20 Best American Restaurants near Eldred

“Best pizza around! Highly recommend.“

“Went to Sprague Maple Farms for a birthday lunch with my family this past weekend. The food was fantastic, as is the overall experience. I wanted to mention the staff going above and beyond for me. I left my birthday cards with check in them at the table on accident. Got home and realized I didn’t have them. Called down, not only did they save them. They promptly mailed them too me saving a 3 hour drive from Buffalo!“

“Veggie wontons were light and super crispy with just the right amount of sweet and spice with the dipping sauce. The fish tacos and the pork tacos were perfect, and we especially liked the tang of that pickled cabbage with the fish. The staff was attentive and the atmosphere was really nice! We will be back.“

“Beautiful oak woodwork and decor make for a warm, inviting setting to have a great meal. The French onion soup was wonderful! The beef on weck was a different style than expected but might appeal more to some diners. Instead of thinly sliced beef in au jus on the kimmelweck (salt) roll, here they served a mountain of sliced beef on the weck roll but without the extra juice, making for a hearty but a bit dry meal.“

“Drove almost 2 hr to get here because they closed all these amazing restaurants in our area. Brought my son for his 24th birthday meal. He felt like a kid all over again. Had a blast. The food was amazing and the service was awesome. Wish we could get one closer to home but it was sooo worth the drive!!“

“Love this place!!!! Food is great and the portions are just right. We have been here many times and usually we have the owner that waited on us and he is excellent at interacting with the customer. Today on the other hand it wasn't a good experience. This was not the owner that waited on us. The guy would rather mess around on his phone than take care of the customer. He messed around on his phone with his gloves on and went directly back to making the food. Yuck! Also just a word of advice if you are working with shrimp and then working on another person's order you may want to change gloves. That customer may have a food allergy. If I would have had ordered for my wife yor daughter I would have had to say I can't take that food since they are allergic to that sort of stuff. Other than that it's worth our drive of over an hour just to have something we can't get in our area.“

“Tonight, we decided to try Eddie's on Main for the first time. This establishment gets 5 stars across the board! The atmosphere was lovely, the music was nice, the dining areas were clean, our waitress was so sweet and attentive, the food presentation was perfect, and everything tasted delectable (compliments to the chef)! We ordered 3 appetizers, 3 meals, and 2 ice-creams for dessert. There was not one complaint from our party of 3. This place is a diamond in the rough and my new favorite place to eat in northern Pennsylvania. They obviously have an educated chef on site and not just a short-order cook. Bravo, Eddie's on Main! We will be back for an encore!P.S. Tonight's seafood specials were amazing!“

“One of the best kept secrets in the area! Beautiful venue. Amazing team to work with. Awesome food! Such a great time!! We love it here!“

“Had supper for the first time here tonight. My husband and I both ordered the Cottage Beef.. absolutely delicious! I also had the creme brulee.. also absolutely delicious! We will be back!“

“Depends on my mood for the fish or meatloaf but both are delicious. They have the best French onion soup in the area! Can't go wrong eating here..oh wait ..forgot to mention how delicious their wings are too!!“

“Great place friendly workers“

“I do a multi day bike ride in that area every October and I look forward to the Sunday morning Breakfast stop. The old school look and “If it works don’t fix it” vibe is perfect, as is the food.“

“As usual the service was amazing Chris was our server and continued to check in on us almost every time he walked by. The food was delicious and we were taken care of in a timely fashion unlike the one in Blasdell. Can't wait to go back.

Service was great did not wait long for drinks or food. Server was polite and checked on us just the right amount of times not to often but we didnt have to try and get his attention.
10/19/2024
Again a great experience after we got seated someone that was 3rd in line tried to go before the other 2 groups but then we all got seated as we showed up our server was very pleasant and checked on us often she did a really good job“

“Been coming here my whole life. My grandma use to work here. Lol.“

“Great atmosphere, friendly staff, and always excellent food! The Manhattan clam chowder was crazy good.“

“best steaks in the area, and the fact that they have Jameson black barrel is a plus!!“

“Rosie... 😁 best waitress.“

“The food was absolutely amazing! Bourbon wings, Ruben with Cajun fries and the fried pickles are the best! The spicy ranch dressing puts the pickles over the edge! We will be back!“

“Great food! Stopped there on a whim and what a pleasant surprise. Staff was fun, food was great (try the chocolate cake) and atmosphere was cool! I can always tell when a restaurant has a real chef, and the quality of food and presentation said it all. Go there, you'll love it!“

“I've been to Green Acres Cafe on several occasions. Never had a bad experiences. My most recent dining experience was with my step mom. She had the homemade Belgium waffle. I had the Blueberry pancakes. You could tell the blueberry pancakes were homemade. They were filled with fresh blueberries. Our food arrived promptly. I remarked. I don't know how he (Paul) manages to do all of the orders so quickly and efficiently. The food is hot and fresh.
The waitress was attentive to our needs. We will definitely return to Green Acres.“