New American Restaurants near Kelleys Island, OH

“The Island House staff is always awesome! Great food, drinks and atmosphere. Shout out to Erica - one of my favorite bartenders on the island. She and Joe (at the Caddy Shack) are the best!“

“Great. Ambience. Good Pizza. Excellent food truck.“

“We love coming here! Beautiful views and great food/drinks AND service. Our server was Alaina and she was sweet and wonderful :).“

“The atmosphere is perfect! Breakfast okay. Had to ask for cream, salt and pepper, not much butter on the toast. Had pizza there last year and that was great.“

“Best breakfast in the area. Great atmosphere and service. love it“

“I had lunch at the Goat today and not only was the food and service excellent, but the owner went out of his way to make sure our day trip ended on a high note. My bike got a flat tire and he insisted on hauling my bike and myself to the ferry. This 70 year old greatly appreciated his kindness and you can be sure we will support the Goat every time we visit the island.“

“Highly recommend the hot ham & hot peach jam sandwich with the truffle fries“

“I’ve never eaten anywhere that you could so easily tell that everything was made in house. The food was absolutely incredible with their meatballs being our favorite item. The steaks were cooked perfectly with a fresh sear that stayed on the outside and such a tender and even cook inside. Decor is really cute and made a great dinner date atmosphere. Our server was great. Super attentive and really engaging when she did stop by.“

“Love the vibe at Crush. Good food and great drink selection.“

“Their birria tacos are the best tacos i’ve ever had. They always take care of me whenever I call 15 mins before they close and I’m looking for some grub. Highly recommend.“

“Absolutely amazing! It's so modern. It really makes downtown Sandusky POP.“

“Got blown off the lake and found Jamestown tavern to be the perfect place to get out of the wind. Enjoy delicious loaded tots and ice cold beer. Buffi the bartender was on top of her game. We will be back.“

“I actually love the place. Unfortunately on our last visit we ordered prime rib which was without a doubt the worst I have ever had. I would think they'd be embarrassed to serve it and to charge $25 was robbery at its finest. Very disappointing from a place I typically enjoy.“

“We visited last week while renting a condo about a block from Tony's for a week. We found this place by accident, just strolling thru town. Our son wanted wings and it was the first place with a menu our family of 4 could all agree upon. We came in from the back and up the patio to enter and weren't sure what to put expect. We were impressed with the interior and that it was the first restaurant (4th overall in Sandusky on our trip) with an adequate cooling system. We were all impressed with our choices. My husband had the Greek cheesesteak and loved it. I couldn't decide between the mac & cheese hot dog or the French Dip. Our server JP a suggested the French Dip and I have to say it is one of the best I've ever had. I think their seasoned mayo is what makes their sandwiches! The daughter and I both got the mac and cheese. She said it was the best mac & cheese she's ever had and she's never impressed. If we are ever back in Sandusky, we're definitely coming back!“

“Great browns backer bar and friendly and fun atmosphere“

“Found this gem ironically mentioned in a regional travel magazine. Definitely a local spot. I was only out of state plate in lot. Had to try the New York strip…. Perfectly cooked as requested. Sometimes I feel worried when a venue as too many things in menu, but with our family we had a broad selection and all was fantastic!! Don’t hesitate to venue out to this spot!!! Will be back again guaranteed!!! A++“