27 Best Bakeries in Lancaster

“Absolutely thrilled with my husband’s retirement cake! I told Patty my ideas, and what she created was better than we imagined. Besides the fact that it looked amazing, it tasted delicious! People at the party couldn’t stop talking about the cake! Highly recommend! (Photo in comments.)“

“Fabulous cream cheese bialys! Better than I can find in NY.“

“The bread, pizza, & granola are all brilliantly good, & Thom & his team are fantastic - highly recommended!“

“Once again you knocked it out of the park! We have enjoyed a cake for our wedding, 1st Anniversary and now 10th!It was delicious and also brought back so many great memories. Here's to many more celebrations!!!!“

“Best Sandwiches in Lancaster area!! And the service customer is great, will definitely come back!“

“Jenna’s cake for my dad’s 70th birthday was truly one of a kind! I wanted to incorporate some of my dad’s favorite things, and Jenna helped me create the most special, personalized cake for him. He absolutely loved it, and it made him feel so special.

Not only was the design perfect, but the cake itself was the most delicious I’ve ever had! It was so moist, perfectly balanced—not overly sweet, just incredibly tasty. We even put some in the fridge, and four days later, it was still just as moist and delicious!

I would absolutely recommend Jenna for any event, big or small. If I were getting married again, she’d be the one to do my wedding cake. She’s that good!“

“Food is amazing and pricing is very reasonable.“

“I dropped by for a quick bite to eat before a work conference and was pleasantly surprised! My bagel was delicious, and the coffee was excellent. After years of having so much burnt espresso it made my day to finally have a properly pulled shot of espresso in my latte. The service was great, the young lady who took my order told me all about some great historic landmarks to check out while I’m in the area and made me feel so welcomed to Lancaster.

Make sure to stop in for a bite to eat and quick caffeine hit, you’ll be glad you did!“

“The best pie I've ever had!“

“I love Alfred and Sam's breads and sub rolls they are fresh and soft, most rewarding places to go get fresh bread. Hope they continue servicing the Lancaster area. You can never have enough bread 🍞😉😋 I promise you'll like it. Best place to buy bread for any occasion.“

“A must stop for anyone in Lancaster. I would consider this a hidden gem. If you are traveling to Lancaster and want a delicious sticky bun, skip every bakery except Mr. Sticky! They are huge, taste amazing and the price is actually very fair. I went to a Cinnabon in the mall the other day and paid $7 for a cinnamon bun! I instantly wished I went to Mr. Sticky.“

“Went to lancaster today and visited this place...Nice atmosphere...The owner and staff were very friendly, Place was very clean... The empanadas were delicious...must try an alfajore for dessert... Can't wait to visit again.... Thank you, had a great time there.....“

“We came across Amaranth Bakery at a festival recently. They had quite a selection of GF vegan options available. The brownies were the absolute best that we’ve had. Amaranth knows how to bake!“

“The bread, pizza, & granola are all brilliantly good, & Thom & his team are fantastic - highly recommended!“

“The menu selection and preparation was, as always, perfect. We had three generations at lunch, and each found something wonderful from the menu. Everyone delighted in the dessert options from the bakery case. Our out-of-town visitors were charmed and impressed. The bathroom was disappointingly dirty with no hook for a bag. Our server had exceptionally long nails with embellishments that did not appear sanitary.“

“Love this place very friendly and happy people to be around“

“Delicious bagel breakfast sandwiches and coffee. Can’t wait to try their lunch menu. Friendly staff!“

“Awesome breakfast spot - flaky croissants are the best! And the homemade ketchup! Nice outside space to enjoy with friends!“

“Hands down the best, really handcrafted coffee I've had in a VERY long time. The guy running the show recommended trying the house chai, and I was blown away. I didn't know chai could be that good. Also had a cappuccino, and I was just as impressed. The owner(?) was super friendly, helpful, and kind with everything. It's a bit off the beaten track if you're driving, but I recommend finding this place and stopping in!“

“We went for the Grand Opening today and I have to say the staff was WONDERFUL. I would love to shout out a few super great people we had the pleasure of interacting with today: the first two were the young men running the pumpkin patch. You could tell they got bombarded but they handled it so well and were super nice. The second is the two young men who were running the basketball game & hit the cans game near the Whip ride. My two sons played both games and the guys there were so incredibly sweet. The third was Greyson, who was running the Photo Booth inside Merlin’s Mayhem - just amazing service and such a great personality. We have been pass holders for the past three years and this was the best day we’ve had!“

“Keep going down with gas prices“

“Went to the Mother’s Day brunch buffet today and it was fabulous! Not only was the food absolutely scrumptious, the atmosphere and service staff was so pleasant and welcoming. Thank you for such a great experience!PS can we just talk about the biscuits and gravy ??? TO DIE FOR!!! My nephew couldn’t get enough“

“My order was done exactly as I needed it and was ready for pick up at the requested time

Parking: Is located in the food court of a mall, more than enough parking

Wheelchair accessibility: Has parking, ramps, and automatic doors“

“Absolutely amazing food great service!!! I got the loaded breakfast tot!!! 10/10 RECOMMEND!!!! Thank you savory truffle for a wonderful meal!!!“

“Great food and service!! Friendly staff and did I mention the food is AMAZING 🤤“