27 Best Pizza Restaurants near Newbury

“Always delicious,I have a hard time picking my favorites sandwiches. Reuben, chicken parm sub, and Philly ribeye are my go to's. My husband loves the burgers. The johnny boy and doubler are always favorites. Been eating here for years and have always had great food. Also love the new online ordering. Thanks for running a great small business in our area.“

“Fawn was a great server as u all know!!! Thanks again for another great visit, brought my grandson this time!Kid-friendliness: Equipped with high chairs, booster seats, server would find crayons sure if need be.Wheelchair accessibility: 1st level easy cheesey“

“First time there and won't be the last. We sampled several appetizers - Giant pretzel and honey mustard, Hot Honey Brussels Sprouts, Deep Fried Pickles and all were amazing. The house chips that come with the sandwiches are so good and freshly fried. French dip is perfect. Zeppes Original sandwich is everything an Italian sandwich should be. Service was excellent.“

“Delicious and made with quality ingredients. If you like a crispier thin crust, this is your spot. We loved the flavor in the aged mozzarella. Far superior to most cheeses used at other places. Pizza sauce bases were all excellent- red, white, and vodka. We loved their salad too with locally grown green leaf lettuce and the homemade dressings. We mixed the creamy Gorgonzola with the vinaigrette- so good. Loved my grapefruit margarita- they have a full bar and lounge on one side that is 21 and over but will serve to the other family friendly side. The family friendly side is super casual- order at the counter, get your own plates and utensils and service is pretty quick. Large screen televisions to watch a game. We will be back.“

“Atmosphere? It’s a gas station but with a very nice convenient store and a FANTASTIC kitchen!Wanted a Smash Burger but they were out. ? But… I had a Reuben and it was delicious! Corned beef, sauerkraut, cheese, sauce and grilled to perfection!We also ordered an Italian Sub - also delicious! Fries were crispy and fresh. Everyone agreed the onion rings were out of this world!Truly a hidden gem in Novelty!“

“Their pizza is great. I've tried a few different ones. My favorite is the chicken bacon ranch pizza. Don't forget the wings or chicken quesadillas.Parking: Really close to the road. But worth the hassle for the pizza.Kid-friendliness: They always greet me when I walk in, like I'm a part of the family or crew who work there. It's a very welcoming feeling.“

“First time here. Imagine, the first time you had ice cream as a little kid. Remember that great taste? That was my experience tasting ETalian food. Awe, and they have the best view in all Chagrin Falls. What an experience. You have to come and check them out. The staff is real friendly also?“

“As always, a wonderful experience. Manon was a top-rate server. Hubs had the lobster/shrimp soup and raved about it. He also loved his pork chops; thick and perfectly cooked. The tomato bisque soup comes with grilled cheese croutons; very imaginative and delicious! We saw lots of people leaving with pizzas; will have to try one the next time we're here. Love the Cupcake of the Day.We have come here during standard dinner hours and have not been able to find a parking spot. That's the price we pay for enjoying a very popular restaurant. We have learned to come during other times.“

“A newer staple to the Chagrin Valley area.We have been here many times since it has opened. The pizza is the best in the area. Slightly on the expensive side but worth it.Next to the takeout spot they have a little bar and eating area. No kids allowed. I guess I get it. Service has always been friendly and prompt.Decent enough beer/wine/booze selection but the real star is the pies!!“

“Exceptional dining experience in Gates Mills. Chef Richie’s rack of lamb and my husband’s pork chop were delicious. They accommodated my wheat allergy with care. Ample gluten free options on the menu. The potato skin appetizer was delightful, and the dessert special was decadently divine. From the warm reservation call with the owner to Claudia’s impeccable service, this restaurant stands out as one of the best in Cleveland and beyond. Can’t wait to return!“

“Had the fettuccine alfredo....the best I ever had. The portion was huge, so was the salad.I've eaten at many Italian restaurants, to me, the best. Great atmosphere too. I can't wait to go again! ?Kid-friendliness: The waitress was awesome. At the end of dinner the owner introduced himself. I liked that a lot. Made you feel like family.“

“I have not a bad meal yet. Although I've never had time to dine in, I love that I xan call in my order and it's ready when they say it will be. The food is delicious, I was surprised by the negative reviews I read but realized they where 6 and 8 years old. All I can say is that I love this place.“

“We loved it! Comfortable and not stuffy ambience Friendly attentive and helpful service Our table ordered the following and loved every bit! Baked Brie enough to share 3-4 people. Completely melted and still warm. Loved the toast Brussel sprouts flatbread special app generous portion and amazing flavors Brussel sprout salad more like a slaw but very good. Enough to share Brisket mushroom stroganoff. Ohio City pasta. Well coated with a rich comforting sauce and tasty tender brisket! Strip steak on corn risotto with burratta cheese and small salad. Easy dish to skip a sep salad with this entree. All in one! The strip was a huge thick cut and a Kalamata olive tapenade. All of these flavors and I could not resist ordering this. It did not disappoint, worth every bit of the $48 price Shared a slice of house made carrot cake. Moist and classic And a berry crumble with ice cream. Cranberries I. This made for a tart twist. But the vanilla ice cream balanced it all out We loved 1815 for our first visit. We will def be back!“

“First time here. So I ordered deep dish pizza and under Special Instructions "made with love" and this is what I got. I'm so thrilled. Thank you for putting effort into it. Hands down the best deep dish pizza around here. It is actually Chicago style. My husband got chicken parm, meatballs, and garlic bread was good. He said balsamic dressing was the best balsamic dressing that he ever had.“

“I stopped here on my way to a destination in chardon. I sat down and was greeted within seconds! The atmosphere was amazing! Service was awesome for both drinks and food. Plenty of parking and the food was so delicious! I recommend it to anyone. BBQ and Bar food. Whole meals with restaurant seating.“

“One of my coworkers mentioned Augies. I did not know of them. The wife and I decided to try them out, we were looking for an early dinner. There were minimum cars in front, we went in, they said they were not opened yet (will be in an hr). A manager overheard... sat us at a table, he took our order and served us. How cool! We had the pizza and garlic bread (with cheese, of course). The food was tremendous, the manager was awesome, we will be back. BTW, we drove by during dinner hours, there were alot of cars out front.“

“The name says it all! I was very impressed with the unique flavors of the Mediterranean pizza. The flavors all went together splendidly. The additional vinegrete dipping sauce was the cherry on top! I can't wait to try another unique specialty pizza! The aspect that led me to this restaurant was the sourdough pizza dough. I had never heard of something like that. As someone who has made home-grown bread with just flour, water, and salt and a little time on the counter, it piqued my interest. I was not disappointed.“

“Our experience at Sirnas Italian restaurant was nothing short of fantastic! The food was absolutely delicious, especially the homemade pasta! The service was prompt, and the employees were incredibly friendly. To top it off, the owner took the time to personally check on us, showcasing their genuine care for their customers. It's evident that Sirnas is a great family business, and I can't wait to come back for another delightful meal! Highly recommended.“

“I had the chance to pick up a pizza from Angelo's Friday evening. I was very pleased with their pizza The crust is thin and hand tossed I prefer pepperoni and mushrooms with lots of cheese. Their pizza sauce is not too sweet and very flavorful. I'm looking forward to another visit to eat in their dining room to enjoy one of their bougie boozy milkshakes.“

“Absolutely love this place! Pizza is always great, and they are generous with toppings! Wings are cooked perfect & they have so many flavors! Looking for something else, they got it and it's good! Haven't ordered something we didn't like, but if we did they would make it right. Definitely try them out, you won't be disappointed!“

“Loved their vegetarian/vegan options! So few places in this area has anything else than burgers or pasta on the menu. We tried the vegan lasagna and the vegan sloppy Joe's and both were amazing and filling! It was a little too loud in there and no light over our table, so it was hard to read the menu. We had to get our phones out to be able to see anything.“

“OMG! I was on that side of town yesterday and stopped in for a quick bite to go and it was really good! Their pizza is like no other around town. Very fresh ingredients. Excellent service too! I typically don't leave reviews, but I popped open my browser and their listing was still there, so why wouldn't I?“

“*Update: Due to Pizza Hut’s response, I have increased the rating to 4-Stars.Not a fan of this location. Despite the convenient late hours and amazing deals they offer, that’s about the only time it’s worth it (except maybe if you’re not a huge fan of pizza sauce).Their pizza is almost sauceless here, which accounts for most of the rating. I then began selecting “extra sauce” when ordering, but end up with a very small amount - only a slight smear…which for me, I don’t think tastes good. Even when ordering it well-done, the pizza just seems like it’s maybe cooked to a regular-bake, in my opinion.All of my orders have been ready on time nevertheless! I do always try to take care of the workers, and have given this location half a dozen tries too, but still have the same experience. I’ve ordered from both the app, and the website as well, to be sure before reviewing.All-in-all, the hand tossed pizza is pretty mediocre taste-wise I would say…but the value is certainly worth it - but only when using a coupon. Staff is friendly, no complaints there.*HOWEVER* The pan pizza, which I’ve just tried for the first time (believe it or not), is pretty amazing! Or could’ve been, but I digress. Their boneless wings are also good, sometimes.“

“So far, when ordering over the phone, the person on the other end is polite, clear to understand & feels like a long time ago, when you were known as the customer & valued & they valued themselves too.. the food is consistently good.. we have never eaten there, so I have no comment on the atmosphere.. but would think it is friendly & clean...“

“I come to this dominoes once at week at least the service is phenomenal the employees working here are great and are courteous and professional when you walk in you are greeted in a timely manner by one of the employees Heather which is the manager runs a great team is very understanding nice and professional and has great employees 110% great service hands down!!!“

“One of the few places we will eat pizza from. Always the best.Vegetarian options: Lots of vegetarian optionsParking: It's in chardo Square so you can use any of the street parking.Kid-friendliness: It's a small eat in, it is pizza but it's not like super geared towards kids although they are welcome.Wheelchair accessibility: There are steps leading into the building not sure if there's a back entrance for accessibility“

“Deliiiicious!!! Their pizza is like Pizza Hut but if Pizza Hut was actually good. Their cheesy garlic bread is like a deep dish pizza but crispy on the outside and perfectly cooked on the inside. Not too thick, not too thin. Perfect amount of cheese! Also got a custom white pizza, first bite I took I was literally blown away. I'm trying to stop eating it right now as they sit on my bed and mock me with their deliciousness. Gonna go put it away before I end up in a food coma...“