50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Waterville

“Yummm!!! First off, Aiden was so polite and patient taking my daughter and I order over the phone. He said 30-45mins. Food was delivered almost exactly 30 mins! Piping hot! Absolutely delicious! Haven't ordered in a few years from that location but absolutely will from now on. Great job staff!“

“We were passing through from Wisconsin. Even though it is a carryout pizza place, the very friendly owner set us up with a table, plates, napkins and even bottled water. The pizza had REAL mozzarella cheese..hot and stringy. The sauce was great and the crust crispy. Wish there were one in Wisconsin.“

“Pizza was good and ready right on time. I ordered online and was disappointed that I was not contacted regarding the fact they were out of mushrooms for our combo pizza. I would have liked to have the opportunity to pick a substitute topping. I didn't know about this until they gave me the pizza. I asked if we might be able to get a discount on it, as I had already purchased an additional topping. They did tell us we would get one free next time as a compensation. This was a more than satisfactory resolution.“

“I ordered a "macaroni and cheese pizza" w/bacon to go. The order was done at thw expected time. The employees seemed distant and uninterested, kind of bored. The waiting area was sparse, narrow, and uncomfortable, but not to the point where I'd complain, but definately nothing to rave about. Overall, if you make a pick-up order, I wouldn't recommend arriving early. Just come in, get the food and leave.“

“Delicious pizza first of all. My wife and I finished the whole thing. Staff was very friendly and pointed us in the right direction as far as ordering food & drinks. Yes, you go up to order your own pizza, but they do bring it to you. Fun atmosphere for a trip out without the kids!“

“The very best service and food for our wedding rehearsal dinner! John, as well as our servers Ashley and Jordyn were fabulous! Our guests were delighted with the menu and service. Hats off to all who made our celebration a big success.“

“My wife and I decided to eat here after going to a haunted house. We sat down and looked over the menu and chose the baked potato pizza and garlic fingers. I like trying unusual pizza flavors and was not disappointed! I went to the counter to order and the cashier apologized for not taking our order at our table, they were just coming down from a large group. I told her not to worry, we weren't from BG and it was our first time at the restaurant and didn't know what to expect. They brought out the garlic fingers first, about 10 min after putting our order in, and they were fantastic! Their crust is light and fluffy and the crunch was perfect! We would definitely drive an hour to eat here again.“

“Staff was absolutely amazing. My husband and I had a wonderful experience there. Our server Bella was amazing and we got talking to the owner and he was amazing and helping out. We could tell the staff loved working there and had smiles on their faces. 500/500 stars. Would recommend to everyone.“

“LAWD, can I get an amen!? This food is so good. I could eat every single morsel of it in one sitting, if my body allowed it. Thank you for always having amazing food and it always arrives hot and fresh. Other local pizza places really can’t compete with the taste and they always put enough cheese.“

“We had a Celebration of Life for my brother Jeff Fyock on Saturday July 27th. Everyone was so impressed with the event & how the girls we had kept me informed all evening. Growing up in South Toledo alot of our guests said that your pizza tasted like the old Gino's on Arlington Ave. This is my 3rd event that I've had @ Capers. Please give your staff a high five for helping my family make memories.“

“We love Jets Pizza, specifically our Bowling Green location! It was a challenging day and I asked in the comments to write a joke in the box. I honestly did not think they would pull through but THANK YOU to whoever wrote the joke. It might be small but it’s a mighty gesture!!! 🤎🤎🤎“

“The 8-corner pizza is my favorite chain pizza, hands down. I get it well done, it's so crispy and delicious with just the right amount of crust, sauce, toppings. Can't comment on delivery as I usually pick up, but they are very fast making it and I seldom have to wait.“

“great!“

“I have gone to this Vito’s a few times. I am thinking that Vito’s is the best pizza delivery out of all of the take out pizza restaurant’s. I know the manager of this location and she is a very nice person. The staff is always friendly and happy to help you out.“

“The best pizza buffet we have ever eaten! Service was excellent!“

“We had so much fun the night of 11/21/24. We got there about 6pm, last minute trip for my daughter’s bday. All three gentlemen working were on top of their game. Pizza was fresh, we ordered a cake, and they brought out candles and everything we needed. Dancing and music was on..Thanks for making our night! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“I ordered food for my daughter and her team at UTMC ER as a thank you. Mancino’s was so gracious and gave them all cookies to go with their meal as a thank you! This made my whole night. It was so nice to see people come together. The team was so grateful for everything and said the food was great! Thank you!“

“I love pizza. I like almost every pizza I can get my hands on but I really really love Vito’s Pizza. Not only is their pizza beyond delicious, they also employ awesome people. They are consistently friendly and polite, but what’s more, they obviously enjoy where they work. It’s genuinely a fun and happy atmosphere.
Did I mention they make the extraordinarily delicious pizza??“

“this was my first time getting pizza here and it was an excellent first impression. Kitchen staff was helpful and friendly, the pizza is delicious, and the draught root beer is excellent. they can it there at the bar!
i will definitely be a returning customer!“

“I've ordered at least a dozen subs over thirty days, all have been great. Mike's is 3 min away, awesome location on Angola. The staff has always been nice and professional.
They only have two seats to dine in, so...Still awesome!“

“Deep Dish pizza was amazing! Best I've had in awhile! Our server, Jettona, was fantastic!! ❤️🍕“

“Pizza Aroma is delicious and their staff is amazing. My order is always and correct and delicious! Pizza is much tastier and a better price than the chains! The garlic bread with cheese and wings are awesome! Highly recommend them! (I’ve stopped in and had delivery)“

“This is my favorite pizza in the area! The crust is the perfect thickness & has a great crunch at the end, the sauce is AMAZING, the cheese is unique & delicious, & the cook is the perfect amount of doneness. The cinnamon sticks are super fluffy when most places have chewy ones. I recommend extra icing!

I agree that the policy of having to show your payment card & ID is outdated & unnecessary, and they also cut unevenly sized slices, but both of these flaws are negligible to me.

I highly recommend!“

“7/6 around 2:30p the young brunette female working the counter was so sweet! Very personable and I appreciated the “gluten free! :)” written on my pizza box so I knew it was in fact the correct pizza and safe to eat. Pizzas are great! Thank you!

Dietary restrictions: Gluten Free Pizza Available :)“

“06/14/25 today my mom and sister came in from Oklahoma and I treated them for pizza from this Marcos location here on route 25 in Perrysburg. oMG. Best pizza ever! I couldn't be more pleased! can't wait to order again and take it back home in Maumee!“

“Amazing pizza! There is not one pizza on the menu that I don't want to try“

“Special thanks to Mama Mary’s for making incredible pizzas for our son’s first birthday! We had ordered pizza from a local warehouse club and they never started our order! We knew Mama Mary’s had to be our next call (and should have been our first!). The gal on the phone was so kind, she told me they would get it to us as soon as it was done and they DID. That pizza was steaming hot when delivered. We love Mama Mary’s and frequently order from here- and our kiddo loves the heart shaped pizza 🥰 I’d highly recommend getting Mama Mary’s for any social event you are having!! Everyone asked us where we ordered from!“

“Really great customer service and very kind staff!!“

“Nothing but good experiences but tonight really stood out. ordered pizza and went to pick it up. we waited a little longer then normal and the manager noticed and decided to comp our meal. There ovens went down and they were really behind. She was slammed trying to get orders out but still noticed how long we were waiting. I want to recognize the manager, the store and the employees for doing such a great job.“

“Breadsticks all day every day. So good and so buttery! 2 will fill you up so the third (small order) is over the top awesome.

It's a local favorite so you'll probably have to wait to be seated but oh well - all good things have a wait.“

“Got a replacement pizza from the last time I came and this time it was perfection. Cheesy, garlicky goodness. And the lemon pepper wings were out of this world. I’d get them more if they were a little cheaper but for a treat they were fantastic.“

“Great place! Good good!“

“🍕🇮🇹🍅🧄🧀🍂

Review: Papa John's

The visit was a mixed bag, but overall, the pizza and the experience held up!

🔎 The Situation:
A dear friend from afar surprised me with a pizza as a thoughtful gesture during a tough time. However, I couldn’t make it to the store within the allotted pickup window. I completely understand that this policy ensures only fresh, delicious food for customers, though I do hope the unused pie was donated or eaten instead of wasted.

💡 The In-Store Experience:
When I arrived, the proprietor—who I believe owns the shop—was curt and seemed unaware of my order. Thankfully, the manager I had spoken to earlier stepped in to clarify and saved the day. She quickly informed me my fresh pizza was about to go in the oven. Big points to the manager for professionalism and attention to detail!

🍕 The Product:
Papa John's remains a standout in the pizza world. The dough, with its perfect balance of fluffiness and chew, and the subtly sweet tomato sauce never fail to hit the spot. And let’s be real—any competitor that doesn’t include garlic butter and a pepperoncini in the box is just playing catch-up.

🏡 Delivery Thoughts:
Though Papa John’s doesn’t deliver to my area, which is far from rural, this lack of service keeps it a special treat. Still, corporate, you’re leaving money on the table—there’s a white-collar hub in Jackson waiting for those delivery zones to expand!

👍 Verdict:
The food and the female manager’s professionalism won me over. No notes other than this: keep being consistent and delicious. I’ll gladly patronize again, even if I have to pick up in person.

🍕🇮🇹🍅🧄🧀🍂“

“Semi retired due 2 failed back surgeries/health issues and new to the south side of Toledo so I order out pretty often. Vito's Pizza 315 S Detroit Ave. Is one of very few businesses that to consistently provide great service to us since our move“

“hands down the best Gino's in the entire city. if you disagree, I can't trust your judgment on pretty much anything in existence“

“The food was really good but was quite disappointed that our server was not wearing a mask. So it makes me wonder who cooked my my food. Won'tbe going back.“

“Called in a larger order and the guy on the phone was very helpful with the amount of people & how many pizzas to order!!When I arrived I was greeted by the friend staff & they had all my food ready and even helped me carry it out to my car!The pizza was so fresh hot and delicious! I definitely recommend them and do yourself a favor and get extra ranch it’s so good!

Dietary restrictions: They have gluten free & cauliflower crust options“

“I ordered a custom pizza and Chasaidy took my order and made my pizza. Nicholi rang me out and was a pleasant chap. When I got to my car I couldn't wait to try my thin crust square cut so I got a bite in my car. The cheese pull and drool was amazing. 😍 And they put garlic butter everywhere like I asked.
Definitely coming back.“

“Marco's is the 'go to pizza crafter's when staff is on site at our Toledo, Ohio site. Whether we have a large group dining together or just one person trying to fix a machine, Marco's is quick, efficient, and always friendly to our team!“

“This seems like a weird review but my Marko's was a home visit. You know home delivery. Which went timely and well. I ordered an Xlarge speciality pizza and it special cut for a zip lock pot luck party. Marko's did exactly as I requested. I do not order pizza very often, however it must have been excellent because it was eaten within a half hour.“

“The food was fantastic, and Alyssa provided excellent service! Our group was well taken care of, and we had a blast with the games and bowling. This was our first visit, and we’ll definitely be back. Thanks to Joe and the entire team!“

“This place is a bit on the pricier side but the pizza was good, just small for the price. You can order online and pick up in store. The Hawaiian chicken pizza and cheese bread are good. Staff always seems to be working hard, and my order has been right both times I’ve eaten here.“

“We loved our visit. We ordered drinks and got them fast. Service was fast and very helpful when trying to find what was good. She gave great feedback on our order. We got two pizzas. Both ended up being 1,000 times better than we could have ever imagined. Loved the food and all the friendly people working.

Parking: Parking lot is off to the side of the building.“

“Big menu.... Great food.... Great prices...And the GM is pretty sweet!!“

“I believe this is the place to go if you want it all.Food,cold beer,pool tables, TVs, and good music“

“Thank you Lisa and her team today for creating Valentine’s pizzas for my son and his preschool party. We are so thankful! 🍕❤️“

“Pizza Hut. Does. It. RIGHT!! The experiences we have had with Pizza Hut in this time has been very above and beyond!!!! Their service, promptness, and high regards to the situation with their customers is AMAZING. The pizza is great either way but this picture should tell you EVERYTHING and be EVERY reason to order from them!! Thanks Pizza Hit in Maumee, OH!!! Keep it up!!!“

“Small place, busy employee but still took the time to help out my family and I. We got 3 calzones one cheese very good, pep bacon also very good. Dough for my veggie calzone or cheese- idk somehow mixed weird and gave it a strange texture, this one maybe needs a longer cook time. Or to be cooked open face somehow then closed, not sure what happened ingredients were fresh just mixed weird, nobodies fault, big enough that I ate half of my husbands and was satisfied.“

“went in with a group of 9 last night. service was less than impressive. Expensive for what it is .. Definitely need to step there game up“