31 Best Pizza Restaurants near Fayetteville

“What an amazing experience with a take out order earlier. Great establishment with very friendly workers and a lovely owner! And then there’s the food! What a huge serving of French fries! chicken cheesesteak sub was delicious and stuffed with meat and fillings,and my husband’s cheeseburger sub had a very thick and delicious burger! Would definitely recommend this place and will be eating there again!“

“I cannot give those location enough stars! Wow! From the service to explanation of the menu- but just wait until the food hits your mouth! This will be a place you crave!“

“Great subs,always worth every cent! I've enjoyed Mim's for years and hope to forever!“

“Fantastic food. Loved the rice bowls and crab nachos. Our waitress Camile friendly and attentive. Absolutely 💯 fantastic foodie experience.“

“Enjoyed a fantastic lunch with my fiancé and parents! The pizza was absolute bliss! The pepperoni rolls didn't last long on the table at all either! Ending with their homemade Gelato was definitely the right move😋. The owners are wonderful and so caring with everything they do, from menu to atmosphere. A must try!“

“New to me. I ordered my pizza with veggies but I think I did the wrong combination on cauliflower crust. The crust was great. Very tasty.

The rewards program was not eligible to me because it did not work on my phone. They don't have the newest version for android.“

“food good ,good price,go back“

“definitely a five star Establishment. best! pesto pasta I've eaten. the Romain salad, everything is very favorable and fresh! and at a reasonable price. highly recommend!! and the good thing! it's two miles from my home. I will definitely be back for more! 💯❤️💪“

“I went in and ordered a taco salad it was the best taco salad I have had in so long they had fresh avocado cucumbers onions tomatoes it came with your choice of meat I pick steak sour cream it was delicious the lettuce was so fresh in the shower was so crispy I recommend Grace Pizza for way more than pizza thank you Grace pizza. And the staff was great“

“Good food. Burgers were off the hook fries were delicious. Will be back“

“Hoagies are lacking meat ! Tried different times to see if it was a mistake! Great family and hoping this can be corrected soon ! Miss eating here and the great food! Wish you all the best!“

“We ate at Arturo’s tonight and Sabian (?) was our waiter. He was so kind and polite. He was very fast to serve us and was constantly checking in. The gluten free pizza was very good! Kudos to the team!“

“I’m from out of town and was staying in Shippensburg and was looking for some pizza for dinner. I found reviews and decided to try Pizza Man. I placed my order online, very simple process and you can customize everything. I didn’t do delivery, I did carry out, as it was 3 mins from my hotel. I ordered the Sicilian pizza with everything no olives and bacon cheese fries with ranch. The pizza was amazing and the size was great for the price. The Sicilian pizza is huge. From the dough to the toppings everything was fresh and the tomato sauce wasn’t overpowering either. The bacon cheese fries were hot, fresh, and cheesy with a homemade ranch to dip them in. My family and I all agreed this was the best pizza we’d ever ate and wished that our pizza down home tasted like this. If you’re looking for a great pizza place, then choose Pizza Man, you won’t regret it!“

“Ledos Chambersburg is now owned by same family that owns Hagerstown Martinsburg and Ranson ledo“

“Pizza & mozzarella sticks were great- good sauce. The wings were very tasty but slightly overcooked on one of them & the blue cheese dressing is a packet. The order was accurate, and the clerk was real nice to talk to.

I plan to return to check consistency.“

“Amazing Italian restaurant in our hometown of Chambersburg. I'm so glad she made it through the Covid shutdowns. Her food is perfection and service is great. I love the chicken parmigiana, salad, and fresh oven baked bread.“

“Papa J's is definitely the gold standard of chain pizza restaurants. Hours are solid at this location and food was cooked great. I do wish they would honor the no contact note when delivering. Since we are sick, that would've been made more sense“

“The service was good. There was only one person working but he was good at his job. The place wasnt busy.The pizza isnt as good as I remember from years ago,though. It used to have a certain taste to it. I dont know what pizza hut did to the flavor.“

“I only order from this papa John’s location.
The workers are very good very polite

They fix any problems.

I recommend anybody else to also order from this location

Very trustworthy“

“I am the soccer coach for Fayetteville 2-3rd grade soccer and Dominos provided a wonderful private room for our end of season party. They also discounted our pizza to support youth sports in the community! The staff was friendly and quick to help with anything we needed. Grateful for an awesome partnership in the community!“

“Alfredo's, in my opinion, has the best pizza in Shippensburg. Having been a customer for more than a few years now, they are a part of my routine and are an appreciated member of the community. Everyone has their favorite, and that's fine, but Sal and his team are my first pick. Small business is the best business to support.“

“I had ordered online for pickup later. My meeting ended early and I went in and asked if they could make it early. They were quite busy and they were so nice about it and started on it right away. I appreciated the friendly staff and being flexible.“

“Pizza sometimes can be undercooked or overdone or even not that warm.. but it came cooked perfectly to order with extra pepperoni extra cheese and very HOT.“

“They have the best pizza. We ordered a Margarita Pizza and it was as good as the pizza we had in Naples, Italy“

“My meal was over cooked wings and calamari, calamari was worst I ever had, waitress was very polite“

“Nobody answers the phone Online pickup order app does not work Find another pizza restaurant“

“Always great food and service...“

“🍕🍕🍕 fresh, hot, and fast!!!“

“Stopped their with my wife and my Mother .. the restaurant was sparkling clean the service was fantastic and the pizza, steak subs, mozzarella sticks and fries were great everyone really enjoyed our visit and will definitely go back again.. Delicious food!!!!!😋“

“Love the pepperoni tavern pizza“

“Huge shout out to Stephanie! The online app wasn't letting me finish my order because of something to do with my card, Stephanie did an amazing job of honoring the same deal for me and made sure my food was made promptly and correctly. Which was important for me that day as thats what my children requested for lunch while we were attending our Harvest Moon Market in Shippensburg! Thanks to her we were able to get our food quickly and effortlessly with smiles on everyone's faces! The Lane family appreciates you and all the other hard workers that made sure our food was Hot, Ready and Delicious!“