5 Best Pizza Restaurants in Reynoldsburg

Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery Pizza • $
7516 E Main St, Reynoldsburg

Customers` Favorites

Half 3 Cheezus Begeezus Half Pauper's Pie
Cheese Danish and Chocolate Croissant
White Pizza with Spinach and Garlic
Pepperoni and Extra Cheese Pizza
Blueberry Chocolate Chip Bars
Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza
Pumpkin and Cinnamon Scones
Pauper's Pie with Pepperoni
Garlic Cheddar Bread
Sunnyside Up Pizza

“Tyler’s is amazing! If I could have it everyday I would!“

4.5 Superb63 Reviews
Vick's Gourmet Pizza Pizza • $
7345 E Main St, Reynoldsburg

Customers` Favorites

Side Garden Salad with Italian Dressing
Extreme Pepperoni Pizza
Kids Pepperoni Pizza
Deluxe Quart Salad
Spaghetti Dinner
Supreme Pizza
Gourmet Pizza
21 Meat Pizza
Chicken Wings
All the Way

“super pizzas! lots of variety what is really interesting to me is the great consistency that Vick's has with the number of specialty pizzas that they offer. if you order a specialty pizza this week and then order it, the following week....it is the same great pizza and the same great taste...that is hard to achieve in any business, and especially with food, but Vick's does a PHENOMENAL job...time and time again oh...did I mention....ALL of their STAFF is PHENOMENAL!!!“

4.1 Good101 Reviews
Romeo's Pizza Pizza • $
499 Lancaster Ave, Reynoldsburg

Customers` Favorites

Build Your Own Pizza 16 Extra Large
Build Your Own Pizza 14 Large
Veggie Deluxe Specialty Pizza
Ranch Lovers Buffalo Chicken
Small Build Your Own Pizza
Romeo's Deep Dish Pizza
Original Meat Calzone
Cheese Breadsticks
Traditional Wings
Pepperoni Pizza

“Saturday night was my first time ever having Romeo’s delivered. It was a great experience from the moment they answered the phone, to the pizza, to the cheese bread, leading to the exceptional Delivery Driver who delivered our order to us on my patio! 🥇 A great experience ALL around. What a Turn Key Operation they have on Lancaster Avenue! We will order again!“

4.1 Good66 Reviews
Pizzeria New York Pizza Takeaway • $
7950 E Broad St, Reynoldsburg

Customers` Favorites

One Topping Cheese Pizza
Side of Mikes Hot Honey
Bone in Chicken Wings
Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza New York
Garlic Knots
Breadsticks
Italian

“Great pizza and wings! Highly recommend!“

4.4 Superb25 Reviews
Massey's Pizza - Reynoldsburg Pizza • $
7070 E Main St, Reynoldsburg

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Wings and Deep Dish
Sicilian Deep Dish Pizza
Pepperoni and Sausage
Med Veggie Pizza
Chicken Parmesan
Super Guido Sub
Pepperoni Pizza
Cinnamon Bread
Supreme Pizza
Meatball Sub

“Tonight we ordered our favorite Massey’s pizza; half cheese and half pepperoni, mushroom, and banana peppers. It was delicious! The thin crust is crispy. The tomato sauce is perfectly seasoned and slightly sweet. And Massey’s does not skimp on the toppings! We love including Massey’s in our pizza rotation. We ordered tonight’s pie to go. Service is always friendly and prompt. Our pizza was ready exactly as promised: 20 minutes from ordering to pick up!“

3.9 Good68 Reviews

You May Also Like