13 Best Ice Cream Shops near New Brighton

1 Treasure Box Nutrition & Treats

5.0 Superb 13 Reviews

904 3rd Ave, New Brighton

• Take-Out

“I just picked up one of the best sandwiches I ever had today. Turkey and bacon with pepper jack on delicious herbed focaccia bread! So good!♥️”

2 Blackbird Market

4.9 Superb 62 Reviews

601 3rd St, Beaver · 2.45 miles

• Delivery

“Awesome place and people. Great for celiacs, gluten free, dairy free. Excellent ice cream. Friendly and clean!”

3 Judy's Jimmies

4.8 Superb 72 Reviews

822 Darlington Rd Suite 3, Beaver Falls · 1.84 miles

“Amazing ice cream! This was our first time at Judy’s Jimmies and it won’t be our last! There are so many choices…it’s going to take us a while to work our way down the menu before we choose our favorite flavor!”

4 Witch Flavor?

4.7 Superb 70 Reviews

588 3rd St, Beaver · 2.41 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“This is simply a great small town ice cream shop. The owner clearly puts a lot of care and love into it, both the ice cream and the shop itself.”

5 Bruster's Real Ice Cream

4.5 Superb 111 Reviews

1525 Riverside Dr, Beaver · 1.32 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“My favorites are Chocolate and White Turtle in a waffle cone”

6 Katie's Korner of North Sewickley Township

4.4 Superb 75 Reviews

801 Mercer Rd, Beaver Falls · 4.3 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Stopped and got a banana split. The bananas were over ripe and brown. The help saw it and did nothing. Very Bad. Does not recommend.”

7 Dairy Queen

4.3 Superb 22 Reviews

1152 Midland Ave, Midland · 9.96 miles

“The workers at this DQ/Subway location are wonderful. They are kind and helpful. The food is good, and many choices, the price well inflation has hit everyone. It's great having a sandwich shop with an ice cream shop all in one place. It's nice having this location, since there are not others close around.”

8 Ellwood Ice

5.0 Superb 119 Reviews

504 Lawrence Ave, Ellwood City · 8.94 miles

• Take-Out

“The dole whip is my favorite but I honestly love everything their I’ve never been disappointed with anything I’ve gotten”

9 Katie's Korner Chippewa

4.0 Good 62 Reviews

600 Chippewa Town Center, Beaver Falls · 5.1 miles

• Delivery

“Stopped and got a banana split. The bananas were over ripe and brown. The help saw it and did nothing. Very Bad. Does not recommend.”

10 Center Cut Deli

5.0 Superb 43 Reviews

3403 Brodhead Rd, Aliquippa · 5.77 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great sandwich and soup for lunch! My new "go-to"”

11 JD's Popcorn

4.8 Superb 19 Reviews

1890 Conway Wallrose Rd, Freedom · 7.05 miles

“Yummy place with delicious treats for your sweet tooth. ~ Service is fast and friendly. Icecream is very good, as well as the various popcorns. They also sell some really cool homemade crafts too. Recommend if you want to treat yourself right. Kid-friendliness: Always good to give your kids a little treat here.”

12 Dairy Queen (Treat)

3.4 Good 72 Reviews

2625 Brodhead Rd, Aliquippa · 8.98 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“Missy does such an amazing job creating unique cakes for special occasions. Even the ones she had in the freezer open to purchase were decorated so beautifully! Appreciate the time and effort she puts into them and the service she gives with a smile! Thanks again, Missy!”

13 Dairy Queen Grill & Chill

3.7 Good 54 Reviews

449 Adams St, Rochester · 2.44 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I want to just say thank you so much! I ordered a custom ice cream cake for my husbands birthday because it's his favorite but my daughter has never been able to eat one because she has a peanut allergy. I mentioned that in my ordering notes and they made the cake fresh and cleaned everything before they made it!! You have made my daughters day!! Thank you for taking that extra step! It is truly appreciated..more than you know!!!”