9 Best Sandwich Shops near New Middletown

“As always the girls behind the counter were friendly and very helpful. I had a salad instead of a sandwich as wanted to have a change from the bread. The salads give you a chance enjoy the fresh vegetables and cheese even more. To make things better I had a coupon for a free 21oz. drink, If you sign up you can get many money saving coupons texted to your phone.“

“Horst Sub & Deli is a hidden gem that promises a delightful experience for anyone craving delicious sandwiches and deli treats. From the moment you step in, you're greeted by a cozy and inviting atmosphere that feels like a neighborhood favorite.The star of the show is undoubtedly their sandwiches. Each one is crafted with care, using fresh ingredients and a generous amount of fillings. Whether you're a fan of classic combos or want to try something more adventurous, Horst Sub & Deli has a sandwich for you.Their menu doesn't stop at sandwiches; they also offer a range of deli items like soups, salads, and sides. Everything is made with quality ingredients and a passion for good food.What sets Horst Sub & Deli apart is the friendly service and attention to detail. The staff is always ready with a smile, happy to recommend their favorites or customize your order to perfection.Overall, Horst Sub & Deli is a must-visit for sandwich lovers looking for a cozy spot with fantastic food and top-notch service. It's a true gem waiting to be discovered!“

“Pizza was ok. Wings were on point . We had one server for like 20 minutes, she told us her replacement would be over. He came over 30 minutes later mentions he's leaving and his replacement would be by. The replacement showed up almost 40 minutes after the last one already left. It was nonsense. Next time I'll eat at the bar. Much less confusing and better service.Also, put better descriptions on your online menu. I don't know what any of your sandwiches are if they've got some wacky name.“

“Great place for subs and salads. Food is always delishous. We love all the firehouse decor as well. We also love how much they support local fire departments. I would definitely recommend it.Parking: Parking right in front of the store.Kid-friendliness: The kids' menu is reasonable, and they get a cool plastic fire helmet.Wheelchair accessibility: Handicap spots and tables available.“

“Clean restaurant with friendly service. The lady that waited on me was very professional and kept busy with side work when not taking care of customers. I was on a time crunch and they got through the line of people faster than I've ever seen any other subway. They even greet regulars by name.“

“Wish the portions were bigger, and that more choices were available maybe a option to customize what you order. My panini was like 80% onion ... Its Like the only vegetarian food in the southern park mall. So I am grateful ? my java smoothie was not anything like the one I got there years and years ago ... It was like watered down chocolate milk . way to thin. way to much chocolate. and way to watery ...Vegetarian options: They have a vegetarian panini and its like the only place in southern park mall that has even a option for vegetarians.“

“My first time eating at Jimmy Johns was delicious. Service really was fast with the help of Lenette, who made my sandwich and also checked me out.Parking: Parallel parking next to the store. A busy area due to being on YSUs campusKid-friendliness: Lots of kids options and small portions.“

“Tonight was our fist time ordering DiBella subs and I'm sure we will be back again. Jers*y M1kes's has always been my favorite because of the amount of meat and toppings and the freshest bread. But I have to say that DiBella's is a close runner-up. I didn't really care for the bread I chose for my Dagwood, so next time I'll get plain or sesame and not the multigrain-- it was kind of hard to bite through. But there was plenty of meat, cheese was ok, not much lettuce however. My husband had the spicy cheesesteak and he said it wasn't very spicy, but there was plenty of meat and toppings. We chose DiBella's due to a flyer we received in the mail that had a bogo sub coupon. But even without the coupon DiBella's prices are better than JMs!“

“It's a Subway, so if you've ever been to one before, it's exactly what you'd expect: subs and salads. This location is very clean, and the employees are awesome. They recognize me and know my order. The line moves quickly, even at lunchtime. The only downside is the parking situation: there are a very limited number of spaces, and it can get very busy here around noon. It's even worse in the winter when the snow gets plowed into the end spaces.“