New American Restaurants near Mayfield Heights, OH

“Had dinner last night at the bar. The bartenders were excellent as usual and the food was great. Thanks!“

“This was my first time at Cork-N-Bottle. I was very pleased. I honestly did not know what to expect but I was very happy when I walked out! I sat in a booth and was seen from one of the bar tenders. Right away I was approached and served very good drinks and food.“

“Amazing food! Best dinner I have had in a long time- service was great, but food was over the top.“

“My husband and I Stopped in randomly after driving past on a Saturday afternoon. We loved it. Sat at the bar. Talked to one of the owners who served up a fantastic cranberry orange margarita! Cozy atmosphere. We shared the breakfast burger with the most perfectly fried hash browns and a side of the Brussel sprouts! No complaints. Everything was delicious! Highly recommend!“

“Always a go to spot for the Wife and I if we are in the area. The food is always terrific and every is very welcoming. Compliments to the Chef and house!“

“Amazing! This was our first time here for a family birthday party, and it did not disappoint. Mary was hands down the best waitress we’ve ever had—top-notch friendly, incredibly informative, and she truly made the entire night memorable. We can’t say enough great things about her. The drinks were outstanding. We tried five or six off the menu, and every single one was handcrafted and delicious. Favorites were the Old Fashioned, Cat’s Meow, espresso martinis, and my absolute favorite—the Frosted Sour. The food was out of this world, and the place itself is super cute with a great ambiance. We’ll definitely be back!“

“Wow! What an absolutely wonderful place to celebrate our 25th anniversary! The staff was so kind, especially Michael and Genevieve!!!!! Loved talking with both of them! The food here is incredible and very creative. Every single thing on your plate serves a purpose to the overall taste. Superb wine selection as well! We also loved its overall ambience and elegance. Hope to return someday!!!“

“Great find! Would never have guessed a gem in a little strip mall. Super clean and tastefully decorated. (I am bias to Roosters however) Top notch service! The place was hopping and the staff stayed on top of it. Chefs super friendly and thanked us for coming. Food was promptly brought out hot, coffee cup was never empty. Great selection of breakfast items, we wanted to try everything! Reasonably priced! Highly recommend! Please support local establishments like The Sleepy Rooster!“

“Great environment. Good food. Amazing service“

“Great food! All fresh made in house 😋“

“Fantastic lunch with a great friend! couldn't decide between a couple items so the waitress suggested their Toofer - basically a soup and sandwich. I got the Seafood Bisque cup and a half Ruben sandwich. Both tasted great and waitress was spot on (there when we needed her and not there when we didn't need her). I'll definitely go back and try other menu options! RECOMMEND!“

“awesome service, very friendly and delicious food!“

“Valet parking and the perfect spot to hang after the game! Kitchen was open late. Burger was amazing and the chicken was delicious as was my mojito. Shout out to all the guys. Thanks for everything! ❤️💛 Can’t wait to go back.“

“Was on vacation and looking foe a place to eat that was different and found Kitchen Social. We had the rolls with the honey butter and I had the mushroom pizza, my friend had another pizza and we both loved our food. The staff was awesome too. We enjoyed it so much that we went back the next day and tried sandwiches. Everything in this place is great.“

“C & S is a terrific option for an evening out. Consistently good food, yummy cocktails and always a spirited atmosphere. Shoutout to Brett - Friendly, strikes up just the right amount of chit chat, and pays attention to the customer’s needs. Give that man a free full course meal! 😊“

“Watched the Ohio State game at the brewery Saturday night. The pretzel nuggets are great, and the pierogi tacos are amazing. Everyone enjoyed their food and their brews are great too. Highly, highly recommend.“

“Cocktails were perfect. We were served by Adam, and he was extremely attentive to our needs, and then some. Great service. Will definitely return again.“

“The Fairmount is a perfect mix of all you could want! Amazing, delicious food, beautiful atmosphere on the large, enclosed green terrace and professional , friendly staff. I have never had a negative experience and I’m there often!“

“This place is way underrated!
We are not from Ohio, passing through on our way back to Buffalo, NY. The food was superb! So fresh!!! We ordered fried pickles - they were super fresh with shaved scallions on top and a homemade sourcream fresh dipping sauce. So good! My husband had a perfectly cooked pickle burger and hand cut fries, I had the Ruben and fries. Both were delicious! Homemade Russian dressing on the Ruben.
The service was really friendly, fast but not too fast, happy! Just like the atmosphere.
We would frequent this place if we lived near by!“

“Paragon Social's ambiance screams grown and sexy. The food taste great, always hot and fresh. The bartenders are welcoming, and knowledgeable on how to make drinks very well. And this is a great place to have parties.“

“Gorgeous redesign, loved the menu, great service. Loved everything we ate... caesar salad, curry chicken and the crab & caviar. I don't usually love creme brûlée but the Bourbon creme brûlée was the best I've ever had! Chocolate pot was delightful, too. The attention to detail, care for fine ingredients, and presentation is very evident. Drinks - had the Smoked Rosewood and Pineapple Smash, will come back just for those drinks... or desserts. Great service as we remembered from Umami. Welcome back, great job!“

“First time stopping by today and I'm glad I did! I loved the Polish girl boxed meal-hadn't had one in years! It was delicious! 😋 Friendly service in a tiny, quaint spot! ☺“

“Excellent food!“

“Food is good, however in the past they along with other restaurants showed appreciation for Veterans by offering a complimentary meal to the Veteran(s) on Veterans Day. They don't do that anymore. Now its a complimentary ice cream desert and a gift card for an appetizer for your next visit. Don't come here Veterans... dont come here on Veterans Day. Go to Outback or Applebee's where you can actually feel appreciated the one day out of the year.“

“Shae was such a good server! She was fast and the food was good. We will definitely be back :)“

“Fantastic establishment! Never have had a bad meal or drink in almost 20 years!“

“What a hidden gem. My husband and I stumbled upon Nordstrom Grill a few weeks ago and it was like we were transported back in time. The wait staff couldn't be more helpful. The soups are amazing and will warm you up on a cold winter day . . . and the burger might also be the best in Cleveland. I only wish it were open for breakfast!“

“Thankfully they were open late because we needed somewhere moderately priced with decent food to take my brother out for a birthday dinner. The food was a B-, service could have definitely been better and the atmosphere was average. Drinks could improve and steaks ordered were reasonable. Would go back but more so thankful for the late hours!“

“Moved to Ohio a few months ago, after trying a few place in the neighborhood, Saw people playing corn hole in the parking lot. Decided to try it out and brought my wife. As sooner as we walked in, 1st it was busy, but was greeted right away, by what I thought was the owner, ( later found out she was working in the kitchen) . Long story short, they made us feel like we found a new home!“

“💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙“

“I talked my husband into going. We went on Friday evening, we sat at the bar, service was great. As we sat there I heard a saxophone with my back to the band. I asked my husband is that a sax I hear. He said yes. The band was good. My husband said "this is going to be my new go to place". Nice crowd.“

“Great food. A little on the noisy side. Popular spot.“

“TLP has quickly become a staple in our date night routine! Every visit is consistently amazing. The food is bursting with flavor and offers a unique twist on classic favorites—we’re always impressed. The atmosphere is just as incredible; every staff member we’ve met is genuinely friendly and seems to truly enjoy what they do. Special shoutout to Peter, the manager— he always goes above and beyond to make us feel like family and ensures everything runs smoothly. If you’re thinking about going—do it! You will NOT be disappointed!“

“Great food and great service. I love that the staff doesn’t have a high turnover and are always pleasant.“

“We went for dinner on a Saturday night. I made the reservation for 5:30pm, but we were ready to eat at 5 when they opened. I asked if they could seat us and they did graciously. Our server, Madison, was very good. attentive but not hovering. She checked on us often. My dining companion had a specialty Christmas eggnog and I had the tequila flights. The eggnog was a little different in that it had kahlua as well as rum. It was delicious. The flights were varied and interesting. My friend had the salmon which she just kept raving about, saying she would get it every time we came. It had a spinach base with risotto and a bourbon sauce. I had the short ribs which fell off the bone and melted in my mouth. They came with candied carrots, brussel sprouts and grits. Perfect. We were so full, we skipped dessert. We love Millcreek. I think it is one of the best restaurants in any casino, except Vegas.“

“Excellent seafood. I eat seafood all the time and the shrimp here are large and of good quality. I got a rice bowl with curry sauce. The sausage crawfish and shrimp were plentiful. Curry sauce was fabulous with just the right amount of heat. I ordered medium hot. First time ordering and I will definitely be ordering again.“

“Our first visit and we were very impressed with the food quality and selections of Irish foods we never had before but absolutely loved - excellent service! The place is really big and has such a great atmosphere and we will be back for sure... one of our new favorites!“

“Nice atmosphere and friendly staff!“

“Everything was just about what it should be for a sports bar. People were great, plenty of TVs, pool and dart area. I got the hot chicken with onion rings/stars and there were not that many of them. Amp up the portionw for things like this and we are 5 stars.“

“I love this place! Been going here since forever !! I love the staff !!! They make sure I’m always good !!!“

“This place is the best ain't enough stars to click they need 10 stars and the sever we had is the best me and my family ate very happy and will come as much as possible thank to or waiter jenevieve I hope I spelled it right .she the best person ever a big plus to yell establishment.“

“We’ve enjoyed many wonderful tasting menus over the years, but our New Year’s Eve experience at JoJo’s truly stood out as something special. Executive Chef Landon and his incredible Executive Sous Chef, Joe, presented our family with one of the most memorable and perfectly executed dinners we’ve had. Since we couldn’t decide between the options, we shared everything, and we’re so glad we did. The stone crab claws and lamb lollipops were an outstanding start. For entrées, my husband chose the bone‑in ribeye while I had the lobster ricotta agnolotti with black truffle. Both were exceptional. We ended the night by sharing the Luxardo cheesecake and the champagne‑poached pears, which were the perfect finish. The champagne and wine we were suggested were spot‑on, though the wine pairing would have been a great choice as well. The management team, with Mark and Ryan leading the ship that night, made the evening seamless, and our bartender, Michael, was an absolute professional. truly, everyone there is fantastic. Chef Landon once shared a quote with us from Oscar Wilde: “To the strangers that become friends and those friends become family.” That sentiment perfectly captures what we love most about every experience here. We could not recommend this establishment more.“

“Amazing food and unmatched service! Highly recommend!“

“From a city 2 hours away but was able to experience Frederick’s today. From start to finish everything was A1 The atmosphere begging you in. The service was top-notch and when the food came out, oh my. I had the red snapper and was blown away. The presentation of the plate of eye catching. The taste of food was mouthwatering good. I pierced the fish with macaroni and cheese and yams. After takes the macaroni and cheese, I ordered some to go. I have the smoked old-fashioned and it was one of the best that I’ve had in a long time. I impression was I’m not sure how I got such a great meal at a value price. I definitely will be back along with encouraging anyone to experience this wonderful restaurant“

“We are new to the neighborhood and happy to be just a short walk from TOLI! Food service and vibe are all great. Can’t wait to go back!“

“Having moved from Florida's Gulf Coast last year, I had yet to find any food in Ohio I liked as well as Sarasota. Last night at Heck's, my hope was restored! The caliber of textures and tastes was fantastic! Delicious and clearly well thought out menu options for anyone's palate. I had the Moroccan kabobs and truffle pierogis (which are NOT your average pierogi!) and our table split several other appetizers. Great ambiance too. You'll love it.“

“Delightful patio experience! They had fat heads on tap and the happy hour prime rib sliders is the best value in town. My bartender Chad was one of the best I've had in some time. The manager Caleb even stopped by to make sure everything exceeded expectations which it did! My first stop in and I will definitely be back! Strongly recommend giving this location a try, you won't be disappointed!“

“The food was great. The experience was great“