30 Best Pizza Restaurants near Greencastle

“Great place to eat! Seat yourself, and then our waitress Jessica came over to greet us within minutes! Service was fast, friendly and the food was delicious! Decently priced too! Great atmosphere and kid friendly! Definitely recommend Brother's Pizza- we will be going back again! Thank you Jessica ☺️“

“Best pizza in the area by far“

“It’s been a long time since we dined in at Pizza Hut. The waitress was better than most of the “finer” restaurants we’ve been eating at.“

“Godfathers has always been my favorite pizza since my childhood.

I have tried every pizza place in Hagerstown before starting to look in adjacent towns before discovering that this quaint lil gas station serves pizza as good as I remember it.

English is not the first language of the employees I spoke to, but they were incredibly kind and got the orders right over the phone and in person. That's what counts at the end of the day.“

“Pizza was tasty and they did the large order in a timely manner. Gluten free pizza was also very delicious.
Our car ended up having a battery issue and one of the kind workers came out and brought his car over with jump cables to help us out. Really appreciated his help! 5 stars!“

“The person who helped me over the phone had an excellent phone presence and was very helpful. When I picked up my order, she was pleasant, cheerful and communicated very well. I cannot remember her name, but would return again and again to receive this level of customer service.“

“The food was wonderful. The Owners were friendly as well as the staff. The patio was a great place to enjoy our meal. Really enjoyed our meals.“

“The restaurant was a pleasant surprise since we were 200 miles from home. Our server Quinn was especially friendly and brought our orders very quickly, accurateltly and always with a smile. The ambiance was perfect for a fun experience for the entire family and we all look forward to visiting again! I would highly recommend for an enjoyable and fun time as the food was great and the portions were large enough to enable us to take home for another meal!“

“Have been a customer of Arturos for 20 years. Ownership has changed a few times but not the pizza. Love their service and selections. They are a little short on staff so be patient and kind. 100% recommend!“

“It's something about the house Italian dressing and the Antipasto Salad!!! Awesome staff and great food!!! #madewithlove“

“The service is top notch down home and very friendly. Never been disappointed. Love Dino and his wife. They are the BEST!!“

“Ledos Chambersburg is now owned by same family that owns Hagerstown Martinsburg and Ranson ledo“

“My meal was over cooked wings and calamari, calamari was worst I ever had, waitress was very polite“

“Have ordered here a few times recently. The first time was a little rough because I mistakenly used the pinpoint order and didn’t fill out the info they needed. Since then, using the app to order, they have it done on time and they serve it up with a smile.“

“Alex is an excellent server to compliment the excellent food. We have dined close to a dozen times and have never been disappointed with any of ours or appetizers. Highly recommend for the best Italian Restaurant in Hagerstown and surrounding areas.“

“I went in and ordered a taco salad it was the best taco salad I have had in so long they had fresh avocado cucumbers onions tomatoes it came with your choice of meat I pick steak sour cream it was delicious the lettuce was so fresh in the shower was so crispy I recommend Grace Pizza for way more than pizza thank you Grace pizza. And the staff was great“

“Such fast service i didn’t even get to talk w my date! 😁“

“What can you say about cafe Italia... if you don't already know how great this place is, you are missing out. I can't tell you how many people have told me this is the only place in town to get pizza. The food is amazing, the people are amazing (hi Mike!). If you don't already know how great this place is you owe it to yourself to stop in and try it. I've literally never had anything that isn't great. The pizza, pasta, subs, garlic knots, salad. You name it, it's great. So get over there already.“

“First time eating here, picked up and it was delicious!“

“I am the soccer coach for Fayetteville 2-3rd grade soccer and Dominos provided a wonderful private room for our end of season party. They also discounted our pizza to support youth sports in the community! The staff was friendly and quick to help with anything we needed. Grateful for an awesome partnership in the community!“

“Papa J's is definitely the gold standard of chain pizza restaurants. Hours are solid at this location and food was cooked great. I do wish they would honor the no contact note when delivering. Since we are sick, that would've been made more sense“

“Waitress was helpful and friendly. The lasagna fresh and homemade. Chicken parmesian was huge and delicious. Also homemade and 2 hand breaded patties.Salad was fresh and house dressing homemade. Cheesesticks fresh, crunchy outside and delicious with delicious homade sauce. Caramel dessert amazing. Everything we had terrific authentic flavor, seasoned well. Overall best food we've had at a restaurant in a long time.“

“It's always pretty good but sometimes they rush the Pizza when they're busy but I used to work in a pizza place and I know how it gets. This time it was wonderful though.

Parking: It's just street parking and there's always open spots because the only other people that park there are people that are delivering.“

“I had ordered online for pickup later. My meeting ended early and I went in and asked if they could make it early. They were quite busy and they were so nice about it and started on it right away. I appreciated the friendly staff and being flexible.“

“They have the best pizza. We ordered a Margarita Pizza and it was as good as the pizza we had in Naples, Italy“

“On a trip home from Myrtle Beach to Northeast PA, we overnighted in Hagerstown MD and decided to give this place a try. We ordered a Margherita Pizza. It was delicious! Where we are from, everything is NY Style so this was a nice change of pace. The crust is delicious! The staff are also super nice and friendly. Definitely recommend Cafe Del Sol.“

“Stopped their with my wife and my Mother .. the restaurant was sparkling clean the service was fantastic and the pizza, steak subs, mozzarella sticks and fries were great everyone really enjoyed our visit and will definitely go back again.. Delicious food!!!!!😋“

“I just wanted too give Tyler a huge shout out he did fantastic with getting my order correct and dealing with the amount of customers there was that guy needs a raise that store was packed an he handled it amazingly he’s the only reason I go there !“

“Very well done! Service was fine. Cant beat the price“

“always excellent food, highly recommend.“