37 Best Pizza Restaurants in Youngstown

“I was out dashing and stopped at this spot….the pizza smelled amazing. So my friend and I called them to ask if I could bring in some turkey pepperoni could he make us a pizza! He made the BEST pizza ever in under 10 minutes!!! It reminded us of the early 2000s Chuckie Cheese Pizza that I miss! Even brought it to our car along with some minute maid drinks! This is a hole in the wall spot! The dough is so light and fresh and each slice had its own pepperoni which I liked instead of it scattered across….the sauce was so fresh also! I’m already going back today!!!!!“

“Their pizza is spectacular… when judging Youngstown pizza you gotta put them up there with the other 2 spots .. Definitely a hidden gem and now my go to spot. 😋“

“Real deal. I searched far and wide for pizza made the way I like it. You gotta give this place a try, who knows maybe it will become your fav too. Love Liberty!“

“They squeezed us in super last minute and took great care of us! Appetizers and pizzas were great! Thanks guys!“

“first time going. little pricey, but hands down best pizza I've ever had. they should bring one back down to Niles for sure. I'll def be back“

“Oh so good. Thick style, a lil sweet sauce smothered in cheese. Spinning bowl salad to start n share bc so big, and some homemade nut kolachi to finish. Q rapid service, quite delightful when the owner came out w fried dough in sugar, complementary. ❤️🖤🤍 YSU.“

“Gene and his crew are the best. Everything is delicious 😋“

“Stopped i tonight for a friend’s Birthday party. We had the Chicago deep dish, Sicilian, Detroit,and New York style pizzas. They were all fantastic! I highly recommend you check them out.“

“Really tasty, yet super cheap pizza is available here!!!!!!! Its pretty dang good, and 5 bucks for this whole pizza is a deal you just can't beat. Its definitely not the highest quality pizza, but for 5 dollars you honestly cannot complain. The service was really quick and speedy, definitely a great pizza shop!!!!“

“Ordered for large party and all pizzas were delicious. Their crust is especially good ! Will be back!!!“

“I grew up in the 70’s and 80’s, and I have been searching for a pizza shop that tastes like the Ole Days. The ones who used to make their own pizza sauce, and the crust was so good, that it made you crave more. I was told about Westgate in Boardman, so I gave it a try today. From the time I walked in, to the time I left, the gals working were very friendly and polite, and was very helpful with suggestions of things I would like to try out. Everything on the menu looked amazing. I went with a pizza with pepperoni, and 6 BBQ wings. I suffered on the way home to Leetonia, windows mostly up due to a rainy day, so got plenty of the smells of the pizza and wings on the commute. Once home, I was finally able to dig into. Words can’t describe how good the food was. The pizza was delicious just like the Ole Days, from the crust to the topping of cheese and fresh pepperoni. The wings were just as delicious. The sauce of both were spot on. The cheese on the pizza wasn’t heavy nor light, a perfect balance between the crust and sauce. So if you’re looking for a great place for pizza, subs, and wings. I’ll say the hardest part about eating here is not taking a nap afterwards, small joke. Very filling and definitely worth the drive and price. Thank you for the great experience. My #1 go to pizza shop now.“

“Great family owned business and great pizza!!!“

“Love everything about this place, including the record store. Kudos!“

“Best pizza in all Ohio. The owner and his family there are very friendly.“

“Oh so good. Thick style, a lil sweet sauce smothered in cheese. Spinning bowl salad to start n share bc so big, and some homemade nut kolachi to finish. Q rapid service, quite delightful when the owner came out w fried dough in sugar, complementary. ❤️🖤🤍 YSU.“

“If you come to the Youngstown area, you must try this place out. I've gone to this place for many years, and the food here is outstanding! The pepperoni rolls are awesome, and the Friday fish fries are great. You will not be disappointed at this place.“

“Great pizza! Sauce was very good and the pizza baked perfectly. Only downfall was the size of the pies. We're a family of 4 (two which are teens) and we had just enough ordering 2 pies. My fault was not asking the size. Also note, to get in to the pizza pickup spot, go to the bar entrance, ring the bell and when the door opens, go into the kitchen located on the left just as you walk in.“

“always delicious consistency for years“

“We have family that lives in Youngstown. We always visit for Thanksgiving and Christmas. We order from Westgate each time we visit and it's always great! Sometimes, we're lucky and they have premade pepperoni rolls at the front counter. They're the best!“

“The food is delicious!. The establishment was clean and service was great! Their sauce is to die for:.Much better then some of your more expensive Restaurants. We will be back soon! P.S. You should advertise that your under new ownership!?“

“Great food and great service! Still the best veggie pizza in the area! Staff is courteous and food has never been better. 🙌🏼“

“We love Papa GeGe’s and the staff AND the food. The food is AMAZING. We love that it’s a BYOB. I think the veal Parmesan is the best I have ever had. I ordered it twice. The soup is amazing. We really enjoyed the cannoli. Beast Italian food around, hands down!!!“

“Thank you for hosting our wedding reception! The food was amazing! The space was lovely and your staff were pros! So accommodating, flexible and had great ideas! Thank you for helping to decorate, serve our guests and tear down! I highly recommend this restaurant and staff for your large party needs♥️“

“Fast delievery and friendly drivers“

“The food is usually really good but can sometimes be inconsistent. Sometimes the dough is fluffy, fresh and delicious..other times it is flat, chewy, and more dense.
Also, I ordered the exact same pizza on chow now a week apart and got two completely different pizzas, one white, and one with red sauce. They said I needed to specify that I wanted white sauce, which is fine. I’m not sure why I got a white pizza the first time without specifying. I believe that this is more of a communication problem between the app and the restaurant than any one persons fault. I hope you guys don’t take this to heart and more as constructive criticism, I’ll be a lifelong customer no matter what.“

“Had a decently large order set up for a party and the gentleman who was working was great. I stopped in about an hour to an hour and a half before ny scheduled pick up and asked if it was possible to get it earlier. No big deal if not, I was already in the area for something else. Within about 20ish minutes he was finishing up my order without having to impact any other order. Food quality was good, cooked exactly as ordered and friendly service.“

“Better ingredients better Pizza Papa John's hands down! If I could make a suggestion get yourself a sausage pepperoni and cheese pizza cut up the little pepper you always get and toss it all over your pizza try dipping it in some blue Ranch if blue Ranch isn't your thing then you got to go with the papa butter

Parking: Watch your doors LOL

Kid-friendliness: Can't exactly say that it is quote kid-friendly but Pizza is kid-friendly LOL“

“Error made with my order today at Marinos.. I ordered the Italian Delight and received the Tour of Italy.. when I told the waitress about the error she went to the chef, who refused to come out of the kitchen, and said I would have to pay for both meals if I insisted the error be corrected.. I angrily replied I would go hungry.. the chef came out of the kitchen, discussed the order, brought me the correct meal and only charged me for the meal I ordered.. Its a shame I had to get loud, make a small vocal scene, and be an embarrassment to friends to get the issue resolved.. Waitress was great, food was excellent, and a relaxing atmosphere overall.“

“The food was amazing along with the service, the wait time was very little and you had plenty to do as you waited. I would recommend the gyro with fries. Would go back. The price to food proportion was also amazing. I would come back for a filling good meal.“

“This is one of our favorite restaurants! My absolute favorite is their chicken marsala, but chicken and greens is a close second! And mozzarella marinara is my favorite appetizer. We also enjoy their whitefish nicollini, fish Frances and the filet. And their bread is so good too! Definitely worth a stop!“

“Its best to order it fresh if not it like chewing cardboard and old alright 😅? I know from experience it was that old but we still ate it for 6 bucks so get the extra tasty pepperoni ones for 1 buck more is definitely worth the price and fresh is best . Oh they don't pick up the phone to order n need a card to order online no cash on delivery sorry 😐“

“This place is great, highly recommend!!“

“just got my order and it's the only Pizza Hut in years that has made a pan pizza that wasn't greasy it was made and delivered in less than 30 minutes and was hot and delicious whenever made my pizza should be teaching all the other stores how to do excellent job thank you!“

“Great people and great service“

“I want to thank most of the staff at coca's pizza! We celebrated my autistic sons 8th birthday!
Upon coming in, I wasn't greeted and didn't feel welcomed at all. The manager which was a woman was extremely unpleasant.
Once we got to the back, I noticed that their AC was dripping and had buckets all over the floor in the party room. I was very upset but i didn't show it. Our lovely hosts, which was two very wonderful people apologized and try to make it work, but it was not their fault. It was the manager's fault for not making me aware of what the room would look like. The manager never once asked me, were we okay? or ever came to check on us? The male manger came over and checked on us, then proceeded to give us a discount for the inconvenience. Thank you so much to the whole cocas pizza staff besides the miserable female manager on duty june 28th .“

“This was our first time to this location. Michelle greeted us, set us up with drinks and menus while we waited. Service was awesome. Food was fantastic. (I ordered one of Michelle's spring specials. The whole place was beautiful and spotless. The other Bellarias should take a few lessons.“