New American Restaurants near Fairfield, PA

“The food and people have remained great at Taverna, but this spot just underwent some extensive renovations. It used to have that small-town ski-lodge dive bar feel, which is REALLY awesome. Now it feels a bit mute while they still undergo more design renos. But the food and people that work there are still the same and haven't sufferer any. So we will continue to frequent this spot!“

“We come to Gettysburg twice a year and always try to stay somewhere new every time. We are so pleased with our stay at Cashtown inn that we will start staying there at least once for our annual visits. I can't say enough about how accommodating the owners and staff were and very knowledgeable of the history of the area and ready to share with you all they know. Of course there is a bit of haunted stories of the building and area, so no matter whether you're coming for the haunts or coming to relax, this is the best place to stay. By far.“

“Food was...almost right. Everything was good, but not quite what it should have been. Not sure what was missing, but to could have been truly awesome. There was an individual pizza that needed a touch of sharpness to make it really sparkle, for example. A drizzle of a balsamic reduction maybe?Still, definitely a cut above the average, and worth considering if you are in Gettysburg for a meal“

“This is a charming spot with good food and quick service, although it can get busy. My burger was cooked just right and the fries were outstanding! Parking is right behind the restaurant and there is an overflow gravel lot behind the paved lot.“

“Popped in before heading out of town, the bartender Hailey was absolutely amazing. She was kind, informative, enthusiastic, and extremely polite. Next time I come to town I am making it a point to come right back here. Cocktails and food were top notch. Excellent place over all.“

“Really liked my smashburger, wife didn't like her regular burger, underseasoned and very little blue cheese on her black and blue burger. Chips are good, fries are good. Beer cheese is awesome. Biggest complaint, I was trying to pay the parking outside and they refused to seat our table of 3 without all 3 of us standing there....like, the restaurant was dead at the time and I was outside paying parking...downloading an app, making a new account, adding a credit card...then paying. Why make them wait? Ridiculous.“

“We couldn't get in the summer. Too long of a line. Easily get seated in January and February lol. Absolutely delicious. Gonna keep going back till tourist season starts.Smokehouse BurgerSmokehouse Burger Went back the next weekend. We sat at the bar and had a fabulous brew draft from Baltimore called Nepenthe Boreal Crypt (Indian pale ale) and delicious burgers again“

“The waitress that served us food was patient, and accommodative as we frantically tried to figure out how to split the bill 6 ways and 4 at the same time (2 people couldn’t pay). The food was great, and worth the wait, and there were hardly any people, leaving a nice environment.“

“Our waitress really made our experience what it was! Family of 7 looking for breakfast with 3 littles - kind of daunting for a server I imagine. She was so kind and patient and told the kids they did a great job ordering for themselves. Food was wonderful too - but I have to reiterate how much we appreciated our server!!“

“The food was very high level...well above even "very good". I don't say that lightly, I travel thr world and love exploring cuisine. We had the crabbstuffed salmon and thr blackened catfish special (among other dishes). They were both superbly executed. Good local beer & booze too.“