50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Sagamore Hills

“The Tuscan Vine is a restaurant that offers a variety of Italian dishes, including fresh pasta, homemade focaccia bread, and Tiramisu. The pasta Carbonara and bolognese are particularly popular choices. The restaurant has been praised for its attentive and helpful service, with servers like Jamie going the extra mile to make customers feel welcome. However, there have been some inconsistencies in food quality and service. Some customers have reported issues with burnt chicken and small portion sizes, while others have praised the generous portions and excellent quality of the pizzas and salads. The restaurant is generally considered to be kid-friendly, with kids enjoying the buttered noodles and Alfredo sauce in particular. The Tuscan Vine is a great option for those looking for a taste of Italy, but the experience may vary depending on the day and time of visit.“

“Valley Pizza Co. has been highly praised by recent visitors. Customers have enjoyed the wood-fired pizzas, with one visitor expressing that it will now be their favorite. The Detroit-style pizza and cheese bread are also popular choices. The sauce is described as hearty and rich, and the ingredients are noted for their high quality. While the individual slices are a bit pricey, customers have found them to be worth the cost. The service is described as excellent, and the staff is friendly. The cleanliness of the store has also been noted. A variety of menu options, including fresh salads, pistachio cheesecake, and tiramisu, have been well-received. Overall, Valley Pizza Co. is considered an excellent addition to the neighborhood.“

“Athena's is a must-try restaurant with very fresh and delicious food. Their 8 piece chicken W/ Jojos and large ? were loved by customers. The staff is polite, and orders are ready on time. The small perogi pizza is amazing, with perfect crust and generous toppings. The gyro is highly recommended, a great meal under 10 bucks. Stop by Athena's for a great dining experience and tasty food that won't disappoint.“

“Napoleon's Pizza offers outstanding food, including their deluxe pizza, wings, and antipasto salad. The Party Combo with pizza and wings is a popular choice. Customers appreciate the fat, juicy, and crispy wings like the garlic parmesan flavor. Generous portions, great taste, and friendly staff make it a local favorite with 100% positive feedback.“

“Farinacci Pizza has been serving delicious pizza for over 40 years in a nostalgic atmosphere. The pizza is highly praised, with a standout personal pepperoni pizza. The service is generally good, although there may be occasional delays. Notably, they only accept cash, but the owners have been known to show great generosity to customers who forget their wallets. Located in NE Ohio, it's worth the 20-minute drive for a remarkable pizza experience.“

“Russo's Pizza offers some of the best pizza around with great service and a nostalgic atmosphere. Regulars appreciate the fresh and delicious crust, with memories that bring them back time and time again. Families have enjoyed the spot for years, with even young kids declaring it the best pizza place ever. First-timers are warmly welcomed and treated to customized orders, making it a worthwhile drive that guarantees a return visit.“

“Pint & Pie Works is a cozy pizza joint with a charming patio and bar area. They serve high-quality pizzas with flavorful crusts, fresh toppings, and crispy pepperoni. The menu is simple, focusing on pizzas made with bright, non-sweet sauce. The salad is also a highlight, with crisp, cold ingredients and just the right amount of cheese. Friendly servers and a kid-friendly dine-in area make it a great spot to visit on a weekday or for takeout.“

“Luca's New York Style Pizza offers giant, hand-tossed thin-crust pies with great toppings in a clean dining room. They provide fast service and even sell pizza by the slice, warmed up in the oven. The restaurant is praised for its authentic New York-style pizza and delicious meatball Parmesan subs, making it a local favorite.“

“Farinacci Pizza is a family-owned, neighborhood pizza place with multiple locations. They offer delicious pizza, Italian sausage sandwich, and more. The menu is simple and consistent, with options like salad and garlic bread. Customers love the homemade Italian dressing and the friendly service from owners Joe and Debbie. Whether dining in or taking out, Farinacci Pizza is highly recommended for its quality food and welcoming atmosphere. Paying with cash is recommended, as they do not accept credit or debit cards. With a long-standing history and loyal customers, Farinacci Pizza is a go-to spot for generations.“

“East Coast Pizza is a renowned establishment that delivers exceptional pizza made with the finest ingredients. The dough is expertly crafted, and the toppings are perfectly balanced, creating a harmonious and delightful dining experience. The owner's Christian values are reflected in the excellent service and welcoming atmosphere, making it a favorite among locals and travelers alike. Whether you're a pizza connoisseur or simply craving a delicious meal, East Coast Pizza is a must-visit destination that consistently exceeds expectations.“

“Pizza Express is a popular spot, with a convenient and free parking lot. The restaurant is kid-friendly, with staff who are warm and welcoming to children. The menu offers excellent pizzas, with one reviewer declaring it the best in Cleveland, and another stating it's the most delicious they've ever had. While customer service can sometimes fall short, the food and atmosphere make it a must-visit destination.“

“Romito's Pizza West in Independence serves amazing food, including family ribs, salads, mushrooms, and chicken strips, all of which are delicious. Their pizza is exceptional, with a fantastic crust, and their cheese sticks are a hit. The restaurant provides great courtesy and exceptional service, making it stand out from other locations with the same name. With a hometown atmosphere, Romito's Pizza West is a must-try for pizza lovers, offering leftovers that are just as tasty as the initial meal.“

“Eddie's Pizzeria Cerino offers an exceptional dining experience. The modern and inviting decor, along with its spotless cleanliness, create a welcoming atmosphere. The menu boasts outstanding Italian fare, including delectable bread and olive oil, a hearty bowl of soup, fantastic pizza, and the popular Rigatoni D. Customers praise the exceptional quality and generous portions, making it a breath of fresh air in an era of rising prices and shrinking servings. With a friendly staff and a nice ambiance, this restaurant is a hidden gem that delivers excellent Italian cuisine at a reasonable price.“

“Danny Boys Italian Eatery offers a delightful dining experience with its reasonably priced, high-quality food and pleasant service. The menu features a wide variety of options, including salads, pizza, subs, and calzones. Customers have praised the Backstage Classic Woogie, a rolled calzone with pepperoni, sausage, yellow peppers, and a blend of five cheeses, as well as the tasty pepperoni pizza and the Italian Cobb salad. The restaurant's welcoming atmosphere and attentive staff have also been noted, making it a popular lunchtime destination for those in the area.“

“Farinacci Pizza serves excellent pizza and salads, with a focus on fresh and flavorful ingredients. This carry-out only spot offers fast and friendly service, with great prices to match. Expect generous toppings on a thin crust, and a warm welcome from the staff. While there's no dine-in atmosphere, the homemade sauce and crust make it a must-try for pizza lovers.“

“The Tomato Company is a highly-recommended spot for pizza lovers. Known for their delicious food, generous portions, and friendly staff. Their pasta dishes are a standout, with generous servings of pasta, cheese, and chicken. Sandwiches are also a hit, with great portion sizes. Don't miss the fried ravioli, which is a must-try. The pizza is amazing, with signature options like the Wild Midwest and Cheeseland. The restaurant has a small crew that works hard to bring customers their food, often working long hours. Despite the demands of the job, the staff is always willing to make things right if there's an issue. With vegetarian options like salads and veggie subs, and a kid-friendly atmosphere, The Tomato Company is a great choice for families.“

“Rosa's Pizza is a satisfying spot for a delicious meal. Their pepperoni pizza and buffalo ranch wings are fan favorites, and their salads feature fresh vegetables. The thin crust pizzas are made with homemade dough and offer great value. The staff is very nice, and the restaurant has a wonderful atmosphere. Vegetarian options abound, including fabulous eggplant and artichokes.“

“Zeppe's Bistro & Pizzeria consistently provides good food and service. They go above and beyond to ensure customer satisfaction, even resolving issues not their own. This welcoming restaurant accommodates large groups and offers a great atmosphere. Their 6-cut deluxe pizza with traditional crust is a popular choice, and they cater well to customers with disabilities.“

“Gionino's Pizzeria serves exceptional pizza, with some considering it among the best they've ever had. The menu offers a range of options, including large pepperoni extra cheese and medium pepperoni and extra cheese. While some find the sauce a bit sweet, others enjoy it. The restaurant is a great spot for pizza, fried chicken, and jojo's, with many customers highly recommending it.“

“Teresa's Pizza offers delicious pizza with generous toppings and a gluten-free crust option. Customers appreciate the quick delivery service and the flavorful pizza. The garlic parmesan wings might not be for everyone, but the traditional wings are a hit. With a welcoming atmosphere and consistent quality, Teresa's Pizza is a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike.“

“State Road Pizza is a restaurant known for its delicious pizza and wings. The pizza has a crispy crust, with flavorful cheese and sauce, and is not overly greasy. The garlic parm wings are a customer favorite, cooked to a perfect level of doneness. The restaurant also offers cannolis, which are highly praised for their taste and the chocolate on the bottom. Prices are described as reasonable and the service is efficient, with orders arriving on time and hot. Some customers even order from the restaurant regularly. The large pepperoni and sausage pizza, as well as the garlic white pizza, are recommended.“

“Siciley Pizza is a family-owned restaurant that offers a wide variety of options on their menu. The restaurant is known for its delicious and quick service, with friendly staff who are happy to fulfill customer requests. One popular menu item is the Price Buster Pizza, which is described as some of the best pizza in Cleveland. The toppings are plentiful and fresh, and the pizza is a great value for the price. The restaurant also offers a Hershey's Ice-Cream area, which is kept clean and has a wide variety of flavors available. In addition to pizza, Siciley Pizza also offers breaded wings with garlic Parmesan sauce, which are perfectly seasoned and fried. The beef lasagna is also a popular dish, with a huge portion size and well-seasoned noodles. The cheesy bread is crisp on the outside and fluffy on the inside, with a nice amount of cheese. Overall, Siciley Pizza is a great find with excellent food and friendly service. The restaurant is highly recommended for those looking for a new favorite spot.“

“Zeppe's Tavern & Pizzeria serves great pizza, including the popular Double Down with added sausage, which is likely to be the best sausage on a pizza. The restaurant has shown an improvement in quality, offering a variety of dishes such as the Italian salad, which is bursting with fresh ingredients. The service is prompt and friendly, with courteous servers and competitive pricing. The location also offers ample parking and is wheelchair accessible, making it a great option for a night out or pickup order.“

“Rocky's Pizza & Restaurant is a family-friendly establishment known for its delicious pizza and welcoming atmosphere. The pizza here has a perfect balance between crust and toppings, always fresh and filling without any slimy grease. The restaurant also offers a variety of pastas, chicken dishes, and dinner entrées that leave customers talking about and craving more. The staff is friendly and upbeat, making it a great place for both dine-in and takeout. The location has a cozy, clean, and cute ambiance, making it worth the drive for many customers. Overall, Rocky's Pizza & Restaurant is a hidden gem that offers great food at affordable prices.“

“Master Pizza is a well-liked establishment, offering a variety of pizza options such as deep dish, gluten-free Sicilian Detroit Style, and old school pizzas. Customers appreciate the fresh toppings, friendly service, and easy online ordering. The restaurant is clean and the prices are reasonable. It is a great alternative to chain pizza places, reminiscent of the classic pizza experience.“

“Don Gi's Pizzeria is a restaurant known for its delicious and well-prepared food. The club sub is a popular choice, and their fried chicken has received high praise, with customers raving about the moist breast pieces and well-cooked dark meat. The chicken salad is another favorite among customers. For pizza lovers, Don Gi's offers a standout option with a crust that is highly regarded. While the service is friendly, it is recommended to avoid using the interior bathroom. A kids meal is available and was enjoyed by one young customer. Overall, Don Gi's Pizzeria is a solid choice for a variety of meals.“

“Geraci's Restaurant in Pepper Pike offers a delightful dining experience with mouthwatering dishes and fabulous service. The restaurant is perfect for special events, offering a party room where they take care of everything, even ordering the cake. Customers praise the friendly and efficient servers like Ashley and Lesley B, who ensure a terrific experience. Don't miss out on their excellent pepperoni pizza, a crowd favorite.“

“East of Chicago Pizza is a regional favorite known for their delicious pan pizzas and unique taco pizza. Customers love the BLT sub with extra bacon and customizable vegetarian options. While some enjoy the spicy double pepperoni, others find it too hot for kids. With fast service, friendly staff, and discounts for calling in orders, it's the best spot in Brecksville for a tasty meal. Parking is available on the street, making it convenient for a quick takeout or delivery option.“

“Roseland Lanes is a great spot for kids' birthday parties and group events, offering good food, including kid-pleasing pizza, and reasonable rates. The friendly staff provide excellent customer service, and the clean facility features bumpers for young bowlers. It's an ideal venue for a fun and smooth event.“

“Georgio's Oven Fresh Pizza Co. offers yummy pizza at great deals. Orders are taken professionally and are ready for pick-up on time. The restaurant stays open a bit later than others, making it convenient for late eaters. Parking is available, although the shared lot can be small, and the restaurant is wheelchair accessible.“

“3 Palms Pizzeria offers a fantastic dining experience, with a variety of vegetarian options and a great ambiance. The pizza is reportedly delicious, though the interior can be quite loud. While the indoor dining area is beautiful, comfortable, and inviting, the outdoor patio area appears to be in need of some maintenance, with an unkempt and worn-out appearance. Overall, the food and staff are excellent, making this a top-notch Italian restaurant, especially for vegetarian fans of Italian cuisine.“

“Romeo's Pizza offers convenient online ordering and delivery services. While occasionally experiencing issues with delivery, the restaurant's orders are usually well-made and accurate. Their pizzas, hailed as the best in Twinsburg, feature exceptional sauce and crust. Despite some minor setbacks, Romeo's Pizza provides a satisfying dining experience.“

“Gionino's Pizzeria is known for its delicious pizza, including a gluten-free/cauliflower crust option with a perfectly seasoned sauce. The restaurant is kid-friendly, with kids enjoying the pizza. Besides pizza, their Jojo's and chicken are highly recommended. However, there have been some negative experiences with rudeness from certain phone order takers, who were unprofessional and uninterested in addressing customer complaints.“

“Courtyard Cafe is a very nice place to eat with good food and affordable prices. Workers are friendly and efficient, providing a pleasant dining experience. The restaurant is conveniently located in a shopping strip with ample parking available. While one customer had trouble reaching them by phone due to a closure until April 15, the overall experience is positive. The layout of the place is cute and awesome, with delicious food and great service that left customers too busy enjoying their meals to take pictures. With reasonable prices averaging $25-$30 per person, Courtyard Cafe is recommended for a satisfying dining experience.“

“Niko's Gyros To-Go in Broadview Heights offers delicious and fresh gyros, as attested by multiple customers. The potato barrels are a must-try, known for their great taste. The restaurant's service is commendable, with staff providing excellent customer service. The menu, offering flavorful hummus and tzatziki, has been praised for its quality and freshness of ingredients. The Gyro dinner box is a popular choice, providing a satisfying amount of food. Niko, the restaurant owner, has been described as approachable and enthusiastic about the food. Overall, Niko's Gyros To-Go offers a satisfying and enjoyable dining experience.“

“Antonio's Pizzeria LoSchiavo serves delicious food with friendly and quick service. Their pizzas, including the butter crust pizza with pepperoni, are a highlight, with flavorful crust and cheese. The broasted chicken and Jo Jo's are also popular, and the in-house delivery drivers ensure convenient delivery. With great salad dressing and a satisfying menu, this pizzeria is worth a try.“

“Gionino's Pizzeria is a popular spot known for its exceptional customer service and old-school charm. Orders are taken over the phone, and delivery is always prompt and friendly. The menu favorites include the Italiano fried chicken dinner, JoJo's, and garlic bread with cheese, all made to perfection. Pizzas, such as the Philly Cheesesteak, Deluxe, and Pepperoni and Sausage, are hot and ready for pickup, even on busy days like the Super Bowl. With its crispy crust, sweet and tangy Cole slaw, and savory sauce, Gionino's is a must-visit for pizza lovers.“

“Little Caesars Pizza is a popular local restaurant known for its delicious and consistent pizza offerings. Customers praise the restaurant's amazing preparation, with the food always being on point and the employees typically greeting them with a smile. The pizza is described as "absolutely amazing," with the cheese being melty and gooey, the toppings fresh, and the sauce just right. While the restaurant can get quite busy, this is seen as a testament to the quality of the food. Some customers even go out of their way to visit this specific location, driving 30 minutes from Westlake, as they believe it offers the best Little Caesars pizza in the area. However, a few customers have reported minor issues, such as missing dipping sauces or drinks, as well as concerns about hygiene practices during busy periods.“

“Teresa's Pizza is a restaurant with a mixed reputation. Some customers have been disappointed by their mozzarella sticks, which have a unique taste that may not be to everyone's liking, and their pizzas, which are likened to gas station fare. However, others have had a more positive experience, praising the friendly and helpful staff, excellent sandwiches, and aromatic pizzas. The restaurant is willing to accommodate customers with special needs, such as delivering pizzas to vehicles. Overall, Teresa's Pizza seems to be a decent option for a quick bite, but may not impress everyone.“

“Georgio's Oven Fresh Pizza Co. in Maple Heights is a go-to spot for delicious and affordable pizzas that bring happiness with every bite. Whether you're looking for a classic pepperoni with bacon and Italian seasoning or a veggie pizza, their pies are made with care and love. Along with tasty garlic cheese breadsticks and brownies, Georgio's offers the option to request a freshly made pizza in-store. The welcoming atmosphere and great food make it a must-visit for anyone craving a hot and ready pizza experience.“

“Rascal House in Maple Heights, OH is a highly recommended spot with delicious food. Their penne pasta with a unique sauce and roast beef sub were very good. Known for their amazing pizza, this location stands out as the best among others. With a loyalty points system for free pizza slices, it's no wonder customers keep coming back for years. Whether dining in or ordering delivery, Rascal House ensures a consistently great experience.“

“Casamel's Pizza offers a variety of delicious options, such as pepperoni pizza and cheese breadsticks. Customers have enjoyed the excellent taste of the food, with some considering it one of the best pizzas in Cleveland. However, some have noted that the sauce can be lacking, with minimal sauce on the pizza and wings. Despite this, the unique pizza sauce and quality of the food make this restaurant worth a visit for those looking for a tasty meal in the Parma area.“

“The Hotdog Cafe is an amazing little cafe that offers a delightful dining experience. The food is described as "such amazing food," with a "very very good" Medium BYO and Polish BOY. The service is noted as "courteous and attentive," and the overall experience is "quick and fast." Customers have praised the fair prices, solid hotdogs, and great service, making it a must-try destination for those craving a tasty meal.“

“Zeppe's Pizzeria offers tasty and reasonably priced pizza. Online ordering and pickup are convenient and hassle-free. While the atmosphere is not meant for dining in, the service is friendly, polite, and helpful. Vegetarian options are plentiful, and the pizza is a great value for the price. Note that food quality can vary, with some dishes, like wings, falling short of expectations.“

“Gionino's Pizzeria offers a delightful dining experience with its tasty pizza and friendly staff. Customers praise the great customer service, delicious meat pizza, and overall fantastic pizza. The restaurant is a popular choice for both regular visits and special occasions, such as a birthday party.“

“Antonio's Pizzeria LoSchiavo is a restaurant that offers delivery service with friendly and punctual staff. The food has been consistently praised as great, with specific mentions of the BBQ chicken pizza and Italian subs being amazing. The pizza, in particular, has received high remarks, and the pizza nuggets are also a popular choice. Despite a minor ordering issue, the restaurant's customer service was commended for quickly resolving the problem by offering to make a new pizza and allowing the customer to keep the original order. The manager's kindness and the quality of the food, even when there was a mistake, were appreciated.“

“Northfield Inn Restaurant & Lounge offers a friendly and relaxed atmosphere with excellent home-cooked meals. Customers praise the chicken Alfredo for its perfect texture and delicious sauce, made from scratch. Known for consistent quality for over 50 years, their chicken or veal parm dishes are always a hit. The chicken piccatta is delicate and delicious, making it a top choice for Italian cuisine at a reasonable price.“

“I love Domino's..! However, they have messed up my order b4 so always good to check before walking out. This last order the young lady called to verify twice to make changes & it was still not right. But, they were friendly and helpful. It was ready on time and I ordered at 7:30 am for dinner & placed it for the time I wanted, which was great.!! Ill continue to order from thislicatikn just making sure to check b4 leaving the store. I prefer carry out over Delivery..! Most mistakes happen with Delivery.

Parking: The parking is not great but, its parking free on street or across the street in the lot. I never really have a hard time finding parking“

“Papa John's Pizza is a welcoming and efficient restaurant that serves delicious and freshly cooked pizzas. Upon entering, customers are greeted by friendly staff, such as Lance, who demonstrate a clear passion for their craft. The restaurant offers a variety of options, including the $6.99 mix and match deal, and ensures that orders are prepared quickly and accurately. The pizzas are cooked to perfection, with generous toppings that are carefully placed. Pizza night is always a treat at Papa John's, where customers can enjoy a hot and fresh meal, making it a homey and satisfying dining experience.“