50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Jefferson Hills

“Best service by Nikki and Shay always hands down they are reason I am there alway best bartenders ever and food and atmosphere is amazing too 🙌🙌“

“Yolis Italian cuisine is amazing, always a pleaser, can't choose wrong on the menu! Catering is delicious, custom charcuterie boards available for purchase. Sit down n dine, or belly up to the bar. Priced right, beers cold! Come see Logan on Monday n Tuesday afternoon, she don't smile much, but lights up the room when she does! Enjoy!“

“I absolutely recommend Fellini’s! DoorDash mixed up the orders between two customers and gave my family the wrong one. Tom, the GM, took care of everything for both us and the other customer. He was awesome and handled the issue right away! We couldn’t have asked for a better customer service experience working directly with Fellini’s! We will continue to order from Fellinis for our pizza & hoagies.“

“I love the deals dominoes always has. 50% off all pizzas is my favorite deal. Their new cheese stuffed crust is really good. This is the “viral” steak, bacon pizza everyone has been getting. Figured I’d try it with jalapeños added. Definitely good. But my favorite pizza to make is ranch sauce, bacon & jalapeños. Always my go to 👌🏼 Dominoes is always reliable.“

“Excellent pizza. Love the sausage.“

“The best pizza we have had in Pittsburgh! Had the Italian Hoagie too- delicious! Place was super clean and folks were friendly. Look no further!!“

“Our family tried the take and bake and it was delicious! Service was fast and the staff was friendly! We will definitely be going there more often!“

“Best hoagies I’ve ever eaten. Good prices and a friendly staff.“

“The most important reason is that this is a local, family owned business. Throughout the year there are holiday baked goods offerings. This is more than our local pizza shop. We feel like neighbors and friends.“

“Finally tried this place and the pizza is amazing a definitely must try it“

“we just moved to the area and have tried a few local pizza places...they've all sucked! 1. we got so SICK after eating it. 2. the pizza was okay, but the calzone was raw...like more raw dough than cheese!!! 3. just tasted like cardboard. 4. over priced but not atrocious. well tonight I REALLY REALLY wanted good pizza! I contemplated driving an hour and a half to get a pizza from a place that I KNOW is safe! I stead I took the chance with Pasquales. seriously the best pizza I've had in the LONGEST TIME. it was so fast, I honestly expected it to be horrible. but it was delicious! I usually can barely crush 2 pieces...I ate 6.. I do feel sick but that's just because I ate way too much!! the sauce has flavor, it's well seasoned. the crust is buttery and delicious. you can actually TASTE the garlic! they don't skimp on seasoning which is so nice! this is our new go to for pizza!!!“

“Amazing pizza!!! Tried NY style which was definitely a traditional Brooklyn slice as well as Sicilian style. Both were fabulous! I’ve been waiting for this kind of pizza in Pittsburgh for a long time and it hit a home run!!♥️“

“This is God's pizza! Pizza by which all others are judged. Pizza all pizzas aspire to yet never achieve. To eat this pizza is to ruin all other pizza on the planet. You will forever hang your head at the thought of another's pizza.“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ highly recommended!“

“Amazing pizza!!! The slices are gigantic! If you could eat 3 pieces of their pizza, you may need to see a cardio doctor. Well worth checking out! You won’t regret it!“

“Great pizza at a really great price! We used to get this pizza many, many years ago when the had a location on east Carson st. Still as good as it ever was! Keep in mind, they are cash only. Good to know before showing up. Definitely give them a try if you are in the area. Follow for more...“

“Love their pizza sooooo much!!! And the owner is a really cool guy.“

“awesome staff. I will go there again and again now baby“

“I just love there cheeseburgers and fries and also the pizza. I order from them all the time. All there good is really good“

“The Pizza was baked just right with perfect amount of pepperoni and cheese. I will be a regular customer moving forward.
They are only about 1/10 mile from my house. I used to have to drive at least several miles for pizza that is decent.“

“I always get takeout but the dine in area is a clean simple pizza shop vibe.
The counter service is so busy and still organized and friendly. The pizza is very different than what you may be use to. Cheese and toppings are piled on cold after the crust and sauce are cooked to a crispy tasty perfection. I like to take a few bites as served and then bake or broil the rest. You gotta love cheese like I do to love this pizza. I personally love the sauce because it's not sweet nor bitter, very flavorful and clearly fresh made. If you think you can eat 4 square pieces, you may want to order 3 or save some for leftovers. If you're still reading, parking is tight but spots open fairly quickly. Just be a bit patient.“

“Solid pizza I would recommend“

“Amazing pizza and people. First place I stopped into on my trip to Pittsburgh area. Cant recommend them enough. Ill be back tomorrow before I leave. Thanks again. Truck N Tony from Idaho.“

“While visiting the Pittsburgh, PA area, I went to Mineos Pizza House for the first time in 20 plus years. I used to eat this pizza with my grandmother while she was working at a dry cleaners in Mt. Lebanon. The person I remember who I referred to as Mineo wasn't there but the pizza was the same as I remember it. While we were there, there was a steady flow of customers stopping in for pizza. I had a scisilian slice of pepperoni and a thin slice with tomato. My dad ordered half of a meatball sandwich and it was more than he could finish. The sandwich was delicious and very filling. Give it a try if you are in the area.“

“My husband and I was just in there. The pizza is really good and the workers are very polite.“

“Their food is amazing never ever had a complaint! But Their garlic butter sauce if off the charts amazing especially for dipping steak rolls in. Only place I will ever order steak rolls from hands down“

“We've always enjoyed Pizza Shack. Since moving to Florida 35 years ago we still haven't food any pizza as great as theirs! Every time we come back to Pgh. we make sure we get that delicious pizza from Pizza Shack!!!“

“when i think of pizza, gennaro's is what comes to mind. the crust is well-seasoned and baked perfectly, and the toppings are the perfect doneness. the menu selection is impressive with reasonable prices, and the staff are always kind regardless of the time of day. my go-to recommendation for friends asking about good south side pizza“

“Great place to eat . Consistency is key for me . these folks got it down.“

“This place was by far better than Scoops, i cannot remember the last time i ate a really good hoagie, until i had a bite of chicken bacon hoagie that was far better than any other hoagie places. They do pizza right, other pizza would burn then crust, skimp on toppings, barely any cheese. This OG place had me get cheese pulls and i am coming back here again. I cant imagine their wings.“

“Worked with our seemingly-constant back-and-forth ordering method. Always available to treat and delicious tasting food.“

“Very clean place nice workers excellent pizza“

“Very good pizza. Never disappointed.“

“Mario’s offers great value deals - we got 12 mild wings and large cheese pizza for $25. They deliver locally for only $2 charge! Delivery was also very quick. The mild sauce for the wings was thin and buttery. The pizza had a nice soft crust, taste almost reminds me of Fox’s pizza.“

“Quintessential pizzeria... not only is the staff fast and friendly inefficient they also go above and beyond with a little extras that mean the world to customers such as myself.

Guys if you're reading this to the staff of Bellisario's I wish there was a way to get you guys even more business not like you're hurting though because honestly your pizza is a Hidden Gem in West Mifflin particularly in Duquesne Shopping Center....yinz keep up the excellent work!

Wheelchair accessibility: It's on ground level and easily accessed and I guarantee if you have the phone number ahead of time which is on Google someone will open the door for you.“

“From the pizzas (regular or gourmet), to burgers, don't forget fresh hibachi, and to the milkshakes. I haven't found nothing here that wasn't delicious! They definitely have a little bit of everything!“

“everything we have ever ordered from here has been great. had pizza, hoagies, gyros, soups, rolls. never had a complaint about any of the food. would recommend.“

“Great place. Just nothing stay in stock for long. There like really our only deli like place. So many people from our area depend on this place. Great employees and they follow most guidelines other then the temperature check, but this is my favorite because they try their best to have and keep supply and demand. A Lot without cars here in this town . so product leave a bit faster then others. Great jon Station“

“There are many pizza places in the Mon Valley. Very few of them are consistent. This is one of the few. You never disappoint. Food is always too notch, and the service is the icing on the cake! I applaud you and will brag about you from here to eternity. Thank you, thank you, and thank you again!“

“This pizza is always hitting the mark, great dough texture and always hot and tasty!

But more than the pizza, the family like atmosphere is always worth mentioning. I have had great experiences with every employee there!

And my dog gives the crust 5 stars lol!“

“Was in town with the family from out of state and wanted authentic pizza with crisp to it. Ordered a large pepperoni and a whole Meatball Hogie. This place did not let down. The flavor, crispy bottom and perfect combination of sauce, cheese and pepperoni this pizza was awesome! Not to mention ton the service was top notch. Definitely will be making this a regular stop whenever I’m back in Pittsburgh.“

“their plum tomato pizza with the cold cheese is the best, and not too pricey either. this is our favorite, deff recommend!“

“I’ve been to this place about 10 times in the past 2-3 yrs. I got a kennywood pass & today suggested it to my husband I wanted to order it to go. I also ordered my grandparents a few slices cause they’re a big fan of square pizza. It’s a cash only place with an ATM.
First of all a boy about 10 yrs old was hanging out outside and followed me in. They said I had a few more mins to wait & to kill time I started looking at photo albums on a rack. The boy came over & knew all the history to these old photos. He was such a smart, sweet, polite young man!
She told me the price & I said I had to run out to the car for the rest of $$ because I was $7 short, she told not to worrry about it& gave me a bunch of bananas. I just can’t believe how awesome this family is. The boy was the grandson of the original owners.
You just instantly felt welcomed here. The pizza is amazing!! I have an Italian hoagie here I didn’t even try yet but it smells and looks amazing. It just feels loved. It’s definitely underrated. They are are open Thursday-Saturday 4-8pm. Hours are weird but worth the accommodation. The world is hard and cold. This place almost made me cry with a simple interaction with this family & the regular customers there.“

“It’s the best pizza in the Burgh. My wife and I just celebrated our 50 Anniversary and we been getting pizza from Pizza King for 50 years. The king took care of us. Thank You.“

“KATIE MY ONE OF THEE BEST GRILLED CHICKEN SALADS I HAVE HAD IN A LOOOONNNNG TIME !!! DEFINITELY WILL RETURN !!! THANK YOU KATIE ! I just called and thanked you personally!“

“Pepperoni Pizza tastes great!! My new go-to pizza joint!“

“The food is amazing and affordable, service is awesome ❣️ delivery was on time food temp was perfect my hoagie was warm and my cheesecake was perfectly chill😋 one day I will have to dine in.... Thanks to all involved with my order ❣️ sorry no photo no time for that lol....“

“Hands down the best pizza in pittsburgh. This place is definitely not talked enough about !! 10/10 everytime !! ❤️❤️“

“Wow! What a find!!! In town for just a few days and our place was close to Fox’s. Prices are very reasonable and the pizza is excellent. Ample sauce and perfect amount of toppings. We will definitely become repeat customers upon our return.“

“Their Philly Steak Hoagies are the best. They use REAL BEEF STEAK. Not that cheap "Steak Ums" or poor quality questionable meat.
Plus, their fries are fresh, not frozen, cut potatoes.
Their pizza is above "average." I'd give 4 1/2 ⭐.
But, I'm not really a pizza connoisseur. To me, a pizza is a glorified cheese sandwich.
I do like their crusts and options given for their crusts. Thin or "Sicilian style," a thick crust.
I prefer thin. I'm not a dough/bread/pasta lover.“