10 Best Italian Restaurants near Lake Ariel

1 Al Dentes Pizzeria and Creamery - Golf Park Drive lake ariel

4.1 Good 179 Reviews

1148 Golf Park Drive, Lake Ariel

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I ordered a pizza past 8 because everywhere I like in honesdale was closed so I figured id branch out. I cant tell you how pleasantly surprised I was when I pulled in. Im not sure if it was the beach vibes, the very nice ladies behind the counter who let my son have a sick pair of shades or just the fantastic pizza itself but I am delighted to have found this place.”

2 Palermo`s Pizza Restaurant & Bar

3.4 Good 214 Reviews

1315 Hamlin Highway, Lake Ariel

“Best food I had by far”

3 Pat's pizza and Hoagies

4.5 Superb 147 Reviews

21 Hospital Street, Carbondale · 10.69 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“💯🔥100% hat's off to you Sir That was the very Best Sicilian we have ever had in our life in the state of Pa 100% you will be seeing us a Lot more Now that we have found you ! God Bless Great People & Pride in Food they Per duce with Pride !!!!💯🔥🤌”

4 Pettinato's

4.6 Superb 95 Reviews

78 Dundaff Street, Carbondale · 10.53 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“OMG...It was so great to have Pettinato's Restaurant food again...Everything was soooo delicious and we even have enough leftovers to eat again today (can't wait). Pierre and family are so nice and courteous. It was the perfect ending to a wonderful Mother's Day....Thank-you!”

5 Frank's Place

4.6 Superb 471 Reviews

57 Jefferson Street, Simpson · 11.13 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Had a great evening at Frank's Place❤️ The food was fabulous and the service and atmosphere equally great. It was truly worth the drive up from Scranton. Looking forward to my next meal at Frank's.”

6 Leonor’s Eatery

4.6 Superb 204 Reviews

135 North Main Street, Moscow · 10.63 miles

“the food is good, nice variety of menu options and the staff is very friendly.”

7 John's Italian Restaurant

4.1 Good 277 Reviews

Pennsylvania 590, Hamlin · 3.64 miles

• Take-Out

“great place for wonderful food at a good price. Their bread is the best”

8 Eleganté Ristoranté & Pizzeria

4.0 Good 247 Reviews

851 Main Street, Honesdale · 10.57 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Friendly staff, and the best pizza in Honesdale!”

9 John's Italian Restaurant

3.9 Good 348 Reviews

1406 PA-507, Greentown · 8.44 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“John’s Italian is excellent! The pizza is absolutely delicious with the perfect crispy crust. The Stromboli is huge, crunchy on the outside, and packed with flavor. The service is always friendly and welcoming. What made our visit extra special was the kindness of the staff. My two kids each donated a dollar to support autism, and the ladies working there surprised them with two huge cookies as a thank-you. Such a thoughtful gesture that meant a lot to them. Great food, wonderful people, and outstanding customer service. We’ll definitely be back!”

10 Two Guys from Italy Express Waymart

3.1 Average 21 Reviews

631 Roosevelt Highway, Waymart · 9.46 miles

• Take-Out

“Stopped on the bikes with my buddy he got a few slices of pizza and boy were they great! Im from New York and havent had pizza like that in years! Super thin crust and not burnt! Perfect ratio!! I went in and told the chef he did a great job!!! Strongly recommend giving them a try!!! 5/5 Kid-friendliness: Very friendly”