49 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Alexandria

“Everyone has their own taste and mine loves this pizza. It's a sweeter sauce that has a nice balance. The cheese is nice and melty, not greasy. The crust has a solid taste, teetering on bagel and fresh baked bread. The sausage isn't overpowered with spice. It's really a treat. Plus the setting if you dine in...it's like pulling up to a spot outside of Mayberry. Well kept place, definitely gives you a feeling. I'm sure the service is 5 stars, I've just always taken out.“

“Not only does Fox's Pizza-New Alexandria have great Pizza, Candie and the rest of the staff are the nicest people! They support The New Alexandria Senior Center every single week with Pizza for our Monday Bingo. Thank you so much, it is greatly appreciated. ❤“

“We grabbed some pizza today for our staff…they pretty much licked the boxes clean! It’s definitely the best pizza in the area!!!“

“10 out of 10! They have lots of vegan options! They have melty vegan cheese and vegan pepperoni! Plus select vegan desserts! There is a bar as well 🍻 We had the stramboli with vegan cheese, it comes with a choice of 3 toppings and we chose, of course the vegan pepperoni, then artichoke and fire roasted tomatoes 🤤 Wow this was good! Served with red sauce. Then for dessert we had the vegan SunButter chocolate chip. On top of the great food and drinks, we had a lovely vegan waitress 💚“

“Just had their pizza today for the first time tried 3 different ones and each one was very very good.. will definitely order again and try different pizzas“

“5 Stars – A Hidden Gem! Bubba’s Pierogies is a fantastic local spot that absolutely deserves your support. Everything is scratch-made and you can truly taste the difference—these pierogies are packed with flavor. David is super friendly, incredibly knowledgeable, and clearly passionate about what he does. From the moment you walk in, you feel welcomed. All around, it’s a great local restaurant with quality food and even better people behind it. Highly recommend!“

“Never had a bad experience. The food is always great and consistent!! One of our favorite go to places. Great people running it.“

“From start to finish, Mylee and her team was wonderful to work with! She paid close attention to every detail and was extremely helpful and organized, which made the day run so smoothly. The food was absolutely amazing, delicious, beautifully presented, and a huge hit with our guests. Our guests are still raving over the food! We would recommend Thirty’s without hesitation!!“

“Mondays has always been a favorite of mine! The food has always been great! The staff has always been so friendly. But this week!!!! Let’s talk about it! This week we had to throw together a quick birthday dinner for my daughter, we were running out of options, mondays got back to us with in less than 5 HOURS to get their place set up, and ready for us, our party of 20 arrived and they were so welcoming, open to our suggestions and helped us save a lot of money😂 the staff was on top of it, the food, drinks, service, their smiling faces, everything turned out perfect for us!“

“we love the sugar shack. they have really good gobs, cookies, pizza and perogies. The lent fish meal is great too“

“Super nice people and great pizza! Their white pizza is excellent.

Their website is tough to navigate, that’s the only thing they could improve. When you go to the website it says “See Our Menu” and nothing comes up. Posting a copy of their menu with this review because they are definitely worth a try!“

“FANTASTIC food!!!! The pizza is thin crust, sauce is amazing with toppings all the way to the edge, you don’t often see that. The atmosphere is casual, comfortable and inviting. The service was great, thank you Nadine. Hats off to Mike the owner and his team. The pepperoni pizza is the absolute best I have ever had. This was my very first visit and it certainly will not be my last.

Parking: Plenty of parking available.“

“ABSOLUTELY BEST PIZZA IN TOWN“

“We live out of town but had this pizza several times over the past few years, when in the area visiting family. The pizza is really good (not greasy or too spicy) but we forgot how big the pies are, so make sure you know how many slices you need when you place the order. This was our first time calling for delivery. We were disappointed that they did not honor a Seton Hill student discount that my sister who placed the order had. They also forgot part of our order but promptly came back after we called them. I'd definitely go back here again...not sure if my sister will.“

“Great pizza, Great service!“

“Best pizza around!The employees are always pleasant and aim to please.My family is going to definitely be a repeat customer!“

“Haven't been here yet but given the circumstances probably one of the best pizza joints in Pennsylvania!

48 hours later I find myself editing this review to let you all know, it is indeed bomb diggity good pizza! We got some yesterday. Your turn 👊🏼✊🏼🤙🏼👍🏼💯“

“It’s all good. Try the breakfast pizza.“

“Best wings & pizza in the area! The pizza is always consistent & cooked perfectly every time and the owner and staff are always tentative and friendly! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“What an amazing place with an amazing Steph! We greatly appreciate the staff and the heart that they have to support local rescues! God bless you guys ! 🙏“

“Best pizza ever !! I’m out of the area now & this is still my favorite place !!“

“We love this place! Highly recommend to everyone to come and checkout!“

“Love the food every time i go, great draft list“

“Best pizza I've ever had. Fabulous crust and sauce. It's an hour away for me but I'll be going back often. It's that good!!!!!“

“Cut from a freshly made dough, hand thrown to perfection and tossed with just the proper amount of toppings to create the Biggest Slice In Town. A pie definitely worth a second visit, perfect for a family meal, a gathering of friends or just a fresh slice of pie to enjoy and wind down with after a long day at the office.“

“I have 5 stars by default because I feel like 1 star would hurt the reputation..

I haven’t tried the food yet but am writing the review to make everyone aware that they do not deliver. I just moved to the area and looked up local pizza shops that deliver and their website advertises delivery. After looking over the menu and getting my heart set on what I wanted, I called to place my order and they told me they did not deliver. 💔“

“What should have been a great family experience turned out to be a headache-- not a regular headache, but more like a migraine. There were so many issues that I'm not sure where to begin-- the online menu is not the menu presented to us, the waitress had to get simple answers from others (which shows the lack of training). When the waitress asked who ordered the 1 meal, we told her that 2 people ordered that item. About 10 mins later, we questioned when that item would be out and realized that she never put it through, so 1 family member had table scraps for a meal. The seats are ok for comfortability, which is good because we had waited approximately 90+ mins to receive our food. Pizzas were flying out the door, while my young children waited the 90+ mins for their's to land on our table. We waited for our bills-- then waited again because the waitress had to be reminded to take money off the appetizers due to happy hour. Then waited awhile for our bank card... and again to get pens. If you have 2- 3 hours to spare, then this place is a gem, but you're better off going to see a movie then getting dinner elsewhere since it would take the same amount of time 🤷‍♀️“

“Super quick delivery. Very nice delivery driver! Food was great!“

“My first time having lunch at Lucky B's and it won't be the last. My friends and I had the white bean chile and it was awesome. Our waitress was the best. I think her name was Manda..“

“Pizza was amazing. Fun time“

“I consider Pizza Sienna to be very good-better than any national chain pizza shop. I am a fan of simple pizza, but the Sienna Pie is my favorite! It is loaded with just the right toppings. Pizzas have a nice crust, ample cheese, sauce, and toppings, and a good blend of flavors!“

“Our experience wasn't with the restaurant itself, as we didn't actually eat there. But we were lost on the way to a burial service, when we stopped in for directions. Both the ladies working there were so kind, and they helped us get where we needed to be on time! We just wanted to say thank you. ☺️“

“Awesome pizza and a fantastic meatball sub!
We came her on our way out of Pittsburgh. Despite it being a cold and snowy night and the staff was cheerful and prompt. We'll definitely hit Fox's when we pass through town again.“

“I was at a birthday party last night the server was awesome and food was great!“

“We have been going here for 20+years. The food is always good and the owners are always polite.Never had a bad experience. Dave and Michelle are wonderful people and so are the staff. The Italian hoagies are the best but all the food is very good .“

“The lady that was working 8-31-24 did an amazing job. I deliver for doordash and they had a issue with the computer system earlier in the day. She got it resolved as quickly as she could. Then she got slammed with orders while working alone. In my opinion she handled it very well and quickly.“

“My favorite pasta sauce. Everyone should come here!“

“Good food, excellent people, and extremely fast delivery. Would definitely recommend!“

“the pizza is the best I totally recommend it“

“This was our first time at Olives and Peppers. We had an awesome server, Jennifer F. The food was excellent as well as the service. The meals could not have been any better and the servings were huge. Loved everything about it. We will definitely be back.“

“The portions are huge and reasonably priced. Our server Becky was very knowledgeable and pleasant. You have to try the fish sandwich, ordered for takeout and made 2 meals of it! Have visited many times and definitely have never left there hungry.“

“Great food and atmosphere! Closes to early and the service is terrible“

“Everything was really good and fresh“

“I have been to Sharky twice. I love it there. Their pizza and wings are phenomenal. The staff is incredible and super friendly. I definitely recommend coming here.“

“They don't answer the phone. I tried calling this pizza hut and let it ring 8 times. No one answered. I called during open hours. Great pizza, but if you order there's no way to contact this pizza hut to change or cancel your order.“

“Always great to order out from here using Uber eats. Fair warning though the more you order the more delivery fees increase. Keep it under 2 pizzas for an actual deal anything above that and you'll be paying an arm and a leg in delivery costs. Unless you're an Uber paying member.“

“The Italian food was very good. I had the squash ravioli with brown butter sauce, and the flavor was unique to me. My boyfriend enjoyed the grilled chicken Parmesan over pasta. The entrees and soup needed more seasoning. The atmosphere is cheerful with glass chandeliers and flowers. It’s a great place to eat when departing or returning from Myrtle Beach. Parking is still free and the restaurant is ADA ACCESSIBLE“

“I have never had a pizza this good it was delicious it was my first pizza and absolutely not my last service was great as well trinitys enthusiasm was amazing added to my experience“

“I had a steak and cheese sub looked at it ... Where the beef no meat at all this was in latrobe and ordered a large pizza pepperoni mushrooms and banaña peppers. Hardly any toppings at all 31 dollars. Never again.“