37 Best Ice Cream Shops near Lyndhurst

“So, I'm not a fan of frozen custard, but my family members are and they picked this over Mitchell's. They were very pleased as none of us had ever been to an East Coast before.

They got butter pecan and traditional vanilla cones while I got a Tin Roof sundae.

They loved theirs! Mine was okay, but I just prefer ice cream over the custard flavor.

They were steady busy while we were there, nothing too long of a wait and the service was great.

All in all, my family members loved it, so that is all that counts for me.“

“Great icecream and carrot cake!“

“Stopped in while in Cle with the family. Everyone loved it. I personally thought the Duo was a great idea for all the people who can never decide on what they want. I had peanut butter something yogurt and it was great. Less sugary than normal. Everyone was happy and prices were actually fair.“

“Great ice cream. While it can get crowded, line moved quickly. If you're there to just get a pint, can go to freezer to grab it and check out.

There's a small counter for children to color which is a nice touch. Kids love the train overhead as well“

“It's hard for us to find a place that provides a few vegan options for my wife (dairy allergy in her case) and this place does! Interesting options too. The ice cream was amazing and everyone was so friendly! Cool place and highly recommend.

Dietary restrictions: Vegan and dairy free.“

“I love bringing my 4 year old here for ice cream and coloring. The ice cream is always delicious - and the atmosphere is top notch. I love the fresh floral arrangements, stylish decor and train. My son loves the coloring station and chance to just relax while he enjoys a treat

Dietary restrictions: Vegan options available

Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly, with a coloring table

Wheelchair accessibility: This establishment is wheelchair accessible“

“EXCELLENT!!! [Original] EXCELLENT!!!“

“Good quality ice cream. A bit pricier than DQ or other smaller ice cream venues. Staff is friendly. They accept both cash and card. It can get quite busy on weekend evening and parking is sometimes and issue.“

“Nicole was amazing with my kids!! They had the BEST time at her shop and declared it “the best day ever!” We drove up just as Nicole was returning from an event and she was so kind and generous. The Ice Cream Pops and Cookie Sandwiches were delicious! Thanks again!!“

“First things first if you’re hoping to give foster’s a try make you you head to the ATM first because they are a cash only establishment. I tried coming a few weeks ago with Apple Pay in hand and had to try again lol. The shop itself is very quaint. It’s only big enough to fit two customers or families at once. The offer a variety of flavors of ice cream along with slushies, malts and even pies. Their portion size is massive! I got two scoops thinking it would be a typical scoop and it had to be about the size of 3 scoops of each flavor. I couldn’t even finish it lol. I got the banana and salted caramel brownie and my daughter got Irish coffee and chocolate. Two flavors is considered a medium so it was $6.25 each. A little much but now seeing the serving size; I completely understand! There is seating outside the parlor to enjoy your treat. The young lady inside was very kind and helpful in letting me knowing what flavors to try. I’d definitely visit again!“

“Ice cream was amazing!! Honestly best i ever had! But the people there kept just starring us, like if they had never seen a Mexican before, i felt uncomfortable while eating my ice cream😔 didnt feel comfortable at all“

“Honey Hut is a classy family favorite. You can't go wrong pleasing a crowd with desserts.Milkshakes are a favorite of mine! And there are plenty of scoops, sundaes, and floats.Their staff is eager to delight and they deliver a smile and a big thank you as you leave. I love feeling welcome.Inside of store seems outdated and very plain inside lobby area. Spruce up is needed. This place could thrive with a remodel.“

“My daughter and her friend picked up a coffee gelato for me. It was Divine. Smooth and creamy without any artificial taste. I will be going back again and sometime the stack was wonderful so friendly that you felt like you were having dessert with your family.“

“The owners make it special ❤️“

“My daughter and I went into Crumbl this week and we were so excited to try a new flavor this week! I had the confetti cake cookie and it was a confetti in my mouth of flavors! It was amazing. My daughter grabbed the strawberry cheesecake cake and it looked amazing she took two bites and said it was too sweet for her...insert sad face. Overall it was a good visit outside of the young people that work in the evenings, they never speak when you come in and you have to get their attention for them to help you on top of they act like it's a hassle to help or work at work...the irony in that is insane. Luckily they have multiple locations so we will visit another one in the future.“

“I love this location but at certain times of the day. During the day the customer service is on point!!! But evening / night it’s trash. The younger employees be needing home training before they get a job because their customer service sucks. But anywho during the day, I love this location and the cookies!“

“Stopped by this ice cream shop with some friends on this Friday afternoon, and the ice cream itself was really good and is definitely worth checking out. Matt was super nice and really knew his stuff. It was my first time there, and he took the time to explain the flavors and give recommendations, which made the experience even better.

The only downside was the atmosphere. There was a girl working who seemed really upset, and it was pretty noticeable. It kind of brought down the vibe a bit, which was a little awkward.

Still, the ice cream was amazing , and Matt made a good impression. I’d come back, just hoping for a better overall energy next time.“

“It’s not fancy, but it is great. A staple in the neighborhood for my entire life. The ice cream is a fair price and the experience is not to be missed.“

“OMG!!!! Just try to Dubai chocolate bar and the Dubai parfait it is the best thing I’ve ever tasted!!!! A MOST KEEP ITEM! And the owner is such a sweetheart!! 1000/10“

“Great ice cream, great service!!“

“Go see Reid and Shayla ASAP“

“Excellent ice cream. Quick and friendly service.“

“Stopped by while on a weekend trip to Cleveland and after a day seeing Lake Erie at Sim's Park. Delicious banana split and my son loved his vanilla custard cone! My sister liked her sundae as well! Cute little Custard stand and delicious on a hot day!“

“The ice cream. Their lemon custard was delicious and the service was good.“

“I cannot tell you enough about this place. It is so good and the workers are very friendly and helpful. I've been there twice in 4 days. They have different cookies every week. They change them on Sundays. I have not been disappointed yet. I love this place.“

“A huge THANK YOU to TIFFANY in the bakery today! She worked with me with ordering my Son’s birthday cake for Saturday. I came in short notice to order. Great customer service and just a kindhearted person. Thank you Tiffany!“

“It’s so good yu will love it“

“My family and I living coming here after a long hard day of work and/or school...It has that special neighborhood feel, and the employees, (mostly college and high school students), are awesome!“

“Good ice cream, concretes, and fare foods. Usually pretty quick and the drive thru moves fast.

Dietary restrictions: I have a wheat allergy. Not quite as sensitive as severe celiacs. But i haven't had any issues if I just avoid the clear wheat products. But they do say they don't use dedicated GF equipment. So very sensitive people take caution.“

“I had me a Carmel Ribbon Frappe. Really good. I can't make it home with the cookies I eat all of them.“

“My fiancé and I want to thank the entire staff at Vero for an AMAZING experience! The pizza is by far some of the best pizza I have ever had in 40+ years! I will gladly come back from NJ to eat here again! My compliments to the Chef and the staff. We now have a home away from home. As we Italians say GRAZIE TANTE! 🇮🇹🙏“

“I went in to order cupcakes for my son’s birthday, and the owner was gracious enough to accommodate my order despite their two-week notice policy—I needed them in just a week. While deciding on my cupcakes, I treated myself to a funnel cake, and it was absolutely amazing—delicious, melt-in-your-mouth perfection! It instantly took me back to all the places I’ve ever enjoyed a funnel cake.

My cupcake order turned out fantastic, and my son and his guests were thrilled. A wonderful experience all around—very happy customer!“

“I am an out-of-towner visiting family. I am amazed at how good the pizza and calzones are! Huge portions, fantastic flavor, generous with toppings, and great service! I thought it was pricy until I got my food; WELL WORTH IT! Delivery was early, food was HOT. 10 out of 10 for me!“

“It's fast food so that why the three. We constantly are at this place. Flamethrower burger is good, so are the chicken tenders. We go thru drive thru. No matter how long the line is the line moves fast. No attitudes and customer service is up there with Chic a Fila.“

“I enjoyed my experience there, but it came to my attention that the food items that I ate were not vegan. I specifically asked if the food items that I ordered were vegan and was told that they were and I sent a friend there and the cashier said that they were not vegan so she ended up not buying anything. I had the Ube ice cream, cheesecake, and the Oreo cookie cake. I won't be returning because I am plant based. I hate that I was misinformed, because goole sent me here. I was there December 30, 2024 at 6:52p. I posted this on Tik Tok and have a number of followers that I will have to update.“

“I got the oreo ice cream cake. The made it perfectly. Had to adjust my son's name. Everything else was great! The color he chose was great. Didn't even know there were those options. This is why it pays to ask questions. It wasn't even extra for the little things.“

“Ordered a gluten-free strawberry casada cake for my 33 year old nieces birthday...she never had casada despite being a pastry chef! It was awesome! She loved it too because it wasn't overly sweet! Great job 0:-)“