50 Best Italian Restaurants near Mayfield Village

1 Alfredo's At the Inn Italian Restaurant

4.0 Good 429 Reviews

780 Beta Drive, Mayfield

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I have dined at Alfredo's many times and have always been very happy with the food and the service. Restaurants in hotels are not always wonderful, but Alfredo's is. I came with a group of four ladies one of whom had never been there before. We were all pleased with our meals and with the service. We all had Italian entree and they were delicious.”

2 The Original Mario Fazios

4.7 Superb 516 Reviews

34400 Chardon Road, Willoughby Hills · 2.42 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Catering for Our Film crew was Perfect after a long day on Set!! Every dish was a celebration of Italy's culinary traditions, fresh, high-quality ingredients. The classic combination of ingredients was a snapshot of what Italian cuisine is all about. The Lemon Chicken, Peppers, Meatballs, Pasta and Salad were Perfection .... the team loved everything!”

3 Nonna T's Italian Restaurant

4.8 Superb 240 Reviews

7345 Center Street, Mentor · 9.68 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We went to Nonna Ts for the first time this weekend. From the moment you step into this charming restaurant, you’re greeted by the excellent staff and amazing aroma of the best Italian food I’ve had since moving to Ohio. The drinks, food and atmosphere is top notch and being greeted by Nonna T was the perfect addition to our evening. We will definitely be back and make eating at Nonna T’s a regular event.”

4 Mama Catena Vino e’ Cucina

4.7 Superb 299 Reviews

711 Babbitt Road, Euclid · 5.24 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“9/24/2025: This place is a gem! The food and service was amazing! Our server Katina was very attentive and made sure everything was great throughout the night!! We also enjoyed talking with Moma and her daughter. Such an added bonus to the night to meet and hear their stories! Can't wait to go back---until then I will enjoy my left overs!!”

5 Casa Rosa Cucina Red House Kitchen

4.8 Superb 131 Reviews

9350 Chillicothe Road, Willoughby · 6.14 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I came here with my sister last night and will definitely be back! Everyone was so friendly and accommodating, and our waitress was the sweetest and she even sent me home with birthday cake! 🎂 The food was amazing (10/10), and I ordered the Conchiglie Salsiccia Italiana, which was so good. Highly recommend Casa Rosa Cucina for great food and even better service!”

6 Pranzo!

4.6 Superb 247 Reviews

4066 Erie Street, Willoughby · 6.4 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Food is amazing, service is excellent. Pranzo! does not disappoint.”

7 Sara's Place By Gavi's Restaurant

4.6 Superb 202 Reviews

1501 Chagrin River Road, Gates Mills · 2.86 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“A most excellent casual, yet fine dining experience at Sara's Place in quiet and secluded Gates Mills. My wife and I had a much needed date night and we're very pleased with our visit. We sat in the upper lounge & bar area which is moody and atmospheric. The food was also amazing. I highly recommend the regular menu Pork Chop item - get the BBQ sauce on the side as the chop itself it phenomenal without it and I went back and forth using the sauce or not. Highly recommend for a casual night out 👌”

8 Danny G's

4.9 Superb 70 Reviews

7224 Center Street, Mentor · 9.88 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Service great. food great, patio great! Owners friendly and Server we had very accommodating! First time there tonight. Will definitely be back and recommend to friends!”

9 Vittorio's Buon Appetito

4.5 Superb 233 Reviews

29664 Euclid Avenue, Wickliffe · 4.26 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“This is officially my new Italian night spot. Everything tasted authentic and homemade, you can tell they use quality ingredients and put love into every dish. If you’re looking for authentic Italian food, I highly recommend Vittorio’s. I’ll definitely be back again and again!”

10 Trios Italian Grille & Catering

4.5 Superb 166 Reviews

7537 Mentor Avenue Suite 23, Mentor · 7.95 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Outstanding experience at Trio's Italian Grill in Mentor! It felt like being welcomed into a family's home — so warm and kind. They were wonderful with our son who is on the spectrum. I had the Chicken Piccata, my husband had the Chicken Pasta Carbonara, and our son loved the corn dog bites. Service and food were both top-notch! She even baked fresh cookies for us to take home and came out to the car to say goodbye to our son. We left with wonderful desserts and will definitely be back next time we're in town!!”

11 TJ's On the Avenue

4.4 Superb 371 Reviews

7485 Mentor Avenue, Mentor · 7.82 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Took my wife out to dinner and everything from the moment we walked in the door was amazing! The hostess sat us and took our drink order and brought it over immediately. Our server Kim was fabulous! She was friendly and Courteous. Our food was amazing and portions were more than generous. Definitely a new staple in our dinner line up!”

12 Mirabile's

4.7 Superb 45 Reviews

1025 Ivanhoe Road, Cleveland · 6.92 miles

• Take-Out

“Very low key but if you know you know. I caught the chicken parmesean special. The chicken was crispy and help up against the sauce. You also get a salad and bread. Everything was ok but the atmosphere wasn't really welcoming. It kinda reminded me of a scene in Goodfellows and the Sopranos. It looks like you could have easily ran into John Gotti!!”

13 Abo's Grill

4.4 Superb 245 Reviews

5288 Mayfield Road, Lyndhurst · 3.4 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The owners and staff are amazing and I’ve never had a bad meal there and one of my recent favorites is their chicken Marsala!”

14 Scotti's Italian Eatery

4.4 Superb 223 Reviews

882 East 185th Street, Cleveland · 6.11 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“My husband, son, dog, and I went to Scotti’s for a late lunch and had an incredible experience. Our server Hayley was amazing and the food was delicious and authentic. We had the outdoor patio to ourselves so our dog could dine with us. We would definitely go back again!”

15 Campola's Social

4.5 Superb 83 Reviews

7224 Center Street, Mentor · 9.88 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Pretty nice little Italian restaurant. Got the chicken parmigiana dinner to go with a canoli and it didn't disappoint. Came with a side salad and Italian dressing which was nice. The sauce is good spaghetti was good chicken and cheese was great. Lots of flavor and fresh. Decent portions. Canoli was tasty as well. I would recommend trying this place out it ain't too bad. Nice little outside area to eat as well. Glad I finally stopped by to try it out. I wasn't disappoint and I'll be back. 🙂”

16 Severino's Restaurant & Lounge

4.4 Superb 141 Reviews

35125 Vine Street, Willowick · 6.29 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Good food and service too.”

18 Giovanni's

4.3 Superb 467 Reviews

25550 Chagrin Boulevard, Beachwood · 6.83 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The best food in the world, the best martinis in the world world, the best, the best, the best, the best the best lemon drops ever”

19 Pastina Rustic Italian Restaurant

4.3 Superb 350 Reviews

9354 Mentor Avenue Suite 1, Mentor · 11.17 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Haven’t been in for dinner in a while. Athena, our server was fantastic. Food was outstanding.Really exceeded any expectations we may have had. It was so refreshing to have a server who was so genuinely welcoming and friendly! We were immediately made to feel comfortable. And she was so informative and this is coming from someone who’s been in the hospitality business for over 40 years! Thanks again for a wonderful evening!”

20 Arrabiata's Italian Restaurant

4.3 Superb 233 Reviews

6169 Mayfield Road, Cleveland · 2.36 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We had my birthday celebration there. Let me tell you, the experience was just beautiful. There were 16 of us, and they catered to our every need. The serving staff was patient, and very thorough. They were so attentive, and made certain we were very well taken care of. THE FOOD! Man oh man. That food was the bomb. I think everyone had something different, and we are all still talking about how good it was! I recommend you have dinner with them. You will not regret it. It’s a whole vibe! ❤️❤️”

21 Antica Italian Beachwood

4.3 Superb 223 Reviews

3355 Richmond Road Ste 151, Beachwood · 6.65 miles

“The food is always fresh and delicious!”

22 Cuoco Bello

4.3 Superb 222 Reviews

718 SOM Ctr Road, Mayfield · 0.56 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Tried Cuoco Bello for my first time tonight and it was delicious! I ordered the chicken parm for carry out and it was flavorful, a large portion size, and better than I had anticipated 😊 Just what I was looking for in a great meal! The staff was friendly and I can't wait to go back and try something else! Also, they have weekly specials so definitely check those out too! Highly recommend! 🍝”

23 Vicinato Pizza

4.3 Superb 195 Reviews

5080 Mayfield Road, Lyndhurst · 3.73 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We just got this two days ago for the first time. It was excellent pizza, and will definitely be back.”

24 Gaetano's Restaurant

4.3 Superb 148 Reviews

2747C SOM Ctr Road, Willoughby Hills · 2.41 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Got pizza this weekend for the whole family and friends this and it was absolutely delicious!! Fantastic quality of products and look forward to going back again soon. Great job team!!”

25 Bar Forno

4.2 Good 76 Reviews

30610 Lakeshore Boulevard, Willowick · 6.34 miles

• Delivery

“great food great service ty”

26 Longo's Pizza

4.2 Good 225 Reviews

8907 Mentor Avenue, Mentor · 10.47 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Love it there. Outside bar is the best”

27 Guido's Pizza Haven, Restaurant, and Preferred Catering Service

4.6 Superb 315 Reviews

12809 Chillicothe Road, Chesterland · 5.71 miles

• Take-Out

“Guido’s is the best. The end.”

28 Pizzazz on the Circle

4.2 Good 303 Reviews

20680 John Carroll Boulevard, University Heights · 6.66 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Wonderful sheet pizza. Great for parties. Your guests will love the pizza.”

29 Piada Italian Street Food

4.2 Good 308 Reviews

6075 Mayfield Road, Mayfield Heights · 2.43 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“First time trying it and it was good! Definitely will go back when I visit town again!”

30 Geraci's Restaurant Pepper Pike

4.2 Good 369 Reviews

29425 Chagrin Blvd, Pepper Pike · 6.37 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Simply the best pizza I've ever had. Superior toppings, great crust and consistent excellence for decades now. I find it unreasonable for me to go anywhere else.”

31 Very Good Pizza Company

4.4 Superb 257 Reviews

12720 Chillicothe Road, Chesterland · 5.59 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“If I could give more than 5 stars, I would! This pizza place is an absolute gem. You can taste the difference in every bite -- from the perfect dough crust to the rich, flavorful sauce and the freshest toppings I've ever had. They clearly use only the best ingredients, and it shows. What really sets them apart is the passion of the staff. You can tell they truly love what they do -- every interaction feels warm, genuine, and full of pride for their craft. They even gave the children a behind-the-scenes tour, which was such a fun and unique experience! The children loved being able to make their own pizza. Learning about their sourcing made me appreciate their pizza even more. This isn't just a meal -- it's an experience. If you love pizza, you need to come here. I'm already planning my next visit!”

32 Zeppe's Pizzeria

4.6 Superb 269 Reviews

5559 Wilson Mills Road, Highland Heights · 2.24 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The best pizza in Ohio!”

33 Crostatas Rustic Pizza

4.6 Superb 235 Reviews

558 Bishop Road, Highland Heights · 2.05 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great food An experience.”

34 Marotta's

4.1 Good 175 Reviews

2289 Lee Road, Cleveland · 7.52 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Unique, fresh, and delicious! We will definitely be ordering from here again!”

35 Dino's Restaurant

4.5 Superb 315 Reviews

1200 East 305th Street, WILOUGHBY HLS · 4.78 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Had an amazing dinner this Friday night. Lynn was fantastic. We have enough from each dinner for 2 or more meals. Heve not been there for a very long time. Excited to go back soon”

36 Mama Roberto's Italian Restaurant

4.5 Superb 279 Reviews

8658 Mentor Avenue, Mentor · 9.93 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Place is amazing. Great food, great portions, so affordable. Got seated immediately and enjoyed an amazing dinner after spending a day hiking. Staff was friendly and entertaining! Dining room was great!”

37 Bar Fuoco

3.7 Good 64 Reviews

87 3/4 West Street, Chagrin Falls · 8.65 miles

“It was horrible! Service was bad. Food was boring. Tiny pizzettes not too bad but not worth the money. The skewers were just 3 chunks of meat with no veggies. Just unflavored meat skewers presented on an empty plate. They brought out one item at a time so the first orders got cold while waiting for the others. Way overpriced for what you get. Way too much furniture crammed into a tiny space. People brushing past you to try to get through. So very disappointing. Not at all like the photos.”

38 Bar Italia Beachwood

4.1 Good 466 Reviews

2101 Richmond Road, Beachwood · 4.61 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We had dinner at Bar Italia yesterday on 10-19. Our server, Joe really enhanced our experience. He was so professional and thoughtful. The food was very good with generous servings. We have recently relocated to Beachwood and will visit Bar Italia again. Hoping to have Joe as our waiter! Thank you!”

39 Maxim's Pizza & Catering

4.6 Superb 116 Reviews

6966 Heisley Road, Mentor · 11.25 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The family and restertaunt a neighborhood icon .The old world food and greeting is why there still in business after 6 decades .Try the eggplant parm magnfeso' excelante'”

40 Piada Italian Street Food

4.1 Good 469 Reviews

13947 Cedar Road, South Euclid · 6.14 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“Everytime I go there the food always good and the worker Alway cool I love going their Thanks Jennifer 😍🤪🤪”

41 Flour | Moreland Hills

4.1 Good 562 Reviews

34205 Chagrin Boulevard, Moreland Hills · 6.7 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I have food allergies - gluten and dairy. I got the ribeye and carrots. The flavor was absolutely phenomenal!! Friendly and very accommodating. Plus they have complementary valet, which was great with a very full parking lot! Oh! Have you had the bolognase, per the server suggestion and it was great!!”

42 M Italian

4.1 Good 845 Reviews

22 West Orange Street, Chagrin Falls · 8.56 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“My husband and I wanted to find a spot to dress up for date night. M Italian was the perfect choice. Bill spotted us and made sure our night was special. Our server was amazing and the food exceeded our expectations. I had the salmon salad and I absolutely loved it. We ended our night with the chocolate lava cake and gelato. The setting was romantic, elegant and we enjoyed a much needed night out together with some great wine on a perfect rainy evening. I will never forget this night! So grateful for the attentive staff for making our night the best one we’ve had in a while!”

43 Zappitelli's Pizza, Pasta & Parm

4.4 Superb 336 Reviews

9570 Mentor Avenue, Mentor · 11.61 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Food was good.. had the chicken Parmesan and husband had pasta diablo … only complaint is we never got rolls and I asked for them and still never got them..”

44 Zeppe's Tavern & Pizzeria

4.4 Superb 320 Reviews

25780 Miles Rd C, Bedford Heights · 9.33 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Best pizza in town!”

45 Angelo's Pizzeria & Ice Cream

4.2 Good 239 Reviews

8162 Euclid Chardon Road, Kirtland · 5.09 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We stop here every time we’re in the area for pizza and ice cream and have always left happy and with full bellies. Love the decor, prompt service, and excellent food. Worth a stop for any family on their way back from Lakefarm Park, Holden, or apple picking.”

46 LaRich's Pizza

4.4 Superb 101 Reviews

797 Bishop Road, Cleveland · 2.18 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Best pizza around... Love the medium thin crust!!!!!”

47 Piada Italian Street Food

4.0 Good 449 Reviews

3870 Richmond Road, Beachwood · 7.39 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“Piada was a lifesaver last night! Even arriving 30 minutes before closing, the staff welcomed me warmly, and the food was incredibly fresh and delicious. It was one the best late-night meals I've had, and the service was absolutely amazing. Highly recommend!”

48 Pizzazz Pizza Mayfield Village

3.9 Good 261 Reviews

839 SOM Ctr Road, Mayfield · 0.99 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Had the BEST pizza in years here today. I will be back! AWESOME”

49 Geraci's Restaurant University Hts

4.3 Superb 326 Reviews

2266 Warrensville Center Road, University Heights · 6.26 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Simply the best pizza I've ever had. Superior toppings, great crust and consistent excellence for decades now. I find it unreasonable for me to go anywhere else.”

50 Congin's Pizza - CLEVELAND

4.3 Superb 265 Reviews

18812 Nottingham Road, Cleveland · 5.81 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“The pizza was hot and fresh, the wings were nice and crispy and the fried dough was the perfect tasty treat to complete the meal”