50 Best Bakeries near Reynoldsburg

“good designs and cakes taste awesome“

“I placed a mid sized corporate order. It was the 3 tiered bundtlette towers. So many combinations to choose from. The team really help me with the messages and decorative ribbon. Customer service was 2nd to none and the cakes always amaze!“

“Quick and easy experience when I walked into the store. I had a quick question and the girl working was helpful to answer my question. I placed my order and received my order maybe 2 minutes - so very quick! The only downside is I felt like the store was dirty - it was more the front area that felt dirtier. The floors were pretty gross - could have been from just the day but highly doubtful all that mess was made in a day. The back looked pretty messy as well but the worker appeared to be the only one there - so that very much could have played a factor if she’s trying to do everything herself.“

“Tried Tyler’s Pizzeria and Bakery recently for the first time. Completely taken back by their quality of service and their products! Friendliest customer service I have experienced. Best pizza in the city without question! 10/10. Will be a frequent customer!“

“under sercomestances with virus they've Ben really nice“

“An amazing and tasty experience. I ordered a birthday cake for a party celebrating two kids and the split theme cake exceeded my expectations. Delicious and super fun, I’ll definitely order again!“

“THE BEST BAKERY HOME MADE ITEMS“

“They had one gluten free chocolate cupcake left. I got to pick the topping and they were able to do the peanut butter one. It was AMAZING! Did not taste GF at all. 10/10 recommend!“

“Excellent pastry and awesome service!!!“

“The food was quality, but could have more flavor. The service was friendly, but could have a bit more forwardness by welcoming you as you come in the door and asking if you have ever been there and offering assistance with how everything works, rather than the customer feeling confused and having to ask. The atmosphere is clean and seems well managed, it just needs to be a bit more polished. It is a bit pricey, however, in the correct demographics it will do well. If the flavors of the week were posted in the window with a large bold font, so it can be seen while driving by it would bring more traffic through their doors.“

“The gluten free brownies are amazing!! The best I’ve had! And fantastic customer service! This is a great business, can’t wait to order more!“

“I actually fell upon this bakery on Etsy and didn't realize they were only 20 mins from me. I ordered a box with 7 goodies every single one was phenomenal. Can't wait to go in person!“

“Challah rolls my all time favorite in this city“

“Canal Winchester crumbl cookie is my by far favorite location I’ve ever been too. The owner is the sweetest lady who made my friend who’s never been before very welcomed. The lady working was very kind and knowledgeable about what cookies we should definitely try. Just all and all a very good experience 💖“

“It is great it tastes good and the service is fast

Vegetarian options: All of them

Dietary restrictions: There is not many

Parking: It is great

Kid-friendliness: It is good

Wheelchair accessibility: You can fit a wheelchair in there“

“We asked Lori to make our cake for our wedding. She was very helpful and our cake turned out just as we envisioned. She arrived on time for the wedding, and the cake tasted wonderful. It received many compliments from our guests as well. Thanks, Lori!“

“I'm a long time customer of the Livingston Avenue location, and was sad to see it go, but the new location in Gahanna is spacious, and spectacular! The wide variety of mouth watering donuts, along with the exceptional staff, make this a worthwhile venture for any pastry enthusiast.“

“Great food. Don’t miss out. Trust me, you really want to eat here. I’m a pretty harsh critic and I LOVED it. Will be back soon. If carbs didn’t make people fat, I would eat here at least once a week.“

“Un trabajo hermoso muchas gracias todos mis invitados les encantó el pastel de los 15 lo recomiendo muchísimo y muy delicioso gracias otra vez que Dios la Bendiga“

“We were so impressed with our eggless mixed fruit cake! Before the wedding, I asked if we could do a tasting, and she went above and beyond by custom-making a cake with two different flavors for us to try before we made our final decision.

The wedding cake was absolutely amazing. It was incredibly moist, fresh, and full of delicious fruit flavor. Everyone at our wedding loved it and could not stop talking about how wonderful it was. She truly delivered, and the cake exceeded our expectations. We are so grateful and would highly recommend this bakery!“

“We received these at my office for Christmas this year! Cannot say enough great things about your brownies and such! Every single one was so good, it is hard to pick a favorite, so I won’t!! We enjoyed them all and will order more for us and others!!“

“Awesome! We'll done Eban's!“

“Amazing white corn to shuck & take home, along with tomatoes and peaches.“

“My little brother has a deadly milk allergy, even just accidentally using a contaminated blender could kill him. The workers at the alliance walmart ALWAYS do an incredible job making sure they're careful with his order, and we've never had any issues there!“

“Today was my forst time going and the experience was great! I got there early and asked the worker what was good and he replied everything 😂 And it truly was I tried 7 different items and the total was below $15. I am 100% coming back and bringing friends next time. So awesome its right as you walk in on the shop side of the bigger store and you can go over to the other side and look at the international groceries. Love this place!“

“Soft, buttery bread and delicious puff puff! I always make sure to grab some whenever I’m in the Columbus area. The staff are respectful and provide great customer service. If you’re looking for the best soft, perfectly textured bread, this is the place to go.“

“Awesome donuts!!! Definitely recommend!“

“Love the ice cream it was good“

“Kitties is my favorite coffee shop in Columbus. Great quality coffee, nice outdoor seating and the best cinnamon rolls in town. My daughter loves their milk steamers. Right next to Gramercy bookstore which makes for a perfect afternoon.“

“These Greek pastries are not only delicious but are artfully created. Cia has developed some amazing items using quality ingredients and making unbelievable desserts.We have tried many of her delicacies but our favorite is Melomakarona. She prepares them plain or dipped. They just melt in your mouth!Her packaging of items for gifts is super. She takes great care in the presentation.Donnajean deSilva“

“This cake was absolutely phenomenal! Down to the flavor which was perfectly balanced, the texture was incredibly moist and fluffy, Every bite was a pure delight, I mean every little element was so perfect. however this bakery is a true gem! I’ll personally will be back very soon And not to mention the service was great ! !👏👏“

“Born and raised in the Schenectady county, I grew up LOVING Freigofers! For the love of me I can’t remember the name of my favorite cinnamon rolls they made. I believe they had a cinnamon/ sugar crumble maybe like pecan or something crushed up with it on the top! Does anybody remember the name of those cinnamon rolls? Or a recipe? I crave them monthly.“

“Words can't describe the wonderful work you did on my trading account, I am delighted I trusted you and gave you a chance to help grow my $1000 into $12,000 in just a week, Mrs. Rachael Raschke my family and I are forever indebted to you for the financial stability you brought to our home, I advise the entire public to invest with Rachael Raschke contact via“

“This is a lovely bakery. I buy their Bundt cake’s for the residents birthday’s, and they love them! This is a must try!“

“Venden los panes mas deliciosos que he encontrado en Columbus Ohio“

“fire tres leches 🥰✨ too good omg.“

“Absolutely what I was hoping for and knew I’d get once I FINALLY got the cake I’ve been drooling over for three years! Kennetha made my 40 birthday that much sweeter with an amazing chocolate ganache cake. 🤤 thank you!“

“Great pastries and coffee and atmosphere“

“Very tasty and cute cupcakes for my baby shower that coworkers surprised me with! If I need anything in the future I’ll order here“

“reviews are correct, if your product is ready they will usually load you early, there is some parking but if you park on street you risk a ticket NO PARKING signs everywhere nice polite people quick load! been here a few times usually a good experience“

“**Best Tres Leches Cake in Columbus!**

My wife and I were so excited to find La Campiña, and wow, we haven’t had Tres Leches this good in ages! A neighbor recommended it to us, and they were spot on! The owner is super friendly and welcoming, and the prices are really reasonable too. I honestly wish more people knew about this hidden gem. From now on, this is our go-to spot for birthday cakes and any special event. Oh, and the freshly baked bread? Absolutely amazing“

“I have known Michelle for years and have heard nothing but amazing things about her cakes. This past weekend, I finally had the chance to order some for myself. My twins turned 5, and my daughter wanted a ballerina cake while my son wanted a fire engine cake. Michelle did an absolutely amazing job with both cakes. Not only were they beautiful, but they were delicious! Everyone at the party raved about them! When I closed my cake business several years ago, I sent all of my customers to Michelle just based on word of mouth. Now I know with first hand experience that I made the right decision!!“

“I tried the marbled rye bread and it was delicious. no chemicals. reasonable price. going back for more today“

“I have been a long time lover of Cheryl’s cookies as my mom introduced me to them when she helped Cheryl start her first company. My mom was in banking ironically her name is also Cheryl! When I found out she started a new company, I was ecstatic to try her cookies! And let me tell you, Cheryl has completely outdone herself!“

“Love my coffee and the staff!“