15 Best Ice Cream Shops near Middletown

“Today was my first trying their ice cream and it was AMAZING! I will definitely be going back. I highly recommend trying it.“

“We enjoyed our dinner. Its rating is spot on. The servers were friendly and patient with my million questions. I was offered add-on suggestions to enhance my plate. Since it was my 1st time, I left the plate as is. Delicious. The food was sizzling hot so i think that the food is made to order. The dine-in space is small, two booths and about 8-10 tables for 2 or 4 ppl per table. What I really liked.. it’s Veteran Owned and the chicken was cooked to perfection. I did hear many people calling in and picking up. One and a half years and just today we discovered this little hidden chicken gem!
I recommend it and have every intention of making another trip to eat something else from the new menu coming out soon!“

“Love the selection of goodies they offer“

“Loved our treats!! So glad you opened but we were trying to submit a survey about our great experience and having issues getting past the first screen“

“So far we have enjoyed gelato treats and they did not disappoint! The nice lady working was so lovely.“

“Delicious and great customer service. Your kids will love all the different flavors and types of ice cream they make.“

“The vanilla custard with cotton candy Italian ice Blendini is addicting!“

“We just enjoyed the best hidden secret in Trenton! Whit’s Frozen Custard is full of charm, serving incredible custard. We were warmly greeted by Lauren and Hayley who explained the menu and helped us with selections. Highly recommend paying them a visit!“

“I normally don’t post reviews, but Zach was exceptional. It was a busy night and another worker misheard my order, but Zach paid absolute attention and realized the wrong ice cream was scooped. He was extremely kind and hospitable. Ultimately, it didn’t matter because all graeter’s ice cream is amazing, but it meant a lot to be acknowledged and to be provided the upmost customer service. I’m an HR Director and I’m ready to hire Zach! Great hire for the Liberty Center location.“

“Mr Frosty is one of those old-fashioned ice cream shacks that serves a relatively large selection of meals and snacks, both hot and cold. Every time we visit we're greeted with smiles and polite service, even when there's only one person running the whole show. From chocolate/vanilla twist cones to sodas (old fashioned sodas, not just pop!), to footlongs and sundaes, this little place can stand up to any big commercial chain in terms of quality and price. And it has the small-town traditional feel that will make you feel good about giving them your business.“

“Great place for ice cream and a cool area!“

“The protein shakes were great. The teas I’ve heard great things about, so we will stop by again to try those! Great service too. Definitely stop by and give them a try!“

“Wonderful family friendly atmosphere and great staff“

“This is my favorite dairy queen, everyone is always friendly and professional. The only issue I have is that if you pay with a card, you cannot tip the servers. So make sure to bring a few bucks if you want to tip the great service

Parking: If you drive a car or a vehicle that sits low, use the entrance/ exit in the back to avoid scraping.

Wheelchair accessibility: Slight difficulties with persons in wheelchairs but possible. Will need help with opening doors“

“My family loves going to the Creamery! My kids loves their donuts and ice cream! And my favorite drink is the iced caramel macchiato - I like it better than Dunkin’s and Starbucks’ version. The atmosphere is fun, chic, and relaxing. The service is great, the employees are friendly, and the owners are great people!

Kid-friendliness: They have clear pastry display cases so it’s easy for my kids to see what the options are. They also have a kiddie corner that has a pretend play ice cream stand and coffee maker, and several board/card games to play that my kids enjoy and look forward to playing with whenever we visit.“