15 Best Pizza Restaurants in Sylvania

“Stopped in for lunch in the middle of the day. Had a great experience. Madalyn was a excellent waitress she took really good care of us. The pizza was good. The Alfredo was absolutely the best I have had in town. The pasta was drowning in the Alfredo which is how I prefer. The Caesar salad was really delicious.“

“Best Pizza & gyros Anywhere!!!“

“My husband and I had such a great experience tonight! First time at the VI and our bartender Tati was absolutely amazing—friendly, attentive, and made us feel welcome from the moment we sat down. She kept our drinks full, and had such a positive attitude all night. It's clear she genuinely cares about her customers. Great service like this is hard to find, and she truly made our night even better. We'll definitely be back!“

“Great pizza friendly service and subs are awesome and delicious 😋“

“headed to Marco's after a long shift to get some food... it was literally a blizzard outside. was dreading getting back out to pick up my pizza when the staff ran my order back out to me. Sweet people AND the best pizza I've had in Toledo so far.“

“Love the ham and cheese sub! Kayla is awesome! So sweet and kind. Had super fast service!“

“I can’t say enough good things about Geo’s Pizzas & Loft at the Sylvania Tamoshanter Rink! The staff is incredibly friendly and always provides great service, creating a welcoming atmosphere for adults, kids, and families alike. Every bartender I’ve interacted with goes above and beyond to remember customer names and favorite food or drink orders, which really makes you feel valued.

As a mom of two hockey players who spends 4–7 days a week at the rink, I absolutely love this place! I would highly recommend stopping by for a yummy meal and a few laughs if you’re at the rink for any sport or activity. The combination of excellent food, drinks, and an inviting atmosphere makes Geo’s Pizzas & Loft a standout spot for anyone visiting the rink.

Highly recommend to anyone looking for great food, great service, and a friendly environment!“

“Tried Romeo’s for the first time tonight, we will definitely be back! Ordered a build your own and cheese bread! Both amazing!“

“The pizzas are absolutely delicious! It's a perfect thin crust and the specialty pizzas are great! I really enjoy the buffalo chicken.

Service is lacking, however. My in-laws got the wrong pizza and were not provided with updates for their corrected pizza.

There is no music, which makes it feel empty even when it's full.

The bathrooms could use a deep clean as the floors are sticky.“

“We came here for dinner and there were 7 of us. Hostess told us there was not a table available so they put us on a list. Than she told us we had to wait in our car. My grandchildren were busy playing on the game machines so I asked her if we could just hang out by the games and she was very rude to me and said we were in the way. So we had to take the small children outside and wait. So than we kept seeing people coming in with the same amount of people being seated before us. Finally when we were seated the waitress took our order and we literally waited for an hour and a half for our food. The waitress got an attitude with us when we asked about our order instead of apologizing to us. I probably would of understood if the place was busy but by the time we sat down all the tables around us were empty. I felt very disrespected and felt like the hostess and the waitress were very rude . Also the food was terrible. I will never go to this place ever again. Terrible customer service“

“Great beer and food, highly recommend if you're in the area!“

“This evening was my first time checking out the taproom. I no longer live in Sylvania and tonight that breaks my heart because I can't eat their spinach pie every day. I would eat this breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Our server, Krista, was fab. Excellent service, great food, great drinks. Full stop. Krista made our night special. Spot on food and drink recommendations and excellent service. Did I mention the spinach pie?? Best I've ever had. I'm glad we did ourselves the favor of going to the Taproom. It is an experience we won't soon forget. Thanks to our amazing bartender, chef, and server!!“

“Five stars!! Best pizza around!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“We usualy go to pizza hut . We have not ordered from Domino's in over 20 years . I've seen your Comercial lately and decided to give it a try. Wow amazing pizza . I'm truly impressed. These are the best pizzas we've had. Thank you. Thank you your our new pizza place. GREAT JOB. Char“

“I stopped in for cheesy bread as a snack during lunch hours on a Saturday. They didn't have any ready at that moment but the manager without hesitation offered to make it within 5 mins. That was super nice of him and I great appreciated his offer!“