10 Best Italian Restaurants near Gettysburg

“We had such a wonderful experience in every way - from menu recommendations, to great service and exceptional food! Our sweet server, Sara, offered helpful suggestions including a favorite, Montepulciano wine, an antipasto salad, customized lightly breaded entrees and desserts! The limoncello cake is not one to miss! We have family coming to visit soon and we will be sure to bring them here!“

“I had the pleasure of working with Cristina to plan my sister’s wedding rehearsal dinner. Cristina and her team set out to make the best pre-wedding dinner ever! The place setting, center pieces, and dinner menus were specially curated by Erin and Cristina to match our Spring theme and wedding colors. The food was spectacular and cooked to perfection from Mama herself! We opted for appetizers, two entrees, mouth watering tiramisu and cannoli bites. My sister had a destination wedding and this was all planned from Central Maine! Cristina was eager to help me plan this special dinner and communicated amazingly with the food and tailored drink selections- and for parking for my ~33 guest count. I highly recommend the food. I highly recommend the genuine people and their service. The Mama Ventura’s team made my sister’s dream come true, and I personally can say they will do the same for you and your family too.“

“Our first experience at Olivia’s was perfect! We sat outside on the patio and enjoyed the beautiful weather. The service and wait staff was top notch and could not have been any better. My wife got a steak and I got the lobster, crab and shrimp scampi. Both meals were delicious and the steak was cooked perfect. When leaving the restaurant, Olivia’s provided a free flower to every mother for Mother’s Day. Our evening was perfect and we will be sure to return!“

“We were visiting PA from Long Island and stopped here. Being from NY I'm always comparing other states pizza. lol Brothers Pizza is AWESOME.“

“if you like Italian food this is the place! Will return as often as possible.“

“I was recently at La Bella Italia on two separate occasions. Antonia was our server both times. She was very helpful and courteous and delivered remarkably good customer service. The entire atmosphere was great and the food was fantastic. I highly recommend this experience Karen and Harry“

“The Italian food at Tuscany's is the best I have had this side of Arthur Street in the Bronx“

“Little Italy V catered my 70th birthday party. The Ziti was awesome!! Plenty of meat and cheese and the garlic bread that comes with it is big and tasty! We ordered 10 dozen wings which were cooked to perfection! The 70+ people at my party loved it all! Thank you Luciano and Victor! You are the best!!“

“The staff at Liberty Mountain Ski Resort recommended King's NY Pizza. My husband and I figured we would try this out. I got a grilled cheese sandwich, which was wonderfully toasted and not heavily buttered! Just delicious!! My husband wanted a sub sandwich which he thoroughly enjoyed as well. Price is reasonable, quality was top notch! I would definitely eat here again and recommend this eatery located in the Market!“

“We stopped in Emmitsburg for gas and chow, on our way back to NY, and decided to forgo McDonalds for once and get a pie from Carleo’s when we spotted the store front. So glad we did…possibly the best pizza we ever had! We hit the road and ate the whole 16” pie in 10 minutes and were seriously debating on turning around for another.“