8 Best Italian Restaurants in New Castle

The Ladies of the Dukes Italian • $
1114 N Croton Ave, New Castle

Customers` Favorites

Frozen Cavatelli or Homemade Spaghetti
Chicken Tenders and French Fries
Homemade Spaghetti and Meatballs
Ravioli Cavatelli and Meatballs
Spumoni Ice Cream
Eggplant Parmesan
Chicken Parmesan
Homemade Platter
Tiramisu

“They're ravioli and sauce is my absolute favorite. Would definitely recommend ordering ahead but they're curbside for pick up orders is still very easy and relatively quick. And the best part is you don't even have to get out of your car“

4.5 Superb79 Reviews
Gallo's Italian Villa Italian • $
2420 Wilmington Rd, New Castle

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Tortellini Alfredo
Homestyle Wedding Soup
Stuffed Hot Peppers
Homemade Spaghetti
Fettuccine Alfredo
Eggplant Parmesan
Chicken Parmesan
Chicken Parm
Cheese Pizza
Garlic Bread

“I went here for dinner and was immediately greeted by the owner himself. He welcomed us with open arms and recommended his favorite dishes. It has a warm atmosphere and the food is great. I enjoy going here for a meal on any occasion.“

4.3 Superb131 Reviews
Soni's Italian Restaurant Italian • $
3209 Wilmington Rd, New Castle

Customers` Favorites

Fettuccine Alfredo Dine in: Yes Outdoor seating: No Takeout: Yes
Chicken Salad Fried or Grilled
Buffalo Chicken Roll Up
Chocolate Cream Pie
Pittsburgh Sandwich
Eggplant Parmesan
Coconut Cream Pie
Italian Flatbread
Bread Bowl Pasta
Strawberry Salad

“We always have a great meal & dessert at Soni’s! Love their red sauce - my favorite dinner is the Italian Platter! We had Brian as our server tonight- he is fantastic- he always has a great demeanor!!!“

4.2 Good156 Reviews
Pagley's Pasta & More Italian • $
1235 E Washington St, New Castle

Customers` Favorites

Portobello Mushroom Steak Sandwich
Homemade Ravioli and Meatballs
Chicken Parmigiana with Penne
Beans and Greens w Sausage
Spaghetti with Meatball
Homemade Cheese Ravioli
Pizza with Extra Cheese
Fried Calamari Rings
Chicken Pastine Soup
Fettuccine Alfredo

“Mark was a great server… food was amazing! Great dinner with mom on a Friday!!“

4 Good113 Reviews
Four Pizzeria Bar and Grill Italian • $
2409 Wilmington Rd, New Castle

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Marsala over Linguine
Crispy Chicken Wedge Salad
New York Style Cheesecake
Romano Chicken Sandwich
Meatballs and Peppers
Italian Wedding Soup
Meatballs & Ricotta
Chicken Parmigiano
Mozzarella Fritti
Chicken Vincenzo

“I came here for my Granddaughtes birthday. My husband was a chef for a hotel in Pittsburgh so I eat good food. Well I loved the food here. The servers were great too. I recommend this place to everyone. Thank you I will be back.“

4 Good99 Reviews
Mr Pizza Italian • $
1204 E Washington St, New Castle

Customers` Favorites

Double Slice of Pepperoni Pizza
Wedding Soup and Pizza Greens
Chicken Pastine with Egg Soup
Tues 2 Slices of Pizza
Meatball with Cheese
Fresh Tomato Pizza
Pepperoni & Cheese
Pizza by the Slice
Meat Lovers Pizza
Anti Pasta Salad

“Mr. Pizza in New Castle PA has got a great location, a drive through, and New York and Sicilian thick square style. They are both great, never had an issue.

All I ever get at Mr. Pizza is, the pizza. That's because they have the hands down best sauce in the area. I'm from Youngstown area, so like a chewy crust with a good sauce with some flavor.

Mr. Pizza doesn't have a thick crust round, but I get the anchovy (this picture of two slices is double anchovy) and sauce and I don't mind the thin crust at all.

Seriously, they have really good pizza. I take mine home to crisp it up and burn the cheese some, but that's it. This pie is just flat good.“

3.9 Good128 Reviews
Mangino’s Pizzeria Pizza • $
2710 Wilmington Rd, New Castle

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Salad with Balsamic Dressing
Pepperoni Rolls and Wedding Soup
Tomato Pizza and Garden Salad
Sliced Tomato Pizza Slice
Italian Supreme Sandwich
Mixed Vegetable Pizza
Philly Steak Sandwich
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Meatball Stuffed Loaf
Meatball Dugout Loaf

“Take out was about an hour wait, but worth it. The red sauce is great and they put a lot on the pizza. We got a poor man's pizza which is good. I like their red sauce better. I normally like hot wings, but food in New Castle can be HOT! Thank goodness we ordered the mild - they had just the right kick! Next timw I will dine in.

Vegetarian options: You can get any type of veggies on pizzas and salads. If you have acid issues from tomatoes, the poor man might be for you.“

4.4 Superb108 Reviews
Chuck Tanners Restaurant Family • $
2305 Wilmington Rd, New Castle

Customers` Favorites

Stuffed Bonless Pork Chop with Mashed Potatoes and Gravy
Meatloaf and Mashed Potatoes and Gravy
Stuffed Omelette
Chicken Parmesan
Wedding Soup
Home Fries
Steak

“A wonderful homestyle restaurant. Delicious, reasonably priced and generous portions. Friendly staff, too! This will definitely be on our list to visit more often!“

4.4 Superb81 Reviews

Find More Tastes In New Castle

You May Also Like