12 Best Italian Restaurants near Brodheadsville

1 Mike's Pizzeria Italian Restaurant / Brodheadsville

4.0 Good 213 Reviews

1421 US-209, Brodheadsville

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Not as good as it used to be. Food is decent, service has been horrible recently. Servers in the bathroom on their phones instead of working. Wings were dry and over cooked..... and we aren't talking a busy night. It was a Monday afternoon, with 2 other tables. Everything should have been perfect.”

2 Spinelli's Brick Oven Pizzeria

3.9 Good 284 Reviews

107 Kinsley Drive Suite 106, Brodheadsville

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“My dad and I stopped in there last year while visiting Gilbert for the RedBall military equipment show. He got wings and I got the five alarm burger both were excellent but what really was over. The top was the homemade blue cheese dressing that we got with our items. This was homemade old-school blue cheese and not that bottled garbage they selling grocery stores. You know the advertisement that they used to sell Dairy Queen blizzards where they turn the blizzard upside down to show how thick it is? That’s how this dressing was my dad stuck a drumstick in the dressing and then turned the bowl of dressing upside down at our table and the dressing in the drumstick, just hung there in the bowl! Lol… Will be back there again for dinner one night in a couple of weeks and I’m gonna see if they will actually make up and sell me some jars of that dressing to take home with us… I have not had a blue cheese dressing that good before or since!”

3 Amici Pizza & Pasta Family Restaurant

4.6 Superb 613 Reviews

2838 PA-611 Suite 204, Tannersville · 9.13 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I haven’t been there yet, but after hearing this lovely story of how wonderfully honest and kind the owners are and hearing so many stories of how delicious the food is I will definitely be stopping by!!!”

4 Prime Pizzeria & Restaurant

4.8 Superb 135 Reviews

6221 Sullivan Trail, Nazareth · 10.1 miles

“Our “NOT BACK to SCHOOL LUNCH BUNCH 2026” enjoyed a variety of great lunches, and great service at Prime Pizzeria today. 20 attended this year and all were pleased with food choices, and our friendly , courteous, great server Sherry. Looking forward to our next event!”

5 New York Pizza & Family Restaurant

4.7 Superb 621 Reviews

2912 PA-611, Tannersville · 9.01 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Every time we come to the area, we have to stop to enjoy the delicious food. New York Pizza encapsulates the true New York flavor of pizza. Any pie that you order is absolutely delicious. Our family favorite is the cheesesteak pizza and the grandmas pizza is by far the best around. Garlic knots are a must! They are huge and delicious. Friendly service by all and a great atmosphere.”

6 Sal's Pizza

4.6 Superb 345 Reviews

487 East Moorestown Road Suite 1, Wind Gap · 7.88 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The best gluten free pizza I've ever had!! 👍🍕❤ Omg! SO SO good!!”

7 Volare Ristorante

4.2 Good 198 Reviews

2756 PA-611, Tannersville · 9.39 miles

“My family and I ate at Volare we had a great experience the food was delicious i grew up italian my parents are phenomenal cook so when it comes to going out to dinner, I usually don't like to pick Italian restaurants, but I'm so glad that we went here. The food was delicious and fresh, including the dessert. I was hoping to post pictures to this review that I took, but unfortunately they're not loading. Highly recommend this restaurant. We had chicken Parmesan, which my son had and he loved I had pasta and clams and again it was fresh and delicious for appetizers. We had octopus, which was fresh. The baked clams were delicious Looking forward to going back”

8 512Restaurant

4.1 Good 74 Reviews

2 East Pennsylvania Avenue, Pen Argyl · 8.22 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We placed a large catering order. Everything was perfect and delicious!”

9 Anthony's Pizzeria

4.5 Superb 180 Reviews

829 Male Road, Wind Gap · 7.66 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Lord, have mercy, we think ya'll have the BEST sausage and green pepper pizza 🍕”

10 PrimoHoagies

4.1 Good 129 Reviews

2836 PA-611, Tannersville · 9.17 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“First time visiting this shop! Absolutely delicious, best bread in the area for sure 💜 bada -bing sandwich is sooooo good ! Will be back for sure :)”

11 Frank's Pizza of Bartonsville

4.0 Good 149 Reviews

3578 PA-611 Ste 240, Bartonsville · 8.25 miles

• Take-Out

“By far the best pizza in the area! Always hot and fresh! just wish the other pleasant server was there!”

12 Tony's Restaurant & Pizzeria

3.9 Good 102 Reviews

290 Frantz Road, Stroudsburg · 8.57 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The best. I moved down to Easton and just haven’t been able to find anything that compares.”