28 Best Italian Restaurants in Lancaster

“Dinner and a show. Everything on the menu is absolutely amazing. “The Show” happens when you sit at Chef’s table and watch them team create one masterpiece after another. I watched them train a new employee to do the same! Pinch and pull the dough- enough sauce, but not too much. Carefully and skillfully place all ingredients! final inspection before the fire and then another after. Watch for this and that before you serve. Pizza will. ever to the same for me.“

“I absolutely loved the food. My boyfriend and I were very satisfied.“

“We ate at the Lancaster PA location today. Service was top notch and food was great! Great experience!“

“After finding out Pie in the Sky offered thick square Sicilian pizza I figured I'd pick one up for NFL Sunday. Unfortunately the person answering the phone misheard me and I had a traditional round pie waiting when I got there. I politely explained this to the manager, he threw a square Sicilian in the oven right away. No biggie I thought, I've worked in busy pizza joints in the past, these things happen. Much to my surprise he threw in the traditional round pie for free, even after I offered to pay for it. A+ service, this place went above and beyond fixing an honest mistake.

So how was the pizza? I now had a sampler of round traditional cheese, square Sicilian cheese and an order of garlic knots to dig into. It's excellent, the sauce has a nice flavor and the mozzarella tastes freshly grated and there's a healthy amount of seasoning on top as well. The crust of the Sicilian is perfect, substantial but not too thick as to be overly filling. The round pie had a nice greasy flavor, almost boardwalk style. The garlic knots have a flawless fluffy texture and just the right amount of garlic.

So if you're in the eastern Lancaster or Lampeter area definitely give Pie in the Sky a call, especially if you want a Sicilian style pizza, far as I know they're the only place in the area with it. Great service and awesome pizza!“

“Wonderful food, fast service and our server was great too. We dined outside and it started to rain a little and she offered us to come inside. We declined and she quickly got us boxes and our checks. The girl at the gelato- not pleasant at all. I sampled two, decided on 1 and then she says to me “the blue mat is down by the bar”. ?? I replied, what am I supposed to do with that. Apparently that is where you now pay for gelato which is not where I paid when I was there 3 months ago. She was rude to previous customer too.“

“Cute little place! Great atmosphere“

“Many times when we travel we choose chain restaurants as we know the quality of the food will be good and the service generally good as well. The Olive Garden stood out because of the staff. The gentleman who seated us was so friendly and nice I wish i had made note of his name. He did introduce himself, but I did not write down his name, and I can't remember it. Our server, Carly, was very friendly and helpful. She was knowledgeable, checked on our progress without being intrusive and made great suggestions that made our dining experience really great.“

“We found our way while riding our motorcycle, glad we did great food.“

“I have eaten here many of times. The food is always so good. I got two pizza's last night and it was really hard to eat because it had a burnt taste to it. I had gotten two pizza's and they both tasted the same. A little disappointing being I have always had great pizza from here. The burnt taste for me was so bad. Felt like I wasted $40 on pizza. I still give 4 stars because of past experiences.“

“Our server, Rebecca, is excellent. She pays attention to our order and makes sure it is done as requested. The food is very tasty and the restaurant is very nice“

“Usually very good but totally screwed up my order last night and this morning the guy on the phone told me "maybe" they could give me 10% off my next pizza. Threw it out, total waste of money. �“

“I just love this place for any italian food. Been going there a long time. I live close by. The food is always good and the staff is always so nice. Thanks Frank and the staff.“

“the food portion the waitress was nice and friendly“

“Absolutely the best subs snd pizza for 30+years!“

“LOVE Picasso's! Feel lucky to have found this place. EVERTHING IS GREAT!!!! Pricey but well worth it! Thanks to ALL of you that delivery with a smile!“

“Food was absolutely delicious. Staff extremely friendly. Thanks for everything. I’ll be back with the family“

“This is the best hoagie restaurant in the world! I fly in from CA just to eat hoagies from this Caruso's. The staff is wonderful, the food is delicious, and it's worth becoming a regular customer. Thank you to the owner and Caruso's in Silver Springs for setting the bar high!“

“I have never been a fan of the Olive Garden, but friends who were visiting wanted to go there to eat dinner. I was pleasantly surprised!! We visited the Lancaster Olive Garden near the Park City Mall. Our server, Mallory, couldn't have been more attentive. The people we dined with were very demanding but Mallory took it all in stride and accommodated all of their requests. She also made the best salad I've ever had at Olive Garden - yes, your server prepares the salads. Our food was delicious, fresh and served hot. Tonight's experience has really changed my mind about Olive Garden and I will definitely return!!“

“Pizza and pasta dinners are the best around!!!!!! Owners are awesome too!!!!“

“Love this family owned restaurant!!“

“I just enjoyed the BEST white pizza 🍕 that I have had in a very long time!!! I will definitely be back for more 😊“

“the best pizza in Lancaster, I recommend Italian cheesesteak pizza and fajita pizza. also lamb over rice and chicken over rice amazing ...“

“Wonderful experience friendly staff“

“Had friends in from Va. and they asked for pizza. The service was terrific. The crust is amazing. We had the spinach, arugula, onion white pizza. It was delicious that evening and the leftover slice just as good, cold, the next day! Thanks Rendezvous. You did not disappoint.“

“Best restaurant in the inside and outside great food, I had a 10/10 experience good food, perfect service and the latin nights are amazing 🤩“

“Luca staff went out of their way to provide my 15 year old son, who is an aspiring chef, with an unforgettable experience. The amazing food and kindness was second to none. Thank you!!“