17 Best Sandwich Shops near New Middletown

1

Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
10651 Main St, New Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Cold Cut Combo
Bacon Egg
Cookies
Steak

“debbie the owner is the absolute sweetest lady ever had a complication with the app got charged twice and never received my food she refunded me and gave me a gift card which was way above and beyond what she had to do, i will definitely keep coming back to this subway just the support her. i love great owners with a great attitude and you don’t have to many of those these days so i cherish her❤️“

4.6 Superb7 Reviews
Horst Sub & Deli Sandwich Shop • $
5437 OH-7, New Waterford - 10.5 miles

Customers` Favorites

Meatball Sub with Cheese on Italian Bread
Pizza with Pepperoni Sausage and Peppers
Sausage Egg and Cheese Croissant
Roast Beef and Turkey Sub
Roast Beef Sandwich
Philly Cheesesteak
Chicken Salad Sub
Pepperoni Pizza
Ice Cream Cone
Chicken Salad

“We love stopping by whenever we drive through Lisbon. The market has goodies, chips, and even frozen tubs of soft serve as well as parbaked pizzas for sale. The subs are very good. The soups are always tasty! They even have ice cream cones to go!“

4.9 Superb102 Reviews
Primanti Bros. Restaurant and Bar Sports Bar • $
6731 South Ave, Youngstown - 6.13 miles

Customers` Favorites

Primanti-Style Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Primanti Size Fries with Cheese
Primanti Size French Fries
Breaded Mozzarella Wedges
Crispy Chicken Sandwich
Loaded Cheesesteak Bomb
Giant Bavarian Pretzel
The Original PB Reuben
Colossal Fish Sandwich
Primanti-Sized Fries

“I don’t live in the area BUT every time I visit the area PB here I come. Do forget they have 1/2 off on wings Sun and Mondays. Also they have a membership please join it. Finally while at the airport by all means go by the restaurant and grab a sandwich. Don’t forget to get your condiments because that’s on you to ask for. I have never been able to eat their sandwich in one setting.“

4.1 Good62 Reviews
Frullati Sandwich Shop • $
7401 Market St Spc 351, Youngstown - 6.76 miles

Customers` Favorites

Rustic Veggie Melt

“Wish the portions were bigger, and that more choices were available maybe a option to customize what you order. My panini was like 80% onion ... Its Like the only vegetarian food in the southern park mall. So I am grateful ? my java smoothie was not anything like the one I got there years and years ago ... It was like watered down chocolate milk . way to thin. way to much chocolate. and way to watery ...

Vegetarian options: They have a vegetarian panini and its like the only place in southern park mall that has even a option for vegetarians.“

4.3 Superb10 Reviews
Jersey Mike's Subs Sandwich Shop • $
813 Boardman Poland Rd, Boardman - 6.08 miles

Customers` Favorites

Big Kahuna Chicken Cheese Steak
Chipotle Chicken Cheese Steak
Chicken Philly Cheese Steak
Big Kahuna Cheese Steak
Chipotle Cheese Steak
Turkey and Provolone
The Original Italian
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Ham and Provolone
Add Chip & Drink

“Had a ham sub today for the first time at Greenwood chevy and it was really delicious! I will be having more!!! thanx!“

3.7 Good59 Reviews
DiBella's Sandwich Shop • $
435 Boardman Poland Rd, Youngstown - 6.33 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Philly Sub with Our Famous Chocolate Chip Cookie
Godfather Sub on Everything Bread
Grandma DiBella's Cookies
Deli Salads & Pickles
DiBella's Cheesesteak
Roast Beef
Dagwood
Chips
Turkey
Subs

“love the everything bread“

3.7 Good46 Reviews
Jimmy John's Sandwich Shop • $
131 Lincoln Ave, Youngstown - 11 miles

Customers` Favorites

Kickin' Chicken Sandwich
Spicy East Coast Italian
Fresh Baked French Bread
The J J Gargantuan
Italian Night Club
Little John B L T
Ultimate Porker
Hunter's Club
Little John 1
Giant 5 Vito

“My family and I love Jimmy John's we love number #9. The cookies are delicious too. The wait is not that long the staff are really nice. I tell everyone to try you won't be disappointed.“

4 Good13 Reviews
8

Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
15 N Main St, Columbiana - 8.68 miles

Customers` Favorites

Subway Club
Steak
Tuna

“It's a Subway, so if you've ever been to one before, it's exactly what you'd expect: subs and salads. This location is very clean, and the employees are awesome. They recognize me and know my order. The line moves quickly, even at lunchtime. The only downside is the parking situation: there are a very limited number of spaces, and it can get very busy here around noon. It's even worse in the winter when the snow gets plowed into the end spaces.“

3.8 Good21 Reviews
Firehouse Subs Boardman & Applewood Road Sandwich Shop • $
700 Boardman Poland Rd Ste 2, Boardman - 6.25 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pastrami Medium 7-8 Inch
Beef & Cheddar Brisket
Jamaican Jerk Turkey
Hook and Ladder Sub
Turkey Bacon Ranch
Firehouse Meatball
Virginia Honey Ham
Firehouse Hero Sub
Spicy Chicken Bowl
Meatball Turkey

“I freaking love these subs.“

3.6 Good38 Reviews
10

Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
3004 Center Rd, Poland - 4.77 miles

“Tried the Pickleball Club today and it was awesome! This was my first time since subway started Slicing meat in store and you could definitely tell a difference in the meat, much better. The young ladies working were awesome and made me laugh on a busy, frustrating day...it was needed, and I may have found a new favorite Subway sandwich.“

4 Good5 Reviews
McAlister's Deli Sandwich Shop • $
1090 Boardman Poland Rd, Youngstown - 5.92 miles

Customers` Favorites

Veggie Sandwich with a Piece of Turkey or Chicken
The New Yorker Add Bacon Cheese Peppers Onions
Chipotle Chicken Baked Potato
McAlister's Club Sandwich
Chicken Tortilla Soup
Black Angus King Club
Side of Potato Salad
Grilled Chicken
Cuban Sandwich
Memphian

“Literally the best guest service I've ever had SOPHIA WELCOMED ME LIKE FAMILY AND GAVE ME A REALLY GOOD EXPERIENCE WHEN I VISITED IN, A LOT OF THESE OTHER PLACES CAN TAKE NOTES FROM EMPLOYEES LIKE THIS, MCALISTER'S IS LUCKY TO HAVE YOU SOPHIA.. I'LL BE SEEING YOU GUYS SOON AGAIN THANK YOU“

3.5 Good101 Reviews
Sandwich Factory Boardman Sandwich Shop • $
6128 Market St, Youngstown - 7.55 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ribeye Steak Hot Sandwich
Ribeye Steak Sandwich
Hot Sausage Sandwich
Bologna Sandwich
Fried Bologna
French Fries
Onion Rings
Roast Beef
Steak Salad
Pepperoni

“I’m happy to say sandwich factory is back!
They fell off for awhile a year or so ago.
I went back yesterday and
Back to great sandwiches.
Meat and cheese portions were very generous. Bread soft. Can’t say enough !“

3.5 Good63 Reviews
13

Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
210 W Rayen Ave, Youngstown - 11.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Meatball Marinara
Cookies

“The service was fast and courteous, Tineka was on point fixing my sandwich and it is so good!!????“

3.3 Good17 Reviews
14

Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
1001 Mt Jackson Rd, New Castle - 6.33 miles
3 Average5 Reviews
15

Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
179 E Taggart St, East Palestine - 8.84 miles

Customers` Favorites

Oven Roasted Turkey
Buffalo Chicken
Grilled Chicken
Cold Cut Combo
Cookies
Steak

“Clean restaurant with friendly service. The lady that waited on me was very professional and kept busy with side work when not taking care of customers. I was on a time crunch and they got through the line of people faster than I've ever seen any other subway. They even greet regulars by name.“

3.2 Average13 Reviews
16

Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
8051 Market St, Boardman - 6.23 miles

Customers` Favorites

Meatball Marinara
Black Forest Ham
Cold Cut Combo
Italian B M T
Potato Chip
Subway Club
Cookies
Steak

“The service was amazing, the guy that made my sandwich was so chill and polite, and I would recommend this place to my friends any day. The place was decorated so well, and it looked like they really put a lot of work into it. The food was great, and it tasted like they were really committed to serving the best food possible. 5 stars, would eat there again.“

3.2 Average22 Reviews
17

Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
5052 Youngstown-Poland Rd, Poland - 6.77 miles

Customers` Favorites

Harvest Cheddar Sunchips
Sunchips Harvest Cheddar
Cookies

“Came in with my husband and son Ordered three foot longs to go. Sherry was there by herself with a line of people. She had a wonderful personality took care of each one of us with a positive attitude and prepared our order efficiently and correctly. She has given the most outstanding customer service I have seen in a long time. Very pleasant young lady.“

3.2 Average23 Reviews

You May Also Like