19 Best American Restaurants near Middle Bass

“For being one of 3 food places on the island it’s not bad. The pizza was okay nothing special and we ordered twice from here( over phone for pick up) food was always ready when I got there. I did like my Italian sub….I also got us a soft pretzel with cheese and I wouldn’t get that again. 9.99$ for a regular sized pretzel and the bottom of the pretzel was hard. I also paid the extra 1$ for the mustard and I didn’t care for it.“

“Great atmosphere! We walked up in the blazing heat with our bags from the ferry and this was our first pit stop. We didn’t know much of what we were getting into, but the nice bartender educated us well. Drinks were good. We only ate here once for breakfast which was mediocre. Fair prices. Didn’t go out back where the resort part was, didn’t know until after. Would consider staying here next time.“

“Awesome place! The perch is excellent and so is the Service.“

“I actually love the place. Unfortunately on our last visit we ordered prime rib which was without a doubt the worst I have ever had. I would think they'd be embarrassed to serve it and to charge $25 was robbery at its finest. Very disappointing from a place I typically enjoy.“

“The Island House staff is always awesome! Great food, drinks and atmosphere. Shout out to Erica - one of my favorite bartenders on the island. She and Joe (at the Caddy Shack) are the best!“

“The service was really good. The pizza and the desert were really good. The Caesar salad was just ok, and the drinks were ok but overpriced. With tip, a meal for two cost slightly over 100$ and for what we got, it was definitely overpriced.“

“Amazing cocktails, food and atmosphere!“

“While in Marblehead for a couple nights we happened upon this local dive bar. And I say that will all due respect, that’s my kind of bar. The area has plenty of pretentious “tiki” bars for the tourists, this is clearly where the locals go for good food, friendly service, and a great atmosphere. We returned for a second night and I was impressed that Liz (our bartender both nights) remember us and what we were drinking. We felt like locals. And Brian did not disappoint when it came to the wings! Absolutely amazing wings! Can’t wait to be back in the area!“

“Great place, that’s all!!!“

“Amanda’s speciality martini, The Orange Creamsicle was amazing!! Light and refreshing and creamy. 10 stars.“

“My husband and I went to Marbelhead to celebrate 14 years. we found this (on google) and the food was amazing we had the jumbo shrimp (which was amazing) I had the grilled chicken and my husband had a burger. the cole slaw was fantastic (and I'm very particular on it). We did not get any pie but they looked positively delicious). our con was the parking we drive a F250 and it's a small parking lot. It was a little pricy but very good!!“

“Serve what is ordered in a timely manner. Our party of 4 was here last Wednesday for lunch and only 1 of 4 orders was correct. We waited 10 minutes after being seated and received drink order after another 10 minutes. All 4 of us placed food order, ( nothing not on menu) and order was finally brought to table 30 minutes later. Only 1 order was correct. After this, it only took about 5 minutes for the other 3 to be delivered and the cole slaw was incorrect, ever hear of cole slaw with no cabbage? Manager was asked for and he was very rude, no apology and no compensation offered. Beware! They only want your money and have no idea how to run a business properly.“

“Everything about this place is just awesome. It’s an atmosphere that you won’t find anywhere else on the island! Staff, food, pricing, absolutely everything is wonderful and it makes me wish I lived closer so I could return more often!“

“From the owners to the kitchen staff to the campers/customers, everyone here makes u feel like family! The food is surprisingly very good for a small kitchen and the prices are better than most.

Dietary restrictions: Gluten free pizza crust option

Wheelchair accessibility: Ramp to go in so easy for a wheel chair“

“Josh, Jersey, and Kiara were integral to the experience here! Fantastic food, with the best seafood on the island with the signature Lobster Martini and their Shrimp and Scallop Skewers. They often have live music from a fantastic cover artist, Steve Brownell, and being right on the docks, you often get a nice breeze coming off the water of Lake Erie. Get yourself a Little Beer, and chat with the bartenders and enjoy some good music!

Parking: Street parking above the docks, and shared parking at the docks“

“My wife and I have been coming in every Tuesday for a drink while we wait for some take out since we’ve moved to the island. I have been ordering the same thing every week The Classic burger. My usual comment is that this is a pretty good burger (believe me when I say I know a good burger). But today I get home with my dinner and I open the box and i see it’s on a pretzel bun. My first though is that this is different?!?!?! I took a bite and holly crap it was AMAZING!!!!! Not gonna lie probably one of the best burgers I’ve eaten in a while. Great work to whom ever was in the kitchen tonight my hats off to you“

“This was the third pool we tried in Put In Bay and the best. Plenty of room to spread out and have a good time with friends. The landscaping and tropical plants make it really pretty. They offer lots of games like volleyball, Jenga, and have large floats available to play on. Nice staff too.“

“Y’all this is a great place to come feed your hungry belly when you’re drinking! We had the most amazing server, Michael, and we loved his service and the food so much we ate there twice! He recommended we try the Brie chicken arugula pizza and it DID NOT miss. Easily the best pizza I’ve ever had!! The drinks are delicious and the pricing is fitting to what you get!“

“Very inexpensive burgers, excellent fries. Affordable when you are traveling with kids.“