35 Best Ice Cream Shops near Dallastown

“sweet tooth will be missed by my whole picky family and I am picky when it comes to sweets......they are the best waffle place and sweets that I ever been to let alone her in Pa no one compares to them I'm my opinion. My husband can vouch for me when I say I'm not a sweets fan but after they opened I was glued to that place. I cant wait to go to the DMV when they open (and it will be just for them🤣)“

“Waitress Tiffany was very nice along with the cook! Cute place to grab a bit to eat❤️ Keep up the good work!“

“perfect everything was amazing and I'd go here again would recommend to anyone“

“best milk around and bonus to have baby cows to pet“

“Great people, great flavors.“

“I came in for my first time for a little girls date Monday morning. The atmosphere is so cute and cozy. Love the fireplace! My cookie butter hot chocolate was delicious and so were the pastries. My only suggestion would be to get a few high chairs so I can bring my wild 2 year old again. She loved running around but Momma needed a break afterwards 😂 Looking forward to coming back!“

“The best snowballs around“

“Everyone on their staff serves with smiles! 😃 Their fun social media keeps the public informed of yummy new things to try. 🍓 With Italian ice made fresh daily, and options for individuals to large events, this spot is great for all occasions! 🍦“

“it's awesome they should make a store all year. we go to east York and loucks everybody is so awesome. the lady in east York let's us try the ice in case we don't like it she goes above and beyond. They should make Christmas kinds also. see you all next year thank you Rita's my daughter loves this place“

“Great Ice Cream, hand made on a farm!“

“Awesome place to stop in for ice cream! Scoops were enormous and delicious! Tons of flavors. My buddy got a milk shake (which apparently they're known for) and said it was delicious.Lots of picnic tables to sit at outside as well as activities like arcade and nice looking mini-golf course. Highly recommend and definitely looking forward to returning for more of their ice cream! 2 scoops is plenty!! (though I got three :)“

“LOVE Aloha Snow!! Just wish better consistency with flavors. I frequent weekly and sometimes flavors are "just right" and other times taste and appear to be watered down (Cherry watered down to taste and appears pink in color instead of deep red this week). Anyway...will continue to support this business, most of the very young staff is pleasant and efficient just need consistency for a 5/5.“

“We come all the way from Massachusetts and always stop for ice cream and breakfast! The food is always so delicious and of course the ice cream! The staff is so nice and we love seeing them every year! We even get the best souvenirs to bring home! Johnny is hilarious and always so fun to have as our waiter! And you can't forget about Laura one of the most kind,caring person❤️! Be sure to check out the wall of pictures we are on there!! Till next year❤️“

“I’m not sure who loves Bonkey’s more…. Me or my dog 😂 Stopped in to the Red Lion location tonight and she devoured her pup cup…. Check out the comments for the pictures 😂“

“I stop by to thank Zoe for preparing my Blizzard just the way I like it! I only have one recommendation and it is for the store, I think they should update their system to be able to place the order through the app. I really don't come here because I don't accumulate points and I always have to order here. Much success and blessings!“

“Their ice cream is so delicious! They have limited indoor seating, but there are plenty of picnic tables outdoors. There are so many activities for kids to enjoy. The last time we were there we witnessed a hot air balloon being filled and taking off. (As a side note: Bring cash, or be prepared to use the ATM.)“

“4 out of 5 only because one of their freezers was out of service so flavors were limited. But I tried a sample of "Baseball Nut" and that turned into a double scoop on a cone! Delicious so 5 out of 5 for the flavor and the treat! Thanks BR!“

“I love Rita's! My favorite thing to get are mistos. I refuse to call them by their new name.😤 I also think they need to be researched. How is it possible that when I drink them, they make me stop sweating?!🤯 It's a pleasant anomaly. If only they could do something about my brain freezes...“

“I had a great experience at this Dunkin' Donuts! Gabby, who waited on us, was incredibly sweet and kind — she really made our visit extra special. The facility was spotless, and I was especially impressed by how accessible it was. My friend is handicapped, and the ramp was conveniently located right next to the parking area, which made everything so easy for us. It was such a pleasant visit, and I’ll definitely be coming back again. Thank you, Gabby and the team! The one on Queen Street in Dallastown!“

“Best roll ice cream and lots of drink options.“

“Love the ice cream but recently it seems they have changed their chocolate peanut butter brownie. I have had a few pints over the last month or two and it’s like tar! It has changed 😩 and seems like they out way to much chocolate and now you can’t even taste the brownie or peanut butter.“

“We had a great time there. I do think supervision needs to be a priority. The screaming & running around of kids is dangerous. Someone is going to get hurt & it was very annoying to be in the tea room listening to it.“

“It's been a good while, and I miss Rita's !! Swedish Fish Galeto with Vanilla Custard and Sprinkles, is my ultimate Fave ..yummyThe strawberry cheesecake concrete is delish too ! Go give them a try before their closed for the season.“

“I usually prefer to go to the E Market St location, even though this one is closer to my home. This location seems to have fewer flavors I like and the E Market St team is more capable. Still, if I'm in the area, it's still worth a stop.“

“Upon visiting Pennsylvania, I always make it a point to stop by Taylor Chip; I was pleased to find a location in York and acquired a 6 pack of their tasty cookies. The lone guy working the store on January 14th was very helpful and friendly!“

“The service depends on employees and how far you are sitted from bar. Locals get all the speedy service and conversation which makes waiting on our meals more irritating.“

“Great food/ice cream Great service & overall a wonderful place !!!!“

“The worker “Aiva” was exuberant, and immediately brightened my day. I understand tips are not a large part of their salary, since it isn’t a serving job, so I could tell Aiva was only this positive out of the kindness of her own heart, and very attributable to her character. I have just suffered a loss, and have not been able to pull myself out of bed. I went into SWEET FROG for ice cream to try to cheer myself up. Well, I’m happy now, but I’m not sure if it was the ice cream (😋) or “Aiva”. Just wanted to say the working staff here run a well oiled machine and they all attract customers. York SWEET FROG is booming. I told my extended family to all come in some time this week. I hope “Aiva” is working.“

“I love this crumbl so much and good service everything was good

Parking: It was kind of full when i went to go buy cookies but it was worth the drive

Kid-friendliness: I love this crumbl cookie they were so nice and helpful and i just love it“

“It’s been a while since we last ordered a cake from Dairy Queen, but today we picked up an ice cream cake for my daughter, and it was absolutely phenomenal! If you’re getting one from the Queen Street location, be sure to ask for Allie—she did an amazing job, and you won’t regret it. Thank you, Allie!“

“Just had a cheeseburger sib and peanut butter brain freezer omg hit the spot fresh vegetables including the pickles i highly recommend“

“Great customer service, amazing food that is flavorful. I got the C&C breakfast bowl (Love it) They also provide coloring books and crayons for children. I will be a returning customer (God Willing).“

“We stayed this past Summer in July and we loved everything about it!!!! The Shoe is so neat and unique on the outside as well as the inside!!! Inside was like a museum to us! We loved looking at all of the memorabilia throughout the house!! So glad we got to enjoy the shoe! So many memories and an unforgettable experience!!“

“Wonderful spot to refresh your senses, the staff always exudes great energy! 🍧❄️“

“The place is nice and cheerful. There is nice music and a great atmosphere. The area which it is located at seems great and it was interesting to see a Blizzard Run 5k sign. I never knew that existed and it seemed interesting to me. It was also interesting to see one of those little libraries right next to the restaurant. Even though I arrived during their opening time, it took a bit for them to actually open their doors.

Kid-friendliness: The place is nice and cheerful. There is nice music and a great atmosphere. The area which it is located at seems great and it was interesting to see a Blizzard Run 5k sign. I never knew that existed and it seemed interesting to me. It was also interesting to see one of those little libraries right next to the restaurant.“