6 Best Bakeries near Reynoldsburg

Sugar Rush Columbus Bakery & Bar Bakery • $$
Recommended
8114 E Broad St, Reynoldsburg

Customers` Favorites

Strawberry Chocolate Marble Birthday Cake
Red Velvet with Cream Cheese Frosting
Lemon Blueberry Cupcake
Custom Graduation Cake
Creme Brulee Cupcake
Strawberry Milkshake
Custom Birthday Cake
Assorted Cupcakes
Birthday Cupcake
Standard Cupcakes

“I personally don't even like cake . I attended a graduation party in 2023 where they served a Sugar Rush cake ,I took a small slice home to be polite 🤦‍♀️one bite and I'm messaging the hostess asking where did you get that cake ...I've been hooked ever since .I've bought thier quick cakes and done custom orders neither have disappointed. I highly recommend !“

4.7 Superb233 Reviews
Sweet Designs Specialty Cakes Bakery • $$
7514 E Main St, Reynoldsburg

“good designs and cakes taste awesome“

4.9 Superb42 Reviews
Amani's Home Bakery | Injera Bakery •
6589 E Main St, Reynoldsburg
4.9 Superb9 Reviews
Nothing Bundt Cakes Bakery • $$
2845 Taylor Rd SW, Reynoldsburg

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Chocolate Chip 10 Bundt Cake
White Chocolate Raspberry
Bundtlet Towers
Red Velvet
Bundtinis

“I placed a mid sized corporate order. It was the 3 tiered bundtlette towers. So many combinations to choose from. The team really help me with the messages and decorative ribbon. Customer service was 2nd to none and the cakes always amaze!“

4.6 Superb33 Reviews
Crumbl - Reynoldsburg Dessert • $$
2863 Taylor Rd Ext, Reynoldsburg

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Chip Cookie
Lemon Bar Cookie
Crumbl Cookies
Key Lime Pie
Mini 12-Pack
Crumbl Water
Lemon Tart
Party Box
Single
4-Pack

“Amazing! Pre ordered and showed up a little early, the store was busy and still managed to welcome us in, inform us of a slight wait and all with smiling faces! Still took them less time than I was quoted and everything was delicious and packaged nice!!“

4.7 Superb305 Reviews
Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery Pizza • $
7516 E Main St, Reynoldsburg

Customers` Favorites

Half 3 Cheezus Begeezus Half Pauper's Pie
Cheese Danish and Chocolate Croissant
White Pizza with Spinach and Garlic
Pepperoni and Extra Cheese Pizza
Blueberry Chocolate Chip Bars
Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza
Pumpkin and Cinnamon Scones
Pauper's Pie with Pepperoni
Garlic Cheddar Bread
Sunnyside Up Pizza

“Tyler’s is amazing! If I could have it everyday I would!“

4.5 Superb101 Reviews

Discover More Cuisines In Reynoldsburg