7 Best Italian Restaurants in New Castle

“We stumbled upon this place on day. We have driven past it for years never really thinking of it... Finally stopped a month ago. Loved it!!! Went back 4 times over the next 3 weeks. Last night we ordered 3 Togo spaghetti meals for our friends whom just lost a mother and brother both tragically. We took them dinner and did lots of help for them and stopped AGAIN on way for 2 more spaghetti dinners for us too. Such good food and amazing low prices. I'm telling you all meals here are at least $5 less than most Italian restaurants. Fast service. Owner comes a greets you asks how your doing and how the food was. Great place and people. If you haven't been there, go there! If you have, go again soon! They also have Pizza and Wings buffet on Thursdays nights. and daily lunch pizza pasta and soup buffet too. 💜“

“The Ladies of the Dukes is the best Italian restaurant in New Castle. I can't say enough good things about it. Reservations are highly recommended. Prices are very budget friendly. Waiters, waitresses, and greeters are all cordial and helpful. Very pleasant place to enjoy your Sunday dinner. And I highly recommend the spaghetti and tiramisu!“

“We always have a great meal & dessert at Soni’s! Love their red sauce - my favorite dinner is the Italian Platter! We had Brian as our server tonight- he is fantastic- he always has a great demeanor!!!“

“I came here for my Granddaughtes birthday. My husband was a chef for a hotel in Pittsburgh so I eat good food. Well I loved the food here. The servers were great too. I recommend this place to everyone. Thank you I will be back.“

“Mark was a great server… food was amazing! Great dinner with mom on a Friday!!“

“Mr. Pizza An absolute Awesome gem in New Castle Pa for years, we are absolutely blessed with the best! New York style since 1972 came from Brooklyn NY where it started in 1953, it's just like being in New York and having the Real deal NY slice , the absolute Best! ????“

“Take out was about an hour wait, but worth it. The red sauce is great and they put a lot on the pizza. We got a poor man's pizza which is good. I like their red sauce better. I normally like hot wings, but food in New Castle can be HOT! Thank goodness we ordered the mild - they had just the right kick! Next timw I will dine in.

Vegetarian options: You can get any type of veggies on pizzas and salads. If you have acid issues from tomatoes, the poor man might be for you.“