“Everyone from the staff to the patrons are always welcoming and having a great time. The only place in the Village where it’s always a good time and not to mention the food which is great. $1.50 Tuesdays are always a good time. Love the locals and the always fun environment!!!“
“Cash or check only, so be prepared. It was very busy on a Wed night. Try to sit closer to the bar, as the area near the door is used by parents as a place to let their kids cut loose. Wed must be karaoke night - there were some truly talented singers.“
“We stopped here on our way back from Hocking Hills, and the food was great! They were really busy, but attentive. We got a small pepperoni pizza, a veggie sub with fries and some hot bone-in wings. It was all excellent! Would definitely stop back.Vegetarian options: You could make your own pizza with all veg toppings. Pizza is easy for vegetarians. The veggie sub was great!“
“If you're looking for a non-chain sub-shop, this is your pick. Other reviews can regale you with their selections, but for me, it's the meatball sub, which reminds me of the grinders I've gotten on the East Coast. The sauce is perfect, and the meatballs are delicious, but the bread steals the show. My wife opts for the Italian Sub and loves it every time. I've also got a good Philly sub here. There is no cheese whiz, but it's close to the recipe. Inside the place is nothing to write home about. One big drawback: You might miss the place because the owner hasn't changed the sign, which says "The Mill pizza" out front. It gives the impression that it's not open, or about the close. It was acceptable for a few months, but after years, it's time to invest the sign, my guy.“
“Had a great experience for our first visit. Pizza was delicious, and we will go back again! We had the meat lovers with sweet chili sauce and the Italian pizza. The crust is thin and crispy, and the toppings are plentiful and tasty. Server and cook both were friendly and attentive. We ate in. It's a lot roomier than it appears from outside.“
“The prices were reasonable, and the portions were generous. The restaurant was very clean, and the hygiene measures were evident throughout our visit. I highly recommend Pizza Cottage for anyone looking for a tasty and affordable pizza place.“
“Love Jerry's Pizza. I like the fact that they are family friendly. Food is always hot and hits the spot just right and quite affordable. The only downside I can see is it's a rather small space. So it can go from a cozy feel to an over crowded issue.“
“Good food at a GREAT price. Prices reflected on Google are wrong. Their subs are $5.99. Lunch special - 8 inch sub with chips and a drink for $6.49. ? Service was amazing. Bathrooms were clean. Dining area was clean and spacious. Choose this place over Donatos or similar pizza spots, you'll be glad you did.“
“In the very quaint downtown of Chillicothe sits this unassuming pizza shop. I was delighted at the idea that they would be using a live fire pizza oven! I ordered the meatball appetizer and it was phenomenal. It wasn't dense at all, there were a couple of cheeses I tasted and the sauce was amazing. The pizza comes out and doesn't disappoint. I decided on the works pizza. Crispy dough (next time I will ask for well done) the toppings were fresh. Again, the pizza sauce is very well balanced. The sausage was not your typical pizza sausage. It was excellent and very well seasoned. Best pizza in Chillicothe.“
“The food is amazing! But, I work at a factory and our lunch is very short and I called and place my order and hour and a half in advance and when I call 10 mins until lunch just to double check the estimated ETA the lady that answered had no customer service, very lacking. I've worked in and ran kitchens before this job for years and there's just a way to talk to people and a way not to.“
“I was in town for a gymnastics meet and got a “take n bake”. When we pulled up to the window we were treated by a young man who was excellent! I didn’t get his name but we were there on March 23rd at 1 pm. He personally carried out my order to my car…then my wife wanted a sub so I went in and placed the order, again he found us in the parking lot out back and hand delivered our food. Take n back turned out great! Added a few picks. Thanks again!“
“Amazing pizza! All the food I've had there was amazing actually. Great folks running the place as well. My landscape shop is only a block away and I can order, pickup, and get back to the shop with a hot and fresh pizza in 20 minutes or less. They're quick about it! I definitely recommend pap's if you're in the area. If you're not, it's worth the drive!“
“We ordered Main St. Pizza for the first time tonight. The customer service was great. I told the lady who took my order how many people I was trying to feed, and she didn't try to upsell me, which I appreciate. She even recommended fewer sauces than I was trying to order because they were very large containers, and she was definitely right. It got here in about 40 minutes (decent for a Saturday evening), and it was hot. The pizza was great, and the cheesy garlic bread was good as well. I didn't care for the garlic butter. It tasted bland and, more like, just melted butter without the garlic. I also didn't care for the dessert pizza. It was dry and fell apart very easily and just didn't have a good texture. I was impressed altogether (and so were the kiddos I was trying to feed) and will definitely order again.“
“The manager Tyler is very rude he interrupted the lady taking our order and he said to us that we need to check our order before we leave cause we always complain I then said I have only completed 1 time and I have been coming there for years he continued to take our order but kept repeating that we always complain so to check our order before we leave and then I asked him his name he replied "my name is Tyler and you can complain on me online I don't care". Then our order sat there on the metal shelf for a while and the employees just kept working around it nobody would hand us our order cause Tyler told his employees that he would give it to us , and when he went to give it to us he opened every pizza box and had us look at our pizza with him. That is no way to treat a customer made us feel affected and uncomfortable cause he stood at the register the whole time we were there and kept staring at us......I don't know about you but that is not how you are supposed to treat your customers when I got home all excited to eat my chicken bacon ranch pizza it didn't have any ranch on it and was VERY dry but I was afraid to say anything about it.. I don't recommend this pizza place to anyone. I will NEVER GO BACK and that sucks cause it the only Domino's in town...“
“I read the 1 star reviews and most are from years ago. Walking distance to ev charger, this bar offers decent bar food and drinks. Watching the games here in Chillicothe. Has keno and a huge conference room in the back. Haylie was a great server, thanks for the recommendations on the menu!“
“First I'd like to send my upmost respect to the General Manager, She is really what you call a professional ?? ?? ??.. She will go above and beyond for this place, I'll never forget what she has done tonight . She called me while I was at work to make sure that I would get my order from her personally which she didn't even have to.Marcos should give her a seat ? at Corporate...Thanks for such an exceptional customer service ??“
“We eat here a lot, it's one of our family favorites. We sometimes get their pizza which is our favorite. Sometimes we get burgers and milkshakes and those are delicious too. We have not really been disappointed with anything we have tried. We usually do takeout but have eaten there a few times too and have always been happy with the service. It's a casual place and has a relaxed atmosphere. Great for a quick lunch too.Kid-friendliness: It's a great place to take kids. They love the food here.“