50 Best American Restaurants near Elizabethtown

“Delicious food and great service! We have been coming to Country Meadows for many years! Love everything about this restaurant!“

“Excellent service. Our server was Billy. Great food.“

“This place is so underrated. I don't get it, the parking lot is practically empty all the time but this place is legit the best restaurant in the area. The food is always unique, the draft beer selection is second to none in this town (have to go to Lancaster city or Harrisburg to compete with this). Music selection is good, servers are chill... I don't get why this place isn't packed. If u pass thru Etown u need to go to the Black Gryphon.“

“I and a group of friends ate lunch on 1/3. The food was great and our server Kelly was very attentive and personable.“

“Love the menu,and the food is delicious.“

“I used to go to Lucky Duck a lot and then stopped when they took salmon off their menu a few years ago. HOWEVER, my group decided they wanted to go to Lucky Duck and I agreed ... Very happy to discover that salmon is back ... and may have been for a while now ... I was happy to be seated in my formerly regular table ... service was great and the food was delicious!!!“

“I stop here at least once a week. Their beverages are wonderful...sandwiches aren't bad either. Their soups on the other hand leave a lot to be desired. I had the veggie last week...it was so peppery that I couldn't eat it...I had the Italian Wedding soup this week...that was just a downright disgrace! The broth was so salty and I have never had or made Italian wedding soup with sausage meatballs...there wasn't any chicken to be found and carrots, spinach and orzo were nonexistent. The broth was so dark at first I thought they made a mistake. Lesson learned...next time I want Italian Wedding soup I will make my own.“

“we dropping in and tried 2 dinner entrees, chicken parm and meat lasagna. They each came with nice salads - not just lots of lettuce, and garlic bread. Portions were big - spaghetti amount was excessive - enough for 2-3 people. Chicken parm was cutlet, not chicken finger like some restaurants. We were very pleased with our meals. Normally, we got pizzas.“

“Waitress Tiffany was very nice along with the cook! Cute place to grab a bit to eat❤️ Keep up the good work!“

“It’s been a long time since I can give a raving review on a local restaurant. The Mill did not disappoint. It was clean the drinks were strong and the food was delicious. Highly recommend to anybody looking for a great dining experience!“

“Stopped in yesterday for dinner prior to Starship and Heart concert at Giant Arena! Great menu selection. Margherita Shrimp Flat bread, Mexican Street corn dip appetizer and Amish Chicken for entree. And a Makers Mark bourbon and ginger ale over ice. And visit to the table by the owner David. Worthy of a trip to Hummelstown. A few miles away from Hershey Park!“

“our order came out fast. food Is delicious. alot of food for your money. The staff was really nice. Bathrooms were very clean.“

“When friends come to town we go to Bully’s. It is the place to go for casual upscale dining in Columbia. I have been taking guests there since Dave and Sherry opened 25 years ago and have always had a great experience. There are always great choices on the menu and the atmosphere is fun and historic. The unique wedge shaped site at the intersection of Lancaster Avenue and Union Street features plenty of parking and an onsite bakery. The owners are great supporters of the community and have been hands-on in all aspects of the operation. Well appointed guest rooms are available above the restaurant. If you want a great meal, a wide selection of beverages and an enjoyable experience visit Bully’s soon.“

“The drinks are amazing this was the second time me and my friends came there our food was cold they took it back and heated it up for us we didn’t complain because it was a great vibe what sucks was the manager coming over to us rudely rushing us to leave we were only there for 45 mins you can scare off good customers with that attitude our waiter Brayden was great sucks because we will not be returning this happened today 1/9/2026 at 9:30 am“

“The hotel manager at Hampton Inn recommended "What IF" for dinner. He was spot on. Excellent service and our table just off the end of the bar provided a quiet place to enjoy an excellent meal.“

“Our son's wedding reception was held here, and it was our first time visiting. I was being a bit nosy about the basement when a gentleman who worked there noticed and kindly asked if we’d like to take a peek. Thank you again — that small gesture showed how much you care about your visitors’ experience. During the reception, a family with three young kids started to get a little bored. That same gentleman came out with a basket of brand-new Matchbox cars and gave each child one. Wow! What a thoughtful and above-and-beyond thing to do. You truly helped make their day — and ours — even brighter. Thank you for your kindness and hospitality!“

“I’ve been a HUGE fan of I&E for a while (their soups are INCREDIBLE) but now I have to eat Gluten Free. Today was my first time having their GF Grilled Cheese and it was AMAZING!!! I’m so excited to still be able to eat at my favorite lunch spot!“

“Stopped in yesterday for dinner prior to Starship and Heart concert at Giant Arena! Great menu selection. Margherita Shrimp Flat bread, Mexican Street corn dip appetizer and Amish Chicken for entree. And a Makers Mark bourbon and ginger ale over ice. And visit to the table by the owner David. Worthy of a trip to Hummelstown. A few miles away from Hershey Park!“

“Thank you for the warm hospitality for getting pumpkin beer for me. It was well worth the drvie to come check out Patti and Dan's favorite place. Thanks I hope to be back again soon!“

“About a year ago, I went to John Wright Restaurant for Sunday brunch with a group of friends. I didn’t know what to expect, but the moment I arrived, I was struck by the beautiful waterfront scenery and the stunning, rustic building. Inside, that old-world charm blends perfectly with an upscale dining vibe, giving the place a truly special and unique energy. The brunch was absolutely delicious—so many options, including my personal favorite, eggs Benedict. Fast forward to last night: I stopped in for happy hour with a friend, and we grabbed seats at the bar. It was surprisingly comfortable and not overcrowded at all. The two bartenders were fantastic—warm, funny, and attentive. And the cocktails… OH MY GOSH. Just try them. You’ll thank me later! We ordered the calamari and crab risotto small plates, and they were so good that we immediately ordered a second round of the exact same thing. From a relaxed Sunday brunch, to after-work apps and cocktails, to a special dinner out—John Wright Restaurant gets a solid 10/10 from me. 🍽️“

“When they remodeled I was hoping the food got better also. It did not. Been going here for 20 years of my life, and started taking my kids there. Mediocre food at best.“

“Be careful if going here. It looks like they are having real issues with trouble makers, which can happen with any tavern along the river. About 10 days ago they confronted a person outside who refused to pay. That guy pulled a gun on the employee and threatened to shoot them in the head. Look online, you'll see the news story. We went there with another couple anyway for supper aware of the situation that possibly the management wasn't able to keep the trouble out of the place. Within minutes Courtney had our drinks at the table and placed our food orders ... and then some white trash at the bar left out a super loud screech or whistle looking for attention. It was bad. Then he did it again a few minutes later and left. One more time and I'd have gotten involved. The owner needs to hire some beefy enforcement right now to keep a handle on this or the place is going to get a reputation like the Bainbridge Inn as a good place to raise hell and start a fight. NOT date night atmosphere.“

“Top of the line, and I’m a bbq snob!“

“We go a few times a month. Always good food. Always good service. Will be back. Thank you!“

“Stopped in because Tröegs was way too crowded. Food was great, beer was even better and I can’t say enough about the service. The bartender was incredibly knowledgeable and super friendly. I have never had better service! Crowd at the bar was great too. Highly recommend!“

“The goat cheese & artichoke poppers were the first truly unique taste I have experienced in years. Our waitress Wendy was very thoughtful and proactive in helping my wife navigate the menu with her food allergies. The burger meat is a combination of brisket, chuck, and sirloin. I am a very picky burger eater and even grow my own grass fed grass finished meat so when I say their burger is amazing, their burger is AMAZING. 11/10, cannot recommend enough. We will be back!!“

“Valentines Dinner was great, peaceful atmosphere with friendly people.“

“Burgers were top notch. Chicken tortellini soup was way too salty last week.“

“Ate in the catacombs last night. I am a huge foodie and was looking forward to the atmosphere of the restaurant. It did not disappoint. Jack, our server was great, the food and drinks were amazing. Overall an excellent experience, we will return!“

“I love the crab fries they are the best ever if a little spicy for some of the kids. I really wish they would bring back the bacon and blue burger that they used to have because I would get that all the time. I like the fact that there is a refill station nearby so I can have one person get a drink while I'm waiting in line.“

“Paige our waitress did a super job. Brought my wife a second iced tea without even asking. Just a great job all around. Seth the General Manager came to our table and greeted us and asked about service and food.“

“went there for dinner and it was a good choice. Great service and the food was really good .It was like eating a home cooked meal instead of dining out. I had the fried chicken and mashed potatoes with gravy and was very good. my fiance had the chopped steak and she wasn't disappointed. one grandaughter had the chicken tenders and fries and the other the Philly cheese steak. next time we are in hershey for vacation we will be coming back for sure .thank you for the great food and great service“

“Nice atmosphere . Good food .“

“The staff was beyond nice and helpful. I checked in late and it was no issue at all to them. It seemed like a nice family hotel. Super clean which is something I need in order to stay at a hotel. Not far from great restaurants and of course, Hershey park!“

“my waitress was outstanding! she was so pleasant. I will definitely be looking for her the next time. The food was delicious. it was my grandsons 16th birthday and everything was perfect.“

“4 of us got the brisket. All 4 were like old leather. Very dry.... Food was ok at best. Atmosphere was interesting. Almost a fight at the bar. Then a girl could barley walk getting up from the bar to leave. Just not the same.“

“daughter loves the fish platter and burgers cooked to order. fries and hot cheddar sauce great“

“We always enjoy our food here. I tried the Moroccan spice cod today and it was delicious! Service was great. We will definitely be back. I’m excited for the new restaurant in Camp Hill to open!“

“Best chicken croquettes I have had in a long time. Good service too.“

“When we go we always sit at the bar. The staff are a riot and make you feel at home. Hanging with the regulars is very entertaining and enjoyable! Everything we’ve ordered has been delicious!“

“I own Yokl, a trolley food tour company in Hershey, PA. We love bringing our guests to Hidden Still Spirits. Bernard and Kevin do an amazing job to help them feel welcome and the ambiance is unmatched. It's a highlight of our tours. Thank you, Hidden Still for being such a great partner.“

“Played today for the first time with 2 friends. Greens were in good shape, tee boxes were a bit rough. Bummed that bar and restaurant were not open after our round. Would definitely play here again though.“

“Thank you for making my Graduates Feel Special!“

“I love fresh warm tasty donuts. I can’t go back to my normal donuts 🍩 anymore.“

“They Have the best chicken Caesar salad!“

“The food and drink was great . Really nice hometown bar with hard working staff.“

“Bills takes me back to a time when I was a young child. It's a beautiful old restaurant. The staff are fantastic, especially the older lady who waited on us. She said she was the waitress there from the time it was opened, many years ago. Food is fantastic! We always went for the breakfast, which came quick and was always delicious! Pricing is very reasonable. The only thing that I would change is, you have to pay cash, no cards. But, I did say it took me back. Thanks Bill, great job!“

“We met 2 other couples for a birthday dinner. It's no smoking in the dining room but the bar allows. All of the servers are great 👍🏻, personal and friendly. I had suicide wings and were dish. So many variations of sauces and dry rubs. Ice cold drafts and the beef sandwiches are killer good and tender. Ordered side of fries and 2 of us couldn't finish. Parking is on the street and if you have to, rear parking lot but about 20 steps to get to the front door. First time and will definitely be back.. real comfy plain. Wear jeans.“

“Stayed at the lodge, fire & grain and Stacks were not bad. We're going to go to Revelry tonight but heard from multiple people to not bother and reviews hit or miss so went to here instead.

How is this place not higher? Easily the best place to eat at the lodge and its not even close. For the price it was best food and great atmosphere.“

“Excellent food. Certainly recommend this place. First time here, definitely coming again!“