38 Best American Restaurants near West Milton

“True mom & pop restaurant in a small town. They get busy and service slows, but it gives you time to take in the true family atmosphere. It'll remind you of cheers, once they meet you, everyone there knows your name!! Truly love the place. And their food is amazing!!!!“

“This is not a high end establishment. The chair leather is cracked, the room is warmer than you might like and there are no guidelines for how a new person navigates their experience - aka we showed up, no one greeted us and we sat ourselves. That being said - 5 minutes of looking at the menu that was on the table a lovely young lady showed up to take our order. She was helpful and friendly and we felt much more at ease. The food was amazing....like REALLY amazing...and the food runner was also lovely and friendly. When we were done, we asked for boxes and the check and everyone was just fantastic. -- For anyone looking for that 'Secret Gem'...this is the place. We will be back.“

“Absolutely delicious! One of the biggest burgers I’ve ever seen. Wraps grilled to perfection. And a tater tot casserole that had us talking about our childhood. Highly recommend“

“Food was great & our server, Dylan, was amazing!! Strongly recommend!“

“excellent dinner! just good hot fresh hamburgers and fries. extra thick malt and shakes. all served with a smile- the staff was really working as a team. good job.“

“Linda was great. She was friendly and efficient.“

“Always a good time with good food!“

“Went to Culver's in Troy a week ago. Spent $40+ and drove back to Piqua before I realized that they forgot 2 burgers. Not cheap burgers either. Called them and instead of telling me to come pick them up, they said they would send me a coupon in the mail. So my daughter and I had sides for dinner(pretzels and fries). Today I take my coupon for the food I already paid for and the Manager Katrina said that the coupon only was for one sandwich and refused to give me all my food I had already paid for and waited a week to get reimbursed on. Katrina said that I should have kept my receipt. Even though they sent me a coupon. To make it worse 2 teenage looking girls stood behind the manager at the window laughing and talking about me trying to get my food. I asked Katrina their names to include in the complaint but she refused to give the names. I asked for the General Managers name and she said it was Cheryl, but she was not in today. Very frustrating. All I want is what I paid for. Not sure how to get it. Plan to call the GM, call corporate(closed until Monday), write reviews everywhere I can.“

“Had breakfast at the Brookville Grille today and it was sooo good!🥞✨First time trying the pancakes and they were melt-in-your-mouth divine! The three-meat omelette hit the spot 🍳🥓🍖, and local tip 👉 grab the grilled sourdough 🍞🔥—you won’t regret it! Definitely a Brookville favorite worth visiting 💯❤️ #brookvillegrille #localbusiness“

“The Clam Dip thank you Russ (chef) for resurrecting an old recipe from long ago. It, you are amazing! Thank you. Try this you won’t be disappointed!“

“Our company would like to say thank you. We had a wonderful Christmas party.“

“I've been there four times in 2 weeks first time no brisket second time no chicken second third time no pulled chicken for time no pulled chicken make some more damn food your food is outrageously good it's really hard to get it though“

“The food was absolutely amazing! The staff was very nice. We will definitely be back soon!“

“Little York Tavern & Pizza is hands down one of the absolute best hidden gems in the Dayton area for pizza! Their thin-crust pizza is legendary—perfectly crispy, loaded with high-quality toppings, and the sauce has the best flavor. We also ordered their wings, which were cooked to absolute perfection and tossed in a fantastic sauce. The menu has a great variety of classic tavern food, and everything comes out hot and fresh. It’s the kind of local spot that puts major pizza chains to shame. If you appreciate great pub food and an awesome pizza, this place is an absolute must-visit!“

“Visited Wednesday at noon. Food was wonderful, excellent service, friendly staff and owners. great atmosphere to sit and visit with friends. Very reasonable pricing. We will be returning!!!!“

“Took my family to Rob’s Restaurant in Brookville, Ohio, and unfortunately we were very disappointed. The chicken looked like it was days old and was also undercooked. The roast was cold. I understand that things happen, but the food quality really needs improvement. Please do better. Take pride in your restaurant.“

“Great food and environment.“

“It was good food, the same as I remember. I do hate they take your payment card and hold it until food is ready though. It should be charged right away at the car or brought right back, especially with all the fraud that happens anymore, but just my opinion.“

“Awesome food and amazing service“

“The sandwiches are fantastic!!! Employees are super friendly and the store is very clean. They even have a small dine-in seating area!“

“Love the 2 meals for $19.99“

“We had a 1.5 hour wait so we went to the bar and ate there. It was such a wonderful experience. The bar staff were amazing!! The food was wonderful. I got 1/2 rack of ribs. They were the best Ive ever had eating out.“

“Hinders has been a favorite place for many years! My late husband was their # 1 fan! Love the butt warmer wings. And also their Ruben sandwich. A very unique Sports Bar“

“Great atmosphere, tasty coffee and baked goods.“

“I rarely dine in at restaurants while I'm out driving because I prefer plastic everything if I dine in, so I just get my food to go. I went to Waffle House here in Vandalia, OH, and when I tell you, walking in, I was in shock. Even though the place was packed, I received a 'Hello, Good Morning' from almost every worker there. It made me feel so welcome in a predominantly Caucasian community. The waitress was attentive and assured me I was okay. The door was held open for me to enter and leave.  I left there with a sense of peace, progress, and pride... humanity is still present!“

“My boyfriend and I went to Brookville Waffle House this morning and had an amazing time. Barbara was our server she was very kind and on top of refilling drinks and taking empty dishes. She was very sweet! All of the cooks and staff were on top of it! They moved very quickly and added to the unique Waffle House aesthetic. Brookville Waffle House is BY FAR my favorite, I have always had good experiences there and I love how they have kept the vintage mood for all these years. Keep it up Brookville staff!“

“Enjoyed hanging with friends playing bingo and laughing. Wings were awesome“

“Very interesting place. The fire truck backdrop to the bar kinda sets the tone. Tables and seating are nicely laid out. Good menu... lots to choose from. Waitstaff very attentive. Meals were plentiful and tasty. All four folks in our group were quite pleased. The crowning touch was probably the infectious laughter coming from a lady 🤣 at a table on the other side of the room. Turns out she is the owner of the place, and well liked by all the waitstaff around us. Always a good sign to have a good time.“

“Nice layout, pretty wide open and well maintained. Greens are firm and roll super fast but true.“

“Good food. Super nice people efficient service.“

“great band first time to the bar. the bartenders were prompt and friendly“

“great place to be nice staff safe environment“

“Highly recommend! Great food and service!“

“AMAZING food, customer service & great atmosphere. Highly recommend.“

“One of my favorite spots for lunch. Always good, hot food and excellent service“

“Pecan waffles 🧇. and hashbrowns... tasty good food..“

“I felt the need to give a review when I don't normally do. Restaurant was HOT, HUMID and busy. Saw one waitress playing on her phone majority time we was there, hostess leaned on podium as if it was gonna be stolen the entire visit. Only one owaitress was actually running around and sweating that was our bartender server Dawn. Very friendly lady. Had a horrible couple beside screaming at her about the endless wings about the air conditioner then over a discounted coupon. My husband finally had enough and told her she didn't need the endless and smacking a table was a child like tantrum, the couple said nothing back but eventually left. To our server Dawn I'm sorry people are jerks. You were awesome“