10 Best Pizza Restaurants in Reynoldsburg

“Tyler’s is amazing! If I could have it everyday I would!“

“super pizzas! lots of variety what is really interesting to me is the great consistency that Vick's has with the number of specialty pizzas that they offer. if you order a specialty pizza this week and then order it, the following week....it is the same great pizza and the same great taste...that is hard to achieve in any business, and especially with food, but Vick's does a PHENOMENAL job...time and time again oh...did I mention....ALL of their STAFF is PHENOMENAL!!!“

“Great pizza and wings! Highly recommend!“

“Saturday night was my first time ever having Romeo’s delivered. It was a great experience from the moment they answered the phone, to the pizza, to the cheese bread, leading to the exceptional Delivery Driver who delivered our order to us on my patio! 🥇 A great experience ALL around. What a Turn Key Operation they have on Lancaster Avenue! We will order again!“

“Tonight we ordered our favorite Massey’s pizza; half cheese and half pepperoni, mushroom, and banana peppers. It was delicious! The thin crust is crispy. The tomato sauce is perfectly seasoned and slightly sweet. And Massey’s does not skimp on the toppings! We love including Massey’s in our pizza rotation. We ordered tonight’s pie to go. Service is always friendly and prompt. Our pizza was ready exactly as promised: 20 minutes from ordering to pick up!“

“Disappointed they are outsourcing their pizza delivery service through DoorDash. I’m not a DoorDash fan and never will be. We received the room temp pizza because they don’t use a pizza insulated carrier. Also our order wasn’t right. Very disappointed!“

“I usually get pizza from the Creno’s at this location for poker nights. Every time they are quick and well made pies. They do well on the request for extra cheese as well. I’ll continue to order Creno’s for dinner or a group poker night. They are excellent and do really good on the toppings.“

“Im glad i reside close to this location so i can dine here often. The food is ALWAYS fresh and made to order. The employees are super friendly. A special mention to the older lady at the counter, and I apologize for not catching her name, she is SOOOO very nice and helpful and even told us to be careful as we were leaving cause it was starting to rain. Employees like that are few and far between.“

“5/5 most people say their are inconsistencies when it comes to service, sometimes their are more orders therefore it might take longer then usual. Either way… this location is “alright,” obviously I’m not going to say they are better than Pizza Hut. But Donatos is definitely still worth getting from time to time.“

“Ordered delivery from here a few times, and it usually shows up hot about 35 minutes later, but one time, it showed up over 2 hours later, cold and pizza not cut.
No bad weather or anything, so Idk what that was about, but they made up for it by a future order on them, so that was nice! 🤙“