7 Best Italian Restaurants in Orillia

Rustica Pizza Vino Italian • $$
132 Mississaga St E, Orillia

Customers` Favorites

Salted Caramel Warm Brownie Affogato
Woodfired Garlic Pizza Bread
Eggplant Parmesan Pasta
RPV Handcrafted Gnocchi
Sausage & Fennel Pizza
Sunshine City Pizza
Limoncello Tiramisu
Eggplant Parmigiana
Chicken Parmigiana
Rustica Meatballs

“5 STARS PLUS ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️+ The BEST dining out experience in a VERY LONG time !!! Our waiter Mike was incredible 🥰 The service and food was exceptional and before we left we made another reservation. My husband and I are Italian and the food has such deep flavour all made to perfection, everything from the start to the very end (appetizers to dessert) was the BEST ! We both left there so extremely satisfied… experience it yourself - you will NOT be disappointed. It’s our favourite restaurant now, hands down beats any other restaurant in Orillia. Worth every dollar spent there. Can’t wait to go there again ❤️“

4.8 Superb268 Reviews
Portage by the Lake Italian • $$
440 Couchiching Point Rd, Orillia

“This place truly is a hidden gem in Orillia. Food is carefully prepared with amazing creative presentation and flavours that are above and beyond expectations each time I try a new dish. This by far is my favourite spot to dine in Orillia after dinner you can take a lovely walk down to the lake to enjoy the sunset.“

4.8 Superb29 Reviews
East Side Mario's Italian • $$
315 Memorial Ave, Orillia

Customers` Favorites

Children's Bow Tie with Alfredo
Ceaser Salad with Cheese
Garden Salad with Meal
Spaghetti Meatballs
Cheese Cappelletti
Seafood Linguini
Chicken Parmasan
Veal Parmigiana
Hawaiian Pizza
Caesar Salad

“Went to East Sides in Orillia last night and was served by Robbylee. She was incredibly bubbly anns outgoing and she was great with my children. She said she was newer but you wouldn't have been able to tell with the speed and quality of her service.
A nice girl and we hope to see her again next time.
A.R.“

4.3 Superb344 Reviews
Bedrock Cafe Pizza • $
9393 ON-11, Orillia

Customers` Favorites

Hawaiian Pizza
Garlic Bread
Garden Salad
Party Pizza
Panzerotti
Pizzas
Sauce

“Bedrock cafe is owned by a wonderful family and they have BY FAR the best pizza around. I’ve been getting pizza here since I was a child and it’s still my favourite. If you’re in or around the area make sure you stop at bedrock for some pizza and meet the wonderful staff! 🍕“

4.7 Superb116 Reviews
Boston Pizza Pizza • $$
3300 Monarch Dr, Orillia

Customers` Favorites

Crispy Chicken Wrap w Sweet Potato Fries
8 Inch Pizza with Pepperoni and Olives
Macaroni and Cheese and Garlic Toast
Peach Cobbler with Vanilla Ice Cream
Pineapple Beets Goat Cheese Salad
Chicken Club Sandwich with Fries
Chicken Fingers with Fries
Chicken Caesar Salad
Chicken Ceasar Salad
Royal Hawaiian Pizza

“The location is easy to get to from town
The atmosphere is a nice family restaurant on one side, bar on the other with the option of a patio
The food was great, the menu had good options.
You can come with groups here as they have the setting for that also“

3.8 Good206 Reviews
Pizza Hut Pizza • $$
685 University Ave Unit 3, Orillia

Customers` Favorites

2 Medium Pizzas for 27 99
10 99 Pizza of the Day
Large Favourites Deal
Creamy Butter Chicken
Smokey Maple Bacon
Traditional Wings
Pepperoni Lover's
Chicken Lover's
Boneless Bites
Meat Lover's

“Spent $25.00 for a medium pizza when I went to pick it up, I didn’t take my debit card with me and ask for a ranch dipping sauce and they were gonna charge me for it a dollar think this is very bad that you can’t give a customer a ranch sauce when they spend $25 on a pizza It’s only $25 but I won’t be back and I’ll be telling him a few people“

3.4 Good88 Reviews
Pizza Pizza Pizza • $
82 Mississaga St E, Orillia

Customers` Favorites

Plant-Based Pepperoni Pizza
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Tropical Hawaiian Pizza
Veggie Pepperoni Pizza
Butter Chicken Pizza
Four Meat Stromboli
Jalapeno Poppers
Garlic Bread
Onion Rings
Fries

“To whomever was making pizzas on Nov 28th 2025 around 5pm, you did a fantastic job. There was a good helping of toppings making the pizza stand out! Others working should learn from you on how to prepare and make a pizza! This is by far the best order we have had in my 10 years of ordering from you. Pizzas were awesome and there was no absence of toppings! Good job! I am so impressed. The delivery gentleman was amazing too! He is so kind and wonderful. Can't say enough tonight as you all hit the mark! Thank you from my family and kids.“

3.5 Good172 Reviews

You May Also Like