18 Best American Restaurants near West Liberty

Liberty Gathering Place American • $
111 N Detroit St, West Liberty

Customers` Favorites

Beef and Noodles with Mashed Potatoes and Lima Beans
Gravy and Biscuits with Eggs
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
Soup \u0026 Salad Bar
Soup & Salad Bar
Eggs and Bacon
Club Sandwich

“A charming “mom & pop” restaurant vibe. The food was delicious. The kids had chicken strips, the men had lunch meals, I ate breakfast. There are a lot of menu options at reasonable prices!! My favorite part about it all was the homemade pie they do in house there at the restaurant. It really set them apart. We had the coconut crème pie and the peanut butter pie. My daughter had a strawberry milkshake & my son had a bowl of vanilla ice cream. Nothing but good things to say about this place. West liberty has a cool antique store and thrift store as well.“

4.2 Good73 Reviews
The Syndicate American • $$
213 S Main St, Bellefontaine - 7.4 miles

Customers` Favorites

Buttermilk Fried Chicken \u0026 Waffles
Buttermilk Fried Chicken & Waffles
8 Oz Barrel Cut Filet Migion & Eggs
Pesto Marinated Chicken Paillard
Candied Bacon Deviled Eggs
Thai Chicken Lettuce Wraps
Spinach & Artichoke Dip
Chicken and Waffles
Praline French Toast
Mushroom Ravioli

“Hubby took me there for my Birthday dinner. The appetizer’s were delicious. The ribeye steak dinners and all the fixings were amazing and all topped with an excellent server. Sorry to say it was our first time and sad we hadn’t checked it out sooner!!! Definitely going back soon!!!“

4.5 Superb187 Reviews
The Farmer's Daughter American • $
904 Miami St, Urbana - 9.9 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Potato Casserole
Cashew Chicken Salad
Fried Chicken Salad
Chicken and Noodles
Country Fried Steak
Sweet Potato Fries
Breakfast Skillet
Beef and Noodles
Texas Sheet Cake
Farmers Daughter

“This is a yearly tradition with me taking my kids for breakfast here when we're in Ohio. We enjoy the food + the Christmas tree by the fireplace always makes a good picture. They also like to sit on the tractor for a picture each year as well.“

4.7 Superb181 Reviews
Chefhouse Seafood • $
1332 S Main St, Bellefontaine - 6.19 miles

“Top Notch! fast, fresh, and friendly! You get what you deserve for a price worth the while!“

4.7 Superb93 Reviews
Fat Boy's Pizza & Ice Cream American • $
2527 US-68, Bellefontaine - 5.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Beer Battered Onion Rings
Pepperoni Sausage Pizza
Pizza with 1 Topping
Pepperoni Pizza
With Sweet Sauce
Garlic Bread
Cheese Sticks
Garlic Knots
blt Pizza
Gyro

“All the workers here are so sweet and the best pizza ever“

4.5 Superb71 Reviews
Airport Cafe American • $
1636 N Main St, Urbana - 8.26 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Bologna Sandwich
Homemade Sausage Gravy
Grilled Chicken Salad
Bacon Cheeseburger
Roast Beef Hotshot
Airport Sandwich
Black Raspberry
Battered Shrimp
Buffalo Burger
Mashed Potatoes

“We came here tonight to try their new Strawberry Jam Bacon Donut Burger and not only was it phenomenal, but everything else we ordered was amazing. The service was top tier and all the staff so friendly. So happy we decided to support local tonight!“

4.5 Superb162 Reviews
Studebaker's Country Restaurant American • $
4679 US-36, Urbana - 11.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Biscuits and Sausage Gravy
Turkey blt Sandwich
Biscuits and Gravy
Trucker Special
Mashed Potatoes
House-Made Pie
Chopped Steak
Cheeseburger
Potato Cakes
Battered Cod

“I just had breakfast here with my adult son. The food was delicious and the coffee was the best I ever had. The staff are so friendly.“

4.4 Superb120 Reviews
Our Hero Express Subs American • $
964 N Main St, Urbana - 9.06 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Cheesesteak 12
Loaded Cheesesteak 6
Chicken Cheese Steak
Super Cheese Steak
Open Face Pepperoni
Club on a Sub Bun
Fried Mushrooms
Homemade Chili
Cheeseburger
Traditional

“I feel like every American in the 80’s and 90’s grew up with a sub shop like this- no-nonsense, family owned, great food at reasonable prices. Here, they call it mayo, not aioli. Got a baked ham and a cheesesteak. Bread was flat, easy to grab and bite, crispy on the outside/chewy on the inside. Crisp lettuce, a little tang from mayo. Such a killer restaurant!!!!! 10 out of 5“

4.3 Superb78 Reviews
Loyal Order of Moose Bar •
632 Mosgrove St, Urbana - 9.47 miles

“This place is excellent for drinks, meals...the prices are unbeatable, and gathering with good people. Friendly bartenders and members!“

4.9 Superb35 Reviews
Mumford's Potato Chip & Deli Sandwich Shop • $
325 N Main St, Urbana - 9.76 miles

Customers` Favorites

The Reuben on Wheat Bread
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Chocolate Brownie
Turkey Bacon Club
Turkey Sandwich
Club Sandwich
Pizza Sub

“I love mumfords we drove 4 hours away from elkhart indiana to get their chips“

4.7 Superb65 Reviews
Ron's Pizza Of Bellefontaine Pizza • $
712 S Main St, Bellefontaine - 6.86 miles

Customers` Favorites

Single Topping Pizza
Garlic Cheese Bread
Cheese Twist
Tossed Salad
Breadsticks
Taco Fries
Wings

“We were originally looking for taco salads, but after seeing the taco pizza on the menu ordered it instead. OMG, this thing was da bomb! We ordered an extra large! lots left over, but wife is sharing the rest at work with friends. Best taco pizza I have had in my 62 years. It was our first visit but will not be the last. Excellent beyond all expectations.“

4.6 Superb65 Reviews
Main Street Marketplace American • $$$
130 S Main St, Bellefontaine - 7.46 miles

“Warm and friendly staff, great smoothies, loaded omelettes, and healthy / delicious wraps and salads as well. The owner puts his heart and soul into the experience.“

4.9 Superb8 Reviews
Waffle House Breakfast • $
1133 N Main St, Bellefontaine - 8.71 miles

Customers` Favorites

Biscuits and Gravy with Tabasco and Black Pepper
Hash Browns Smothered Covered Chunked Add Gravy
Bacon Eggs and Grits Bowl Hash Browns
Sausage Egg & Cheese Hashbrown Bowl
Sausage Egg and Hasbrown Bowl
Chicken Melt Hashbrown Bowl
Chocolate Chip Waffle
Steak Breakfast Bowl
Texas Toast Philly
Steak \u0026 Eggs

“great service great jukebox great ppl“

4.4 Superb147 Reviews
Whit's Frozen Custard Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $
112 S Main St, Bellefontaine - 7.5 miles

Customers` Favorites

Salted Caramel Cookie Dough
Almond Joy
Brownie

“I went in craving a chocolate malt, and Wyatt (the guy behind the counter) was super efficient and friendly—he whipped it up lightning-fast without missing a beat, even during a busy moment. He nailed it perfectly: thick, chocolatey, malty goodness with just the right consistency. No lumps, no weak flavor—just pure indulgence in every sip. It hit the spot so hard I was grinning the whole way out!

The place has a great small-town vibe, clean and welcoming, with fun options like shakes, sundaes, and their signature blends. Generous portions at fair prices too. If you're in Bellefontaine, do yourself a favor and stop by—ask for Wyatt to make your malt, you won't be disappointed!

Highly recommend—5 bright, shining stars! 🍦“

4.2 Good23 Reviews
LINCOLN & MAIN GASTROPUB Gastropubs • $
624 N Main St, Urbana - 9.55 miles

Customers` Favorites

Southern Rock Pulled Pork
Jalapeno Firecracker Rolls
Hamburger and Tater Tots
Classic Pulled Pork
Korean Beef Tacos
Mile High Burger
Bourbon Burger
Flight of Beer
Fish & Chips
Marvin Mac

“Amazing experience as out of towners passing through. We were seated immediately and Grant was extremely warm and welcoming right away. We enjoyed a conversation at the bar with Grant, Sunny and Josh while we had our late lunch which was AMAZING! So glad I chose this spot to fill our bellies and meet some locals 🥰👏 would love to visit again soon!“

4.2 Good106 Reviews
Iron City Sports Bar Sports Bar • $
1125 S Main St, Bellefontaine - 6.46 miles

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Iron City Burger
Chicken Tenders
Mashed Potatoes
Cheeseburger
Pulled Pork
Beer Cheese
Tater Tots
Sandwich
Boneless

“First time being back since they first open. The staff was great got seated right away then the waiter was right there taking drink orders. I ordered wings and garlic parm fries. Wife got the burger with the pulled pork on it. everything came out hot and fresh with great taste. There was a couple downside my wings came out needing a life jacket way to much sauce. Plus for being a sit down restaurant it would of been nice to have actual silverware instead of pre packaged plastic silverware. Will definitely be back.“

4 Good86 Reviews
Bob Evans Family • $
2100 S Main St, Bellefontaine - 5.47 miles

Customers` Favorites

Homestyle Beneless Fried Chicken Breast
Bob Evans Wildfire Chicken Salad
Family Size Chicken Cobb Salad
Reese's Peanut Butter Pie
Signature Chicken Salad
Grilled Chicken Breast
Hash Browns Home Fries
Brioche French Toast
Buttermilk Hotcakes
Banana Nut Bread

“they was all very polite & it was clean.“

3.5 Good142 Reviews
Tumbleweed Tex Mex Grill & Margarita Bar Bar & Grill • $
2241 S Main St, Bellefontaine - 5.29 miles

Customers` Favorites

Queso Chicken Rolls Pretzel Bites
Cheeseburger and Fries
White Queso and Chips
Chips and Salsa
Angus Burger
Steak Dinner
Baked Potato
Cheese Dip
Sliders
Nachos

“Tasia, thank you for excellent service today. You are so polite and efficient. The cook made my 6 oz. Sirloin a perfect medium-rare. So flavorful and delicious. We ordered the $10 sirloin+2 sides deal. Exceptional value for a delicious meal, served with perfection. Thank you, $1.99 margaritas are strong and tasty for the cost.“

3.3 Good127 Reviews

You May Also Like