nest

    4.3 Superb 355 Reviews

    2170 North Buck Road, Lakeside Marblehead · 6.4 miles

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • Ribs Grilled Broccoli & Salad
    • Smoked Lobster Mac N Cheese
    • Pulled Pork with Brisket
    • Mushroom Swiss Burger

    “I actually love the place. Unfortunately on our last visit we ordered prime rib which was without a doubt the worst I have ever had. I would think they'd be embarrassed to serve it and to charge $25 was robbery at its finest. Very disappointing from a place I typically enjoy.”

  • The Bay Bell Restaurant & Bar 803 East Bayview Drive, Sandusky American · $

    16 The Bay Bell Restaurant & Bar

    4.0 Good 302 Reviews

    803 East Bayview Drive, Sandusky · 10.52 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Pulled Pork Sandwich with Onion Rings
    • Grilled Ruben Sandwich & Onion Rings
    • Yang Chow Fried Rice with Shrimp
    • Shrimp Risotto Frutti Di Mare

    “What a great find! This was our first time at The Bay Bell, and we were really impressed. Brooke was our waitress, and she was very friendly and provided fantastic service! The walleye was huge and perfectly cooked, with fries and coleslaw for $18.95. And an ice-cold jumbo draft for only $5.95! It’s hard to find prices like this, especially anywhere around Lake Erie. Great food, reasonable prices, and a beautiful view of Sandusky Bay. We’ll absolutely be back!”

New American Restaurants Nearby