36 Best Ice Cream Shops near Mayfield Heights

“I love this store. Everything that comes out of it is delicious. The staff is amazing , always courteous and friendly. I usually do preorders and it’s always ready or just about ready when I get there. Couldn’t be happier with this Crumbl store!!“

“Go see Reid and Shayla ASAP“

“I got the oreo ice cream cake. The made it perfectly. Had to adjust my son's name. Everything else was great! The color he chose was great. Didn't even know there were those options. This is why it pays to ask questions. It wasn't even extra for the little things.“

“When we went, there were 4 vegan ice cream options (though they were sold out of 1). We got the sampler trio to try the 3 available. All so good. The buckeye was fudgy deliciousness. My husband said it was the best ice cream he's ever had. We'll definitely go back.“

“A great location with a lot of options (something for everyone 🍦. The staff are always friendly, they move the lines quickly, and the prices are affordable. My favorite is the key lime or berry crumble. They even have already frozen options to pick up and take home.“

“My visit today was on a Sunday at approx 6pm or so. I accidently placed the wrong Sundae order and was willing to eat it anyway, but I thought what the heck I'll just be honest and explain what happened. The staff was nice enough to correct my order and offer the Turtle Sundae I desired which was delicious as usual.

Here is the Plus/Minus on this store:
Plus - The ice cream always tastes delicious; the service is fast and excellent every time. Even if the line is long it always moves fast. The temperature in the dining area is always comfy whether it is hot or cold outside. The dining area is always clean. Lots of delicious flavors and speciaty items like shakes and sundaes. This has become my fave ice cream spot in NEO.
Minus: Approx 6 unruly, loud, disruptive youth arrived near the end of my visit. I wanted to escort them right out the door, fortunately they didn't stay long. Perhaps this is a new trend in Solon because a similar thing happened in nearby Chick-Fil-A Solon a few weeks ago. Oops I spoke too soon, the bad kis came back :(“

“Highly addicting.....but we'll worth it“

“Good quality ice cream. A bit pricier than DQ or other smaller ice cream venues. Staff is friendly. They accept both cash and card. It can get quite busy on weekend evening and parking is sometimes and issue.“

“EXCELLENT!!! [Original] EXCELLENT!!!“

“Great donuts and better ice cream. Would highly recommend this place“

“Honey hut is my favorite ice cream place in cleveland! I hope we can get another location on the east side“

“My daughter and her friend picked up a coffee gelato for me. It was Divine. Smooth and creamy without any artificial taste. I will be going back again and sometime the stack was wonderful so friendly that you felt like you were having dessert with your family.“

“Ice cream was amazing!! Honestly best i ever had! But the people there kept just starring us, like if they had never seen a Mexican before, i felt uncomfortable while eating my ice cream😔 didnt feel comfortable at all“

“CASH ONLY!!!

First time stopping in and despite the sign on the door, which we totally didn't see, we soon found ourselves in a minor panic; they only take cash.

I ordered 2 scoops of Rocky Road which was huge! So much that I needed a cup to put it and my sugar cone in. Very generous portion for $6.50.

When I tried to hand my debit card to them I was informed they only take cash. Thank goodness I had $10 stashed in my car.

Other than the payment inconvenience, the ice cream was very good and again, a generous portion. Nice little homemade ice cream shop.

Fun bonus, the white spoon turns blue when in the cold ice cream.“

“love the chocolate or vanilla custard. you can see it being made while standing in line“

“The owners make it special ❤️“

“It’s not fancy, but it is great. A staple in the neighborhood for my entire life. The ice cream is a fair price and the experience is not to be missed.“

“I can't review this any easier than simply saying everything is delicious. Their sundaes are as big as a house, ice cream is yummy, plus the hot dogs are tasty too. Love“

“The very best part of sweet roz is the family that runs it! Charles is one of the sweetest people on earth. Doesn't matter what day you've had he puts a smile on your face. My daughters and I always leave feeling satisfied with our treat and warmed by the infectipus glow and optimism of Charles and Roz“

“best place ever. all the unique flavors are spot on 😎“

“The best Graeter’s location ever! As a huge fan of Graeter’s, I go to different locations. But this location offers the best value. One scoop is bigger than 6.25 oz (standard). Very friendly staff, and short wait. Easy to find parking. Black raspberry chip is the flavor! It goes really well with the cone:)“

“Valley Villa is one of those rare ice cream places that has truly perfected the Turtle Sunday, as well as many, many more. My favorite part about Valley Villa Custard has been the new renovations and evolving menu, always coming up with innovations in the industry with a strong staff to support. Bravo Valley Villa, best of luck this Summer.“

“Great ice cream, great service!!“

“I love how this Dairy Queen’s parking lot is easiest to get in and out of because of its size. The one closest to me is so small the line is on the street on busier days. I also thought it was very cute that they had coloring books and markers out for the kids inside. It made the long line bearable for my little one. Although they were busy they were still kind once we got to the front of the line and I appreciate that. We’ll have to come back for those $3.79 specials on Wednesdays!“

“My family and I living coming here after a long hard day of work and/or school...It has that special neighborhood feel, and the employees, (mostly college and high school students), are awesome!“

“I love this location but at certain times of the day. During the day the customer service is on point!!! But evening / night it’s trash. The younger employees be needing home training before they get a job because their customer service sucks. But anywho during the day, I love this location and the cookies!“

“Perfect for anytime and now“

“First visit this evening with a small group of friends, had 14 different menu items, drinks, apps, pizzas and desserts The staff was attentive and swift, a nice back room to sit and relax with friends. Everything we tried was wonderful, the staff was flexible bring the hot honey for the pizza on the side. All five of us left comfortably stuffed . Will absolutely be returning. 10 out of 10 pictures of drinks and dessert, eat the pizza to quickly“

“Highly recommend trying! Soo good!“

“A huge THANK YOU to TIFFANY in the bakery today! She worked with me with ordering my Son’s birthday cake for Saturday. I came in short notice to order. Great customer service and just a kindhearted person. Thank you Tiffany!“

“The ice cream. Their lemon custard was delicious and the service was good.“

“I love their ice cream been going there for years“

“Best frozen custard we’ve ever had—creamy goodness!!! The dipped waffle cone didn’t fail to impress either-plenty of thick chocolate on the rim. Will definitely be back!!!“

“I am an out-of-towner visiting family. I am amazed at how good the pizza and calzones are! Huge portions, fantastic flavor, generous with toppings, and great service! I thought it was pricy until I got my food; WELL WORTH IT! Delivery was early, food was HOT. 10 out of 10 for me!“

“I had me a Carmel Ribbon Frappe. Really good. I can't make it home with the cookies I eat all of them.“