17 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Hamburg

“We placed a large pick up order for a family gathering at the end of August 2025. The pizzas were done right, at the right time. The staff was friendly, and acknowledged the milestone birthday we were celebrating. Customer service A+, Food Quality A+, Value for Cost A+. We highly recommend their restaurant, and we will be back again! Thank you!“

“I will not be buying pizza anywhere else , best around . Cooked to perfection and the toppings were fresh and generously distributed. Amazing flavoured sauce . The crust was not greasy at all. Would recommend this place to any one that likes pizza.“

“Placed an order for pickup through the app for the triple treat box and it did not disappoint! The order was correct and ready upon the requested pickup time. 2 medium pizzas, chicken bites, bread sticks, a giant chippits cookie and two dipping sauces for less than $45.00? Send me!“

“Our favourite pizza place in town! We had always loved it, but stopped ordering from here a few years ago after a couple negative experiences. Started ordering from here again recently, and it is much improved. Tremendously friendly staff and excellent pizza.“

“I can’t say enough good things about Tito’s! I’ve been a regular for a while, and they never disappoint. Recently, there was a mix-up with my order—there was a miscommunication with the front of house and another customer accidentally took it home—but the owner (great guy) went above and beyond to make it right. Not only did they remake my entire order, but they also refunded me! Their customer service is absolutely top-notch, and the quality of the food is always amazing. This is why Tito’s remains my favourite pizza joint in New Hamburg!“

“Harv and his team make the most amazing pizza 🍕! Fast and friendly service always!! 5 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Excellent Pizza and friendly staff/“

“We were in town from Toronto to see shows and stopped in to get a pizza. It was excellent. The toppings were fresh, tasty, well distributed and there was lots of them. Glad we stopped!“

“The pizza was really good and the people were beyond friendly. Well worth the price.

Parking: Shared parking lot right next to shop. If you are mindful when parking you wont have an issue leaving.

Kid-friendliness: Some free candy I'm sure kids would love.

Wheelchair accessibility: Ground floor only no steps. Inside might be a bit tight.“

“Pizza Bella makes fantastic pizza !!! There large oven makes for a delicious crust. if you like wings... they have great wings and lots of hot sauces I recommend the crimson creepy & Chipotle Ghost !!! I Definitely advice anyone to try them out !!!“

“Really loved our pizzas tonight! Greek and a meat lovers, both were delicious thank you!“

“Best pizza for baden surroundings, I really enjoyed their pizza. Extremely delicious, best service and reasonable price!!! Highly recommend this place and wings are a must try! Thank you❤️“

“I ordered online a thin pepperoni pizza and i didn’t know that comes with oregano, my son can’t eat it with different flavours. I talked with them and they make a new one right away, even though it was a busy night and they had lots of orders to do . the stuff here it’s friendly and great. they didn’t want to charge me for the second one. We get our pizza from here all the time . Please make sure to leave a great tip for the hard working guys.“

“Amazing Pizza and Excellent Service at Tito’s Pizza!

Tito’s Pizza truly stands out. The moment you walk in, you can feel the quality. The pizza is outstanding — fresh dough, perfectly balanced crust, rich cheese, and generous, delicious toppings.

The staff are friendly, welcoming, and always make sure your order is done right. Even when it’s busy, they handle everything professionally. The store is spotless and has a warm, family-friendly atmosphere.

Orders are always accurate, hot, and ready quickly. For the quality and portion sizes, the prices are very fair.

Tito’s Pizza has become my go-to spot. Amazing food, great service, and excellent value. Highly recommended! 🍕🔥“

“I recently started to work in Tavistock and was looking for a good pizza place. I came across New Orleans pizza and it didn’t disappoint. I had the 2 slices with a pop, the price was great, the pizza was great, the employees are welcoming and nice.
The restaurant is clean.

Will definitely come again. 10/10 recommend.“

“There is a new owner. His name is Kumal. And he is wonderful. We had an error with a large order for a party and the front desk worker said we could have 50% off. I was happy with that, but the owner called US back to insist he make it right and refund us. While speaking with the owner weeks later he stated that they had purchased a new oven because he had a few other complaints as well. That is a HUGE investment to ensure customer satisfaction. We order there almost weekly and we have been repeatedly impressed with their customer service and quality. Check them out and give them a try! You won’t regret it!“

“Always good and fresh Good service“