37 Best Ice Cream Shops near Wexford

“We love everything about Graeter’s. The people, the yummy ice cream, the people, the tables inside and out and the people.“

“Best Rita’s service around! ❤️“

“Our new ice cream spot. IMO you can’t even tell the ice cream is vegan - it’s really really good! We had the blue moon and coffee & cookies. Both were delicious.

Dietary restrictions: Perfect for anyone with dairy and/or gluten intolerance.“

“Very great flavors, prices & staff!“

“The ice cream is good, but have you tried their cakes? They are amazing! Best icing and they are absolutely beautiful!“

“Always awesome, they will always be remembered“

“Love the special flavors of soft serve weekly!“

“The custard is great! I get the flavor of the week and I've loved them all. I travel 15 miles to get a cone and stop if I travel close to them. Haven't tried the food. The atmosphere is friendly.“

“Handel’s homemade ice cream is always a good choice! When we found out we would be near McCandless Crossing, we knew we had to stop and bring some home for the entire family! They have a wide variety of flavors that everyone will enjoy. We tried the salty caramel truffle, horchata, mint chocolate chip Handel’s pop, and multiple different pints to bring to family members! We absolutely loved the dipped waffle cones, it was the cherry on top!“

“Good service, delicious ice cream, want to go again and again and again“

“Patient and professional employees & management.
Would like to see them add a better variety of Italian Ice options other than fruity flavors…more taste profiles, including more mixed chocolate options.
Custards and Toppings are great. Parking lot needs better lighting.

Parking: Adequate parking. Lot needs better lighting.“

“We recently visited The Milkshake Factory in Pleasant Grove, and it was an absolutely delightful experience from start to finish. The moment we walked in, we were warmly welcomed by Micah, the owner, who made us feel like family. It was as if he had known us for years! Micah’s hospitality was unmatched. He generously offered us free samples of their incredible chocolate, encouraging us to try as much as we liked. It was such a thoughtful gesture that truly set the tone for our visit. As for the milkshakes, they were out of this world! I indulged in the Bananas Foster Milkshake, which was rich, creamy, and bursting with flavor. My wife couldn’t get enough of her Cookie Brownie Fudge milkshake—it was the perfect blend of decadent flavors. Our kids loved their classic Vanilla Milkshakes, which were smooth and delicious. The attention to detail, quality of ingredients, and exceptional customer service made this visit unforgettable. We can’t wait to return and try more of their amazing offerings. If you’re in Pleasant Grove, do yourself a favor and stop by The Milkshake Factory—you won’t be disappointed!“

“I most certainly do recommend janie’s! Any time I have ever gone down there everyone is patient friendly and professional! I have discovered a new affinity for bubble tea, and I love to take it with me when I have to go to work😊 ☀️Great prices! ☀️Excellent ice cream! ☀️Amazing selection and really sweet employees“

“Love love the frozen custard. Great flavors and super people who work there. I’m a regular!“

“I admit that this visit was marred due to an absolute melt down by my 3 year old after having some of his large cone scooped into a dish (apologies to anyone who had to partake in that). But beyond that, this is a cool little soft serve stand with some really enjoyable options and that feel you only get from a small ice cream operation on a warm summer night.

I tries the heralded raspberry soft serve, and found it truly something special, with the tartness of the raspberry mixing with sweet vanilla to be a very nice combo. My daughter got a rainbow cone and was very happy, and the couple normal bites my son had of his chocolate choice were nice. With nice cashiers and very fair prices for the area, it's definitely worth a go if in the area on any hot day or evening.“

“This Bruster's is far better than any other ice cream shop in the area. It was "Every Given Sunday" but after Covid, they closed permanently. This place has excellent mango sorbet and Chocolate ice cream shakes and pint size. Friendly. Helpful and the ice cream tops every place I've been too. Cool Cones is awful and can't compare!“

“Hands down the best ice cream in the state. Always a large variety of flavor options and staff willing to answer any questions about the product. The best flavors are the cheesecake ones, no question!
The freshly made waffle cones always add a nice crunch and subtle vanilla flavor to every bite and pairs well with every flavor.
Don't forget to grab a pint, quart, or half-gallon to bring home to share (and of course have real ice cream on hand at all times).

Dietary restrictions: Plenty of options for those who want a nice dairy free or nut free treat.

Parking: Very rarely an issue to find parking, unless of course it's 90°F on a weekend evening, then the walk from your car may increase to 2 minutes from 30 seconds.

Kid-friendliness: Super fun staff and grassy seating area nearby.“

“I love the chocolate raspberry truffle, cherry vanilla & butter pecan.“

“Great view of the river and so close to the zoo! Only soft serve ice cream, milkshakes, and other ice cream options at the moment. The ice cream is really good though! No food like burgers or hot dogs at the time of writing this. Clean tables and good customer service. Good portions for price.

Vegetarian options: All ice cream here is vegetarian.

Dietary restrictions: Vegetarian and gluten free options.

Parking: Free parking lot with around 15 spots.

Kid-friendliness: Kids would like their ice cream

Wheelchair accessibility: Location is wheelchair accessible.“

“Coffee is excellent! Great selection of ice cream and staff is very nice. Highly recommend.“

“I love the creative specials each month and the regular menu has delicious options“

“Quality icecream, couldn't decide between two delicious flavors and Maddy was nice enough to suggest splitting a scoop, so I could enjoy both, will definitely go back.

Dietary restrictions: There is dairy free, gluten free options.

Kid-friendliness: Very patient with the children ordering.“

“If you ever go to any of their locations please ask for the homemade raspberry soft serve. I have it in a swirl setting on the biggest plastic cup because I enjoy taking my time. The cones may be for a faster eater. No matter if a cup or cone I guarantee you will love my favorite flavor. Have fun and kids love it also.

Parking: Awesome place!!!!!!! Plenty of parking.

Kid-friendliness: Kids are always excited even without their cell phones.“

“Wonderful customer service. Very warm and welcoming. Atmosphere is great and coffee was excellent.“

“My fiancé’s first time!! He’ll be back!“

“Employees were really nice and quick to serve us and let us sample flavors. Ice cream is good as always (highly recommend waffle bowl & double fudge brownie ice cream) and we were able to use a coupon from our rewards account for a good price. Good portions and clean, nice location!“

“Already had rated this location 5 stars but coming back after another great experience. My mom called and asked for two cats on a birthday cake - the woman working let her know she would likely have trouble fitting two cats. My mom asked if they could please try and let me tell you - they did a PHENOMENAL job. Not only did they fit both cats, they just happen to look EXACTLY like my cats. They also did this without seeing a picture of them. We were over the moon, my mom said she almost got teary eyed LOL. Absolutely get your ice cream cake here! AmazIng job!!“

“Cornhole golf is one of the funnest things I’ve ever done. My friends and I had an absolute blast.“

“Great quality drinks, syrups and products AND EVEN BETTER are the people! We absolutely love this spot ♥️“

“I stopped into SIMPLE SUBS today. I CHOSE A CHEESESTEAK SUB. IT WAS DELICIOUS. IF YOU HAVE NEVER STOPPED IN YOU SHOULD TRY IT OUT CUZ IT'S GREAT.“

“Great cookies!“

“I absolutely love the Dairy Queen on Rt 65 Bellevue. They have the kindest people working there. They've helped me when they didn't have to, but kind enough to. It's always a pleasure visiting, and I love the reward points.

Dietary restrictions: My son loves to order for us, pay, and scan the receipt. They are so patient!

Parking: They have a drive-through that works perfectly with parking. You can always find parking.

Kid-friendliness: The customer service is amazing, patient, and kind.

Wheelchair accessibility: My Dairy Queen has a 2-way wheelchair accessibility.“

“Best pumpkin spice latte! Food is amazing. Best Cafe!!“

“It works for the area. Prices are a bit high, especially for the do it yourself concept and only seemingly one employee working to finish orders, but it's not unexpected for the area and in the current economy.

The cake batter frozen yogurt I shared with my wife was good, and my kids enjoyed their choices, especially the amount of mix ins they could add in.“

“Such a cute store! Always super clean! Workers arent always the friendliest however!
Cookies are great! Sometimes they are out of some which is a bummer but overall great place!

Kid-friendliness: super great family atmosphere!“

“We had a wonderful time this morning having coffee and visiting together. Generoasta reserved a spot for us and we were very well served! Greater Harmony Chorus loves supporting our local businesses and getting to hang out together in the process! Thank you!“

“I was very impressed this evening. My son has a severe peanut allergy. He often can’t eat the same desserts the rest of us eat due to the possibility of cross contamination at a lot of establishments. He ordered a blizzard this evening, and an employee thoroughly sanitized the machines used in making his blizzard before she made it. Dairy Queen could have just said they couldn’t guarantee there was no cross contamination, but instead they took the time and care to make sure my son could safely eat there, which was greatly appreciated. The staff is always kind. They work as quickly as possible. The ice cream and food are delicious. Thank you Dairy Queen!“