16 Best Bakeries near Gordonville

“The combination of ingredients used in and on her cupcakes are awesome! I love her cupcakes and her personality and cheerfulness! I just wish I didn’t need to be on a diet! A treat once in a while is necessary though! Keep up the great job!“

“The journey to this bake shop is a story.

We drive into an Amish farm and saw no cars parked, nor a sign telling us where the bakery is. We drive deeper into the barn, almost knocking over the family dog. There were some dogs in cages barking at us, not sure if it was to welcome us, or to warn us.

We saw a guy who seem to work there, or owns the place. He told us that we went too far in, and said “turn around, it’s the red shed”.

We turned the car around, again, looking around to see which of those could be the bakery. We saw a hand written board “open”.

We go in. Shelves were almost empty except for a few trays of whoopie pies and some fry pies in the refrigerator. No one was inside except a box saying “self service”. “Interesting” we thought. Never have we seen such an establishment that was based on trust.

OH yes, how were the pies you say? SO GOOD. Just gotta bake them real good for a little. The whoopie pies are also really moist and cream not coyingly sweet.“

“Michael's Homemade Breads are the absolute best breads in the area! Their cinnamon raisin Bread is so delicious, it keeps me driving an hour away just to get it! Love it!“

“This was something like my 3rd visit. It is an absolute must when coming to Amish Country. Make it a jumping off place for your exploring. The baked goods are amazing, the service is friendly, efficient and well thought out and the ambiance lets you begin to feel that you have really stepped away from your busy, modern life. Great for families, tourists or those who just want a to slow down.“

“As always amazing the woopie pies where a hit at our friends party .. Thank you again“

“I liked the store very much!“

“I've had cheesecakes, special order cupcakes and special order cakes and everytime they were delicious and decorated so beautifully. My recent turtle cake was amazing! Always above and beyond my expectations! Thank you Pastry Paradise“

“Beautiful White Rhapsody Birthday cake! The colors and the glitter were so pretty! The raspberry mousse and raspberry marmalade are like clouds of heaven. First cake from here and would definitely order from them again. Prices are reasonable as well. Thank you!“

“We were in this PA area for only about 1/2 hour but I am very glad we chose to stop here! I was curious about shoo-fly pie and was thrilled when we walked in and were promptly offered a free sample of shoo-fly pie! It was delicious! There were plenty of other baked items for sale and the prices were really reasonable. I got a small plate of snickerdoodle cookies and my son got a peanut butter whoopie pie, and they were really good. The prices of the other souvenirs were pretty good too. Recommend stopping here.“

“best cheese Danish ever !!.“

“Great people, found them while delivering over the years as a truck driver.If you have a farmers market in your area with Amish selling cheesecake, cakes, and torts most of it is Pellmans, if you can't make it out to the New Holland area“

“Alway a good place for a quick lunch, often there are samples for you to try.“

“Unique accent to the local "flavor". Neat, clean, well stocked with only locally made food for that unique experience. Staff is friendly and knowledgeable. Stop in, a must see that's worth it!“

“My son loves Dutch wonderland. And it’s great. My only issue is customer service. I reached out about getting tickets reissued due to the rain and their rainy day guarantee and didn’t get an answer.“

“I got a variety of the buns since this was the first time visiting. Once we got home, we tried each bun- regular sticky, cinnamon roll and walnut sticky. They were all delicious and the vanilla icing just made it even better. Nice treat for ending our trip to Lancaster.“

“Jessica does the BEST cakes!!! Every time she does one for one of my kids they absolutely LOVE it!!! and especially all of their friends. Thank you again for making Bryce's birthday so special.“