29 Best Ice Cream Shops near Lyndhurst

“Glad to wait in line here. They have the recipe for Euclid Beaches’ frozen custard (which they obtained from Coney Island!) Delish! It brings back such sweet memories. Not located in a high traffic area, but the wait for service, based on the crowds that flock there, say differently. If you’re like me you’ll order a large portion. But hold yourself back! It’s too easy for your eyes to tell your stomach you “need” more! We go to East Coast Custard whenever we can. It’s too good to pass by. (From the throngs of people waiting to place their orders, you’ll probably make some new friends, besides.)“

“Great icecream and carrot cake!“

“When we went, there were 4 vegan ice cream options (though they were sold out of 1). We got the sampler trio to try the 3 available. All so good. The buckeye was fudgy deliciousness. My husband said it was the best ice cream he's ever had. We'll definitely go back.“

“Always a great variety of ice cream! The toasted pistachio in a waffle cone is absolutely delicious! There's handicapped parking, but the door is not automatic, so I had to wait for someone to come along who was willing to open the door for me. The seating was nice, and the tables looked clean. The ice cream is a bit pricey but is very delicious.“

“We love Mitchell's! I particularly like the mango sorbet and vegan chocolate (and I'm not vegan). Seasonal flavors are wonderful. Lavender Honey is another favorite. All locations are consistent in their quality, cleanliness, and friendly staff. Way to go, Mitchell's!“

“My visit today was on a Sunday at approx 6pm or so. I accidently placed the wrong Sundae order and was willing to eat it anyway, but I thought what the heck I'll just be honest and explain what happened. The staff was nice enough to correct my order and offer the Turtle Sundae I desired which was delicious as usual.

Here is the Plus/Minus on this store:
Plus - The ice cream always tastes delicious; the service is fast and excellent every time. Even if the line is long it always moves fast. The temperature in the dining area is always comfy whether it is hot or cold outside. The dining area is always clean. Lots of delicious flavors and speciaty items like shakes and sundaes. This has become my fave ice cream spot in NEO.
Minus: Approx 6 unruly, loud, disruptive youth arrived near the end of my visit. I wanted to escort them right out the door, fortunately they didn't stay long. Perhaps this is a new trend in Solon because a similar thing happened in nearby Chick-Fil-A Solon a few weeks ago. Oops I spoke too soon, the bad kis came back :(“

“Im riding past all other ice cream shops and parlors to get my Honey Hut fix. I dont play with the small servings, I go for the large take home packages--I want to savor my creamery for several days, on the couch, in front of my television. 😊“

“The owners make it special ❤️“

“Ice cream was amazing!! Honestly best i ever had! But the people there kept just starring us, like if they had never seen a Mexican before, i felt uncomfortable while eating my ice cream😔 didnt feel comfortable at all“

“My daughter and her friend picked up a coffee gelato for me. It was Divine. Smooth and creamy without any artificial taste. I will be going back again and sometime the stack was wonderful so friendly that you felt like you were having dessert with your family.“

“Great ice cream, great service!!“

“I love this store. Everything that comes out of it is delicious. The staff is amazing , always courteous and friendly. I usually do preorders and it’s always ready or just about ready when I get there. Couldn’t be happier with this Crumbl store!!“

“I first came to Graeter's about two years ago in June, and I was immediately drawn to the banana chocolate chip ice cream, only to discover that it was seasonal. The rest of the menu is good - we've never been disappointed - but there's nothing else quite like that flavor for me.
They recently added my beloved banana chocolate chip to the permanent menu. Clearly, Greater's knows what the people want, and they aren't afraid to provide it.“

“My family and I living coming here after a long hard day of work and/or school...It has that special neighborhood feel, and the employees, (mostly college and high school students), are awesome!“

“I love this location but at certain times of the day. During the day the customer service is on point!!! But evening / night it’s trash. The younger employees be needing home training before they get a job because their customer service sucks. But anywho during the day, I love this location and the cookies!“

“I placed a last minute order and it didn't effect the pick up time or quality of our order. Our order was ready when we arrived. The store was clean. The staff was friendly! This was our first time ordering from this location, we had a positive experience and we'll surely choose this location in the future!“

“Go see Reid and Shayla ASAP“

“Perfect for anytime and now“

“Good cookies everyone should go and buy them“

“Excellent ice cream. Quick and friendly service.“

“The ice cream. Their lemon custard was delicious and the service was good.“

“Best frozen custard we’ve ever had—creamy goodness!!! The dipped waffle cone didn’t fail to impress either-plenty of thick chocolate on the rim. Will definitely be back!!!“

“I got the oreo ice cream cake. The made it perfectly. Had to adjust my son's name. Everything else was great! The color he chose was great. Didn't even know there were those options. This is why it pays to ask questions. It wasn't even extra for the little things.“

“A huge THANK YOU to TIFFANY in the bakery today! She worked with me with ordering my Son’s birthday cake for Saturday. I came in short notice to order. Great customer service and just a kindhearted person. Thank you Tiffany!“

“I went in to order cupcakes for my son’s birthday, and the owner was gracious enough to accommodate my order despite their two-week notice policy—I needed them in just a week. While deciding on my cupcakes, I treated myself to a funnel cake, and it was absolutely amazing—delicious, melt-in-your-mouth perfection! It instantly took me back to all the places I’ve ever enjoyed a funnel cake.

My cupcake order turned out fantastic, and my son and his guests were thrilled. A wonderful experience all around—very happy customer!“

“I had me a Carmel Ribbon Frappe. Really good. I can't make it home with the cookies I eat all of them.“

“My fiancé and I want to thank the entire staff at Vero for an AMAZING experience! The pizza is by far some of the best pizza I have ever had in 40+ years! I will gladly come back from NJ to eat here again! My compliments to the Chef and the staff. We now have a home away from home. As we Italians say GRAZIE TANTE! 🇮🇹🙏“

“I visited The Sweet Spot after seeing their Croffles online and just had to try them! I ordered the strawberry croffle along with the twisted ice cream (matcha & ube), and both were delicious! The croffle had the perfect balance of chewy and sweet, and the ice cream flavors paired really well together.

I was a little bummed that even though the menu listed several croffle topping options, only strawberry and chocolate/almond were actually available. Hopefully they expand the selection soon, because I’d love to try more next time!

The shop itself is super cute, but it was pretty warm inside—it felt like the AC wasn’t running, which made it a bit uncomfortable to sit and enjoy the treats.

Overall, the food was great and I’d still recommend checking it out if you’re in the area and want something sweet and unique!“