19 Best Pizza Restaurants in Pickering

“Tried this place last night and was pleasantly surprised. probably the best pizza in Durham.“

“My extravaganza was too DELISH and had to be devoured the minute it got to the door. Was too busy enjoying and didn't get enough time to take a pic but I did have enough time to enjoy the delish cinnabites!!!!
When there's no left overs you KNOW it was AMAZING!“

“Always fast and consistent. Better prices than most competitors. The app has great incentives, I've received many free pizzas from all the give-aways and points collected.

Parking: Location is connected with a condo complex and is situated inside the complex with other business and condo entrance. Plenty of customer parking separate from the condominium.“

“Best spot to get pizza! Always fresh and delicious 🍕🍕“

“Best pizza with good quality. Must try there authentic chicken club pizza❤️“

“I honestly don't know why people are giving very bad review on their pizzas and food. I have been a customer for almost 3 years and each and everytime I received excellent customer service, delicious and quality food.
I think some people just trying to spoil the reputation of this place! Whoever is doing this,I am pretty sure they have not even tried a single piece of slice from this place. So please do not put fake feed back and review!!! You may have to face legal consequences if you keep doing this!!!

Once again, Grandpa's Pizzeria is one of the best pizza places that you should try!“

“Amazing delicious pizza and staff is so friendly and welcoming . It’s made perfect with all the toppings. Thanks to make it perfect every time. Reason for me to go from Markham to Pickering for yummy pizza .“

“Coming in for a big birthday order Mehboob helped us out and got our order ready hot and fresh in am amazing time. He greeted us with a friendly smile and a clean store. I highly recommend this location to get your pizza hot, fresh and ready!! Thank you Mehboob for making our busy life a whole lot easier today! ❤️ ?

Parking: Lots of room for big vehicles“

“After always driving by this place with my wife I finally decided to give it a try. I haven't had better tasting pizza since! The staff was friendly and place was really clean!“

“Their pizza is always good easily the best in Pickering. I had a misunderstanding with my order and the Owner called me to fix and deliver the order to my house himself. Customer service doesn't get any better than that at all. Definitely gonna continue ordering and supporting them. Pizza is always ? when I order from here.“

“"Hello! I wanted to express my sincere appreciation for the amazing experience I had at Pizza Pizza restaurant. The food was delicious, the service was excellent, and the atmosphere was just perfect. Keep up the fantastic work! ??"“

“5 star They have affordable pizza with great taste. Highly recommended. cheap option is medium pepperoni pizza for $5 only. (All halal.)“

“Even though this location is out of my way (there is a closer location near me), I still chose to get my pizza here because they don't skimp on the ingredients like the one at 1360 Kingston Rd.
This location also doesn't burn the crust (unless you ask for it that way).“

“The tandoori desi style pizza was so unbelievably good! While other pizza spots cheap out on their toppings, this City South makes sure your pizza is loaded with toppings and it tastes amazing! We order our pizza from here every time now! Thanks!“

“My first impression was excellent service by the young lady in the store, who took my order and made relevant suggestions to me. I'm happy I took her suggestions and I enjoyed the pizza and wings combo. She has a lovely personality and made me feel very welcome, and upon leaving the store, I got a "Have a great day" again from her and another young man. Both gave excellent service. I would highly recommend them both as employees and it made me enjoy the food even more, because it was a feel-good experience.“

“Got the cinna bites and some were "overdone" , some where near black in some areas and also, not enough cinnamon sugar , almost non-existent. I almost thought, I didnt order bread bites. I didn't take a picture because I didn't know I was going to get a survey and they were still edible. Because hey.. a snack is a snack.“

“East Side Mario’s feels like a warm hug for anyone who loves classic Italian-American comfort food. The meal starts on a high note with their garlic home loaf—soft, buttery, and wonderfully aromatic. It’s simple but oh-so-satisfying, especially paired with a generous dollop of creamy butter.

The tomato soup was rich, hearty, and just the right level of tangy, a cozy start before diving into the mains. The linguine seafood diavolo was packed with shrimp and mussels in a flavorful tomato sauce, with a mild kick that didn’t overwhelm. The spaghetti and meatballs were comforting and familiar, topped with a snowfall of grated cheese that added just the right touch. The chicken parmigiana, served alongside creamy fettuccine alfredo, was hearty and satisfying—a dish that feels like it’s made to share with family.

And then came the tiramisu, the sweet finale. Light, creamy, and perfectly balanced with just a hint of coffee, it felt like the dessert equivalent of a warm smile.

If you’re looking for a place that serves generous portions, friendly vibes, and flavors that feel like home, East Side Mario’s is a delightful choice. It’s not just a meal—it’s a happy, comforting experience.“

“Great location! Always will come back“

“Got stuck on the 401 and was over an hour late to pick up the pizza. The employee through the pizza out and had a fresh one waiting for me. I was expecting a cold pizza as it was my own fault why I was late. Instead they went above and beyond to make me a fresh pizza. I wish I got the employee name as he deserves a pat on the back for his customer service. I order from here often and the great customer service always keep me coming back. Great job by all the team at this Pickering location and I will see ya for my next pizza ?“