26 Best Sandwich Shops near Lemoyne

“We love Issac’s, but the other night was not so great. However, when we mentioned it to the manager, he was quick to remedy the situation. Just another reason it will continue to be our “go to” place!! Consistent, friendly, and delicious—“

“Just had 38 McAlisters sandwich boxes delivered to our family reunion. They arrived on time, fresh, order filled perfectly. Everyone loved the ham or the garden Turkey sandwiches. Fruit cups and cookies were a special hit with the kids and every pickle was eaten! I highly recommend McAllisters!“

“LOVE this extra-special touch shown in this pic!!! Thank you! I ordered on the app to pick up in-store and it was ready on time plus, I was greeted when I went in and the BBQ sub was delicious! Great store with wonderful employees! Love the Grayson Rd Jersey Mike’s!!“

“First time visiting. It is an old school sandwich shop. I appreciate that,.food was fresh and from what I could tell, everything is made in house. Had a 8in, turkey and provolone. Food was fresh, best provolone I've had at any sandwich shop. The staff was steadily working, However, The employee at the counter was more concerned with watching football than taking orders, but he eventually got around to helping customers. Food is reasonably priced especially compared to the chain shops. I would definitely recommend this place. But get extra meat, my sandwich was a little light, but overall really delicious.“

“Yes , it’s good - no question! Great atmosphere, great service . So far tried fish loved it , salmon cheesesteak great, but these tacos i bought today 😮‍💨 , gotta get the panda sauce on those .f Taco Bell I was disappointed when I went there last time any way …. #RapidSandwhiches And They Gone Correct“

“The subs here are always perfect. Today I had a coworker pick up a tuna sub for me and it was the absolute best tuns sub i have ever had in my 39 years. To the person that made the mini tuna sub on 11/5/2025 at around 2pm, May you find a bunch of money on the ground, may your pillow stay cool and fluffy and your coffee or tea be sprinkled with magic!“

“Fast & friendly service, delicious subs!“

“the food was fresh, delicious and the beer was awesome!“

“Had a great experience at this store! We needed a to go order for the whole CV ice hockey team 20hungry teenage boys plus coaches for a bus trip. The amazing staff worked with us for an easy solution to let all the boys order and pay for their own subs online and I picked them up to deliver to the bus. The process was smooth and quick. When I went to pick them up they had them all sorted and individually labeled with names and put in a box for easy transportation. The staff was extremely friendly and they even carried the box to my car for me! If you ever need to order for a group or sports team I highly recommend using this store! Oh and the subs received rave reviews from the boys! So they tasted great too! Thank you for great customer service and we will definitely order from your store the next time we need to feed the team!“

“We ordered the hot turkey meal and hot turkey sandwich last month, and both were exceptional! The food delivery was on time, and the food was still hot! Can't wait to place our food delivery order again soon.“

“Simply Turkey is phenomenal in every way possible. Not only is their food phenomenal, but so is the staff. Recently I had their baked potato soup and it was AMAZING. I had been watching the soup specials for it again for two weeks when I decided to send an email to the Ft St location. TWO days later, I got an email AND phone call to let me know they had made the soup. That kind of customer service is unbelievably hard to find these days and I was floored that they would even consider making it, let alone that they actually did. I am just baffled and absolutely thrilled that they would listen and take action like that. Service this good is rare and when coupled with delicious food, it deserves to be recognized.“

“Friendly staff, reasonable price and good food.“

“I've loved this place see they first opened. Their freshly made po boy bread is wonderful, and the rest of the menu is to die for“

“Was in the mood for a hot dog and enjoyed it till I walked back out to my car and got mugged by two guys from behind.“

“I realy recommend this Resturant the best food ever 😍😍😍“

“Everything is so good. Every time I walk in there, they are always ready to greet me with a smile on their face and a joke lol. I always get to go food but, I can’t wait to sit down and eat in. I never tried their Mexican side. That’s next on my list, but the Stromboli, cheese steaks, wings, pizza is delicious.“

“Yummy , the best subs around .“

“Hi everyone! I’m the manager of this location and have had some reviews under our location that have to do with the summerdale plaza location. I’ve tried to comment but couldn’t figure it out. Please make sure before you are writing a review you have the correct location. We are the subway beside the planet fitness. And to anyone who has had any issues with any of my employees I do apologize and we do not condone this. Our goal is to provide great quality food and amazing customer service with a friendly atmosphere. I will continue to work with my team and I encourage you all to come out and give us a shot! Thank you!“

“The staff was friendly, the restaurant was clean, and my sandwich was made exactly how I wanted it. The ingredients were fresh, and the service was quick, even during the lunch rush. I love how customizable the menu is—there’s something for everyone. I’ll definitely be coming back for more delicious, made-to-order meals!“

“The order was for 75 3 inch subs for a special project. Order took a little longer but only saw 2 people working Order. I felt there was not enough lettuce/tomato/onion on the side of which they reluctantly gave us more, but they gave me just enough for the 75 subs. We ordered ham & cheese/Italian and 2 other types of subs. They did a great job even with the small issues we thought needed. They were correct in what they gave us. Thank you for your making our project a success. ALTRUSA“

“Note: For Fast Food reviews, my rating is based primarily off of order accuracy, staff friendliness, and location cleanliness. This is because most locations in a chain have the same food. Don't worry, exceptionally bad or good food will be noted in the review.This Subway is clean and the staff is very friendly. The staff remembers your usual order if you've been there a few times. Basically, this is as good as a Subway can get.“

“We were disappointed during a recent visit. We ordered subs online an hour and a half a head of the pickup time. I got there at the pickup time and subs hadn’t been started. When the employee started making the subs, she stopped and told me the toaster was broken. I asked if she could refund the charge so I could go somewhere else. She evaded the question and said she could warm the sub in the microwave.

I understand refunding an online payment may be impossible. There should be a way to offer the customer a voucher for a future discount. The employee was very polite and apologized, but I’m not sure I’ll visit this location again. I definitely won’t order online from this location again.“

“My order was received at 2:19 and delivered (5 minutes away) at 2:31. That is quick service! We tried the 9-grain rolls and will get them again.“

“Subway helped take down the local mom and pop sup shops with inferior sandwiches that they sold at a low price. Sure it's a nice sup but not enough meat and cheese to bun. Also they don't cook cheese steak hot and fresh. They rewarm the meat and melt your cheese.Now that the mom and pop shops are gone they've raised there prices with the same inferior sups .What can we do to get a good local sup shop?“

“Wow. I didn't think I'd ever be writing a review for Jimmy John's of all places, but I received some of the best customer service by a nice teen named Max. I wasn't sure what to order, and Max recommended me the #9 (delicious btw) and was super friendly during my whole experience. We had a nice chat and he truly just seems like a genuine guy who loves his job. Don't know how much they make but he definitely needs a raise. Will be back just to see Max again.“