5 Best American Restaurants near Greencastle

“I was shocked at the freshness of the food. There's no a chain-style eatery that can compare!5⭐️I'll travel the 3.5hrs to eat there again.“

“Absolutely hands down one of the best if not the best restaurants in Greencastle, PA!! AJ has done a superb job with taking over ownership not to mention keeping the fantastic chefs and I am sure adding new chefs too!

Drinks, alcoholic or nonalcoholic are superb as well! The atmosphere is amazing, great customer service staff, with the choice to eat casual in the bar or restaurant side of the bar or enhance your evening with date night to enjoy the more formal dining experience.

Plus BONUS, for all your event needs you can also book their banquet room for special occasions. We held our daughter’s graduation party here years ago!

Check out these images“

“It has been years since we had been here (no reason other than it hadn't been top of mind) and decided to give it a try and was very glad we did. The steak tips and the haddock were absolutely delicious, along with the roasted potatoes and green beans, plus the fresh baked bread. Stacey, our server was friendly and attentive. Will definitely be back again soon.“

“it was great to find a truck stop with a real restaurant. food was great and large portions“

“I have to say, wow, we are very impressed with the new old bay chicken tenders. Keep up the excellent work. I highly recommend eating here—my 3 yr. Old is tough to please and very picky, but he loves the food also. Thank you for everything. Enjoyable environment. The people are so kind. If you have high expectations of cleanliness and love home-cooked meals, Gibbles is the place to go. Ps, the cupcakes are out of this world delicious.“