50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Macedonia

“We ordered online for a later pickup, but our order wasn't ready. The manager apologized several times while I waited. When she brought out our pizzas, she thanked me for waiting and waived our bill, which was very kind and unexpected. The pizzas were delicious (and worth the wait!). We will definitely be back.“

“It was nice to go out with family and relax for the night“

“Tried Valley Pizza for the first time tonight.Supreme Pizza. Wow.reminds me of the neat little mom and pop Pizza parlors from back it the day 1970s.Lots of flavor, even the dough tastes good.cant wait to try the other sauces.Very well done.Ill be back soon.“

“I tried this place with my mom and kid's on August 1st for the first time and I have to say it was really good I order a pepperoni pizza and split it with my kid's and then have chocolate 🍫 and strawberry 🍓 Gelato together it was so good I recommend it and trying it 😊“

“I just wanted to say that there pizza is the best on this side of town and the new owners are very nice they have my vote for tastiest pie around???.“

“I enjoyed a salad, pizza and half a carafe of white Zinfandel. Excellent food with a delightful waitress named Lexie.“

“Amazing pizza and atmosphere to either eat outside around a fire or indoor! They also have a great full bar. Amy is your go to girl for amazing service“

“Best pizza in town!“

“I have worked in the Garfield Hts area for almost 8 years now and anytime I think of having pizza for lunch or dinner, I think of East Coast Pizza. Their pies are always hot with fresh ingredients. Delivery service is great however, if I order pickup the parking has never been an issue. My staff and ladies at the group home love them.“

“Another Road-Trip pizza review!! Ordered an 8-cut pepperoni and sausage. Took 40 mins on a Friday night (pretty normal). The pizza sauce was savory, the dough was tasty and the crust was crunchy, sausage was normal, the pepperoni was their downfall in the rating... I think the whole pizza had 16 prices (not joking with 2 each slice). But the atmosphere was spectacular!! I don't think you can take it all in with one visit!! We will be back, but they really need to work on that pepperoni issue 😁“

“It is the best pizza I have had I recommend this place it is worth but the pizza size is bigger then you think“

“Awesome pizza!! And their salad is also very good with their homemade italian dressing. We go quite often to the Brecksville or Northfield location. When I brought my grandkids they said it was the best pizza they ever had. Highly recommended!!!“

“There are a lot of great, independently owned pizza joints in the Cleveland area. Romito's is a prime example. I would place them in my personal top 5. The sauce has great tomato character and is not too sweet. The cheese is ample and well baked. The sausage is hand pinched, and the crust is nice and hearty. I would suggest Romito's to anyone I know.“

“Parking: Very nice parking lot also free i always find a parking spot.

Kid-friendliness: They are very friendly with kids very nice down to heart people. Best pizza in all of Cleveland I drove here all the way from Pittsburgh just to try it and i am very satisfied“

“Im a truckdriver delivering at amazon warehouse shop is on corner by truck entrance it had great pizza and one of the best cheesesteak subs I've had in along long time... the man in the shop was awesome very professional and personable definitely will be back“

“The pizza is the best ! The Fiesta Salad with the House dressing is my absolute favorite. The best pizza in Northeast Ohio!“

“After searching for good pizza in Cleveland for a decade, I finally found The Tomato Company <3 Easily the best pizza in the area!“

“Holy cow so good ? ?
Got a thin crust pepperoni pizza with extra cheese and a BBQ chicken pizza with veggies and I am not disappointed! Will definitely make this a regular cause baaabaaay it's the best pizza I have had so far since being in ohio. The delivery guy was really nice and delivered with care. Thanks you guys for a great dinner.“

“Sagamore Hills has equalled the quality the Maple Heights original achieved BITD. They finally have online ordering as well, well sorta. One star penalty for forcing “Skipify” which is untrustworthy and a hot mess.“

“The WINNNNGS were sooo good! not all wings are created equal and these wings were really good! I like how they were crispy and flavorful and not salty or overbearing with the seasoning. The pizza was amazing but I’m guessing you guys already know that ?“

“Romeo’s is awesome! The only thing I’m concerned is that I didn’t receive a full order of wings listed on the menu, in which a full order is 10-12 wings. I only received 8. Other than that I will continue to order from this establishment!!!“

“When I heard they had a chicken crust pizza, I just had to try it, you know? It is, I will say, the smallest whole pizza I have ever seen, but oh boy! It's out of this world and completely worth it! With all their crazy topping options, this is a pizza joint you won't get tired of soon!

Dietary restrictions: Chicken crust pizza for keto dieters“

“I recently left a 5 star review but unfortunately that had drastically changed. Do not get me wrong, they have good food. BUT, Twice in a row now, I've been ripped off by this store. Online they have deals and twice I've tried ordering the '16" xl 1 topping pizza and 6 Pepperoni rolls for $25.99'. After 5 minutes of being on hold because nobody knew what deals they had, i was finally able to redeme the online deal. This last time ordering, we got home and realized they gave us a 12" pizza.... i thought the pizza looked small when my husband got home but we were hungry. it wasnt until the next day, i noticed the bottom of the box says 12". soooo, instead of getting an extra large, we got a small? either update your website and deals, or educate your staff on the deals you have!! $26 for a small pizza and 6 skimpy Pepperoni rolls??? Complete ripped off!!! Attached is a screenshot of the deal in their website. Pic is of the 12" pizza box.“

“Service has gone down hill in recent years. Biggest problem with poor service is that it shows in the food. This was once an excellent establishment for quality delivery, not any longer. There is zero consistency between orders other than something is always missing from the orders. Completely different from when this location opened up several years ago.

Edited for follow-up: Owner reached out after our latest mishap and was more than understanding, even giving us a generous and unnecessary gift card/credit. Customer service from the store manager and owner was fantastic. If nothing else, try them out based solely on the customer service from management and beyond.“

“I went for the first time today and will definitely be going back. I purchased a cheese danish, raspberry filled croissant, and fresh bread. All three were absolutely delicious! I am so excited to go again and try more pastries/breads.“

“I love this location!! After moving to this area 5 years ago i have had little good/positive experiences with most businesses. Whether it's the employees bad attitude or the food being not worth the money. The few times I have ordered from here, every employee has been respectful, kind, patient and has a great work ethic. And the food is always fresh and exactly what we ask for. I live very close to a little ceasers drive thru, but will drive past it every time to come here.
Good job guys! You are definitely noticed and appreciated!! 💜“

“I really like ordering from this particular location. They always have the items listed on the menu, and the service is great and very respectful. Thank you for showing us that there are people working fast food who still care about customers.“

“Absolutely delicious gluten-free/cauliflower crust pizza! I love it. The sauce is perfect - not too sweet, and just the right amount of savory & spice. My daughter and husband enjoy the traditional pies, as well! Highly recommended!

Dietary restrictions: Cauliflower crust is yum! And the sauce is absolutely perfect. I also appreciate that the size is slightly larger than what you get at other locations.

Kid-friendliness: My daughter loves this pizza!“

“Just so you know if you order mozzarella sticks they are not made with mozzarella and does in fact have a unique taste. Not the greatest…and the pizza tastes like gas station pizza. Grab some from the Sunoco around the corner for cheaper ?‍♀️ nice people though “

“We got the meatloaf, cabbage w/ kielbasa, macaroni and cheese, & cornbread muffin. Listen…

I don’t get on here to speak up about very many places; a place has really, REALLY gotta impress me for that. That dinner was absolutely phenomenal. Everything was on point and seasoned just perfectly. Y’all put y’all foot in that!! First time customer and I will be back soon all the way from Painesville.“

“This is the best pizza around, period. The sauce is delicious, and just wait till until you try the cheese. I don’t know how they do it, because they’re also the least expensive pizza! I’ve never had a bad experience here, you won’t be disappointed.
(Ordered: Pepperoni & Sausage Pizza / Large - $15 🤯)“

“Food is food. Let's be honest. You get what you pay for, but more importantly, it's the staff. The guy that took my order is a rock star! It was late and hot, and in there, he still took my order with a smile. I appreciate you guys tipping the staff. there are worth it!“

“I really like their pan pizzas but our thing to order when the grandkids are over. And I always get at least one double pepperoni. But my last several orders the pepperoni has been extremely spicy that the kids won’t eat it. Did you change vendors? Perhaps you can offer a spicy and a mild.“

“We have been patrons of The Courtyard for many years.
We hadn't been there for several months over the summer, but I am happy to say that dinner this evening was right on par.
Cheddar burger cooked perfectly, fries hot and fresh. Teriyaki chicken flavorful, veggies perfectly al dante. Not to mention the garlic cheese bread! Always a favorite.
Happy to know that The Courtyard continues to strive for perfection.“

“I am leaving a recommend for now with a 2.75/5* rating. The first two pizzas I had were solid and I really liked them. This third one I got is a pepp pizza only and has so much sauce the entire slice accordions in your hand. It’s really bad. I called the restaurant and they didn’t seem much to care so 2 strikes in one pizza. If I get another one that’s this bad I’ll update review to reflect. If nothing else this place definitely has major consistency problems“

“My family and I order from Papa John's regularly. Steel is the person I usually deal with. He always greets me with a smile and is incredibly helpful. All the staff is friendly when I enter and the individuals by Steel collectively help with my order, bag my drink and open the door for me. I sincerely appreciate the collective effort and Steel's demeanor. The service is great and we are always happy with our order.“

“This is a Solid Mom & Pa pizza place. Their Pizza, subs, and Calzone Sandwiches are the best and at very reasonable prices. This place is a little Gem hidden in plane site. I highly recommend giving them a try. Its like getting a home cooked meal from your favorite family member.“

“First off. OMG!! The guy there was the sweetest human being ever. I apologize I don’t remember his name, but he was so sweet. He asked me what I preferred due to being pregnant, he wanted to make sure he covered my cravings, while telling me sweet stories about his family. The food was amazing. But he’s the real reason for the 5 stars. Ladies better go snatch him up. He’s amazing.“

“best gluten free pizza EVER“

“My husband and I ordered wings and pizza last night for delivery and the food was delish! Our delivery driver was very nice. Teresa’s is our #1 place for wings and pizza. We’ve ordered twice in the last 2 weeks LOL! 100% 2 thumbs up! Trust me ya’ll.“

“food and Bowling, atmosphere“

“I ordered a veggie pizza and this is the best pizza i have ever had from little ceasars….others store food is not fresh and not hot…this pizza is amazing and i just moved here…THANK YOU ☺️“

“I had the calamari appetizer with a Bianca and verde pizza. The pizza was crushed garlic, arugula, Evo, cheese. Definitely enjoyed the flavors.“

“Amazing deep dish delivered hot!“

“I have had the pleasure of ordering from here since they have opened. The specials lately have been phenomenal love the change up! I ordered the Firebird Sandwich and The Pickled Pig Pizza, amazing I hope they keep both. Also always order the focaccia bread, you won’t be disappointed.“

“Last Saturday I ordered a Carry-out special consisting of a large New York style Sausage pizza. I had never been to Domino’s before because of their poor reputation. I must say that it was one of the best pizza’s I have eaten in a long time. I finished the last piece today and it tasted just as good as fresh. Thanks. I will be back. I gave 5 start for Atmosphere because Google won’t let me post unless I gave a rating.“

“I was not aware this store had the BUFFET! I needed something quick and stumbled in here. Good food at a great value. Clean restaurant. Hostess-Waitress, Heather, was very attentive. All-you-can eat pizza, salad, pasta, and desert pizza, I’ll be back, soon!“

“My wife and I have been watching customers picking up their pizza for a long time while enjoying our coffee next door, so today we decided to go and try Augies Pizza, I can say is one of the best pizza we ever tried, from the crust to the sauce, customer service and cleanliness everything was perfect.
Thank you for having such a great prod, I will recommend Augies Pizza 100%“

“The food and service is always top notch! Last time I was there I got their seasonal Harvest Chicken Salad and have ordered it 3 times since for delivery! It is always fresh and the quality of all the ingredients are perfection! The chicken doesn’t have an ounce of fat! Last time I ordered I also ordered the steak salad for my daughter and she absolutely couldn’t say how delicious it was. We wanted to order them both again for dinner the next day but they were closed! So we’re going there tomorrow for dinner again!!“